Chapter 8 - Contribution & Subrogation Flashcards
8 - Contribution & Subrogation
- When does contribution apply?
When more than one policy covers the same loss or liability.
8 - Contribution & Subrogation
- When does subrogation apply?
When the loss is caused by a third party.
A - Contribution
- Provided there is no fraudulent intent, can the insured take out as many insurance policies as they wish?
Yes, however they can only recover the total amount of the loss sustained.
A - Contribution
A1 Contribution Condition
- Does contribution need to be stated in a policy document for it to exist? Why?
No, because it supports the principle of indemnity.
A - Contribution
A1 Contribution Condition
- Is the insured entitled to choose to claim the whole amount from one of the insurers?
Yes, it is the insurers responsibility to then recover appropriate shares from the other insurers.
A - Contribution
A1 Contribution Condition
- What does a Contribution Condition restrict the insurer’s liability to?
It’s rateable proportion or rateable share of loss.
A - Contribution
A3 How Contribution arises
- Under common law, what conditions must be satisfied before contribution arises?
Two or more policies exist
The policies cover a common insurable interest
The policies cover a common peril which gives rise to the loss
The policies cover a common subject matter
Each policy must be liable for the loss
Neither policy must contain a non-contribution clause
B - Applying the Contribution Principle
B1 Rateable Proportion
- What is the rateable proportion?
The share of any claim that an insurer pays when two or more insurers cover the same risk.
B - Applying the Contribution Principle
B1 Rateable Proportion
- What are the two ways to determine Rateable Proportion?
By sum insured
By independent liability
B - Applying the Contribution Principle
B1A By Sum Insured
- How is the rateable proportion of a loss calculated by sum insured?
Policy sum insured / Total sum of all policies x Loss
B - Applying the Contribution Principle
B1A By Sum Insured
- What type of situation is the by sum insured method used in?
Property policies not subject to average.
B - Applying the Contribution Principle
B1B By Independent Liability
- How does the by independent liability method calculate the amount payable?
Calculates the amount payable under each policy as if no other policy existed. The loss is then shared in proportion to the independent liabilities of the two policies.
Policy Sum Insured / Total Value at Risk x Loss
B - Applying the Contribution Principle
B1B By Independent Liability
- When is the method of by independent liability used?
Where property policies are subject to average
Where an individual loss limit applies with a sum insured
B - Applying the Contribution Principle
B2A Non-Contribution clauses
- How does a non-contribution clause modify a policy?
Means the policy would not contribute if there was another insurance policy in force.
B - Applying the Contribution Principle
B1B By Independent Liability
- Can Non-Contribution clauses be cancelled out?
Yes, if both policies have them non-contribution clauses they cancel each other out.