Chapter 8 Flashcards
Depersonalization/derealization
disorder
Experience of detachment from the self and reality
Dissociative amnesia
Lack of conscious access to memory, typically of a
stressful experience. The fugue subtype involves traveling
or wandering coupled with loss of memory of one’s
identity or past.
Dissociative identity disorder
At least two distinct personality states that act independently of each other
The core feature of each dissociative disorder, involves …
some aspect of emotion, memory or experience being inaccessible consciously
What distinguishes common dissociative experiences from dissociative disorders, and what are the main types of dissociative disorders?
Common dissociation (e.g., zoning out while studying or driving) is harmless and brief. In contrast, dissociative disorders involve more severe disruptions in consciousness or identity. Types include:
Depersonalization/Derealization Disorder: feeling detached from self or surroundings, like being in a dream.
Dissociative Amnesia: inability to recall important personal information.
Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID): memory gaps so extensive that a unified identity is lost.
What are potential causes of dissociative disorders, and why are they controversial?
Dissociation may be an avoidance response to stress or trauma, supported by links to military stress, mood disorders, sleep problems, and even ketamine use. Trauma may disrupt sleep, which then triggers dissociation. However, controversies remain—some symptoms are so rare they may reflect exaggeration or confusion, and there’s limited consensus on causes or best treatments. Research is ongoing and complex.
What are the key features of depersonalization/derealization disorder, and how is it different from other dissociative disorders?
his disorder involves persistent or recurrent feelings of detachment:
Depersonalization: feeling detached from oneself (e.g., as if observing from outside the body).
Derealization: feeling detached from the environment (e.g., surroundings feel unreal or foggy).
Unlike other dissociative disorders, it does not involve memory disturbances. It often begins in adolescence and may persist for years.
What are common triggers, risk factors, and differential diagnoses for depersonalization/derealization disorder?
Triggers include stress and childhood trauma, and symptoms may arise suddenly or gradually. It’s often comorbid with personality disorders, anxiety, and depression. The disorder must be distinguished from other conditions like schizophrenia, PTSD, borderline personality disorder, and substance intoxication (e.g., marijuana, ketamine). Though fleeting episodes are common (especially in students), diagnosis requires persistence and significant distress.
What are the defining features of dissociative amnesia, and how does the fugue subtype differ?
Dissociative amnesia involves the inability to recall important autobiographical information, usually linked to trauma or stress, and is too extensive to be normal forgetfulness.
Memory loss can last from hours to years and usually resolves suddenly.
Dissociative fugue subtype includes more extensive memory loss, often involving bewildered wandering or even adopting a new identity, home, and lifestyle.
During the episode, procedural memory (skills) is intact, and behavior may appear normal apart from disorientation. After recovery, memory returns, excluding events during the fugue.
What are the leading theories about the causes of dissociative amnesia, and what challenges exist in explaining it?
Psychodynamic theory suggests traumatic memories are repressed to avoid conscious pain.
However, cognitive research finds that trauma usually enhances memory for central features (not suppresses it), often through norepinephrine-driven arousal.
An alternative view proposes extreme stress may impair memory encoding by disrupting attention or flooding the brain with stress hormones.
The condition raises questions about how memory and attention operate under extreme stress, and debate continues about the validity of repression and the mechanisms behind memory loss in trauma.
What are the key features of Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID), and how do they affect a person’s experience of self and memory?
DID is marked by a disrupted sense of identity, involving two or more distinct personality states or modes of being that exist independently and alternate control. Each identity can have its own behavior, emotions, and memory, often leading to amnesia for actions done by other identities. The person may feel confused, hear internal voices, or be unaware of lost time.
Why did the diagnosis of DID increase dramatically in the 1970s, and what are the controversies surrounding its validity?
Increased diagnoses may stem from greater media exposure (e.g., Sybil, The Three Faces of Eve) and the formal inclusion in DSM-III in 1980. Some critics argue that suggestive therapy, especially using hypnosis, may have contributed to false or therapist-induced cases. While clinicians can reliably describe DID, debate continues over whether it’s an iatrogenic condition or a legitimate disorder.
How does culture shape the diagnosis or interpretation of DID, especially in contexts involving possession?
In some cultures, shifts in identity are framed as spiritual possession and are considered normative or even valued. In such cases, a diagnosis of DID is not appropriate. This underscores how cultural beliefs about the self and consciousness influence whether such symptoms are pathologized or spiritually integrated.
How does DID compare in severity and comorbidity to other dissociative disorders, and what common co-occurring conditions are observed?
DID is more severe than other dissociative disorders and commonly co-occurs with PTSD, depression, somatic symptom disorder, and borderline personality disorder. Symptoms can include hallucinations, self-injury, and suicide attempts. Most people diagnosed with DID report a long history of symptoms, often dating back to childhood.
What brain-related factors contribute to depersonalization/derealization disorder, and how might they explain the symptoms?
The disorder may stem from dysfunction in how the brain integrates sensory and bodily signals. PET studies show underactivity in sensory integration regions, and mismatched sensory input (e.g., distorted goggles) can induce temporary symptoms in healthy people. Reduced activity in emotion-processing areas (like the anterior cingulate cortex) may also lead to emotional numbing.
What does the posttraumatic model propose about the origins of DID, and what evidence supports it?
This model suggests DID results from extreme trauma (often childhood abuse), with dissociation used as a coping mechanism. Studies show abused children are more likely to dissociate and develop symptoms later. However, evidence is mixed on whether objectively verified abuse leads to adult dissociation, possibly due to recall bias.
What is the sociocognitive model of DID, and how might it explain the emergence of symptoms?
This model suggests DID is influenced by therapist suggestion, cultural exposure (e.g., media), and patient suggestibility. It may be iatrogenic, meaning unintentionally caused by treatment. Therapists using hypnosis or reinforcing identity states may encourage the development of alternate personalities, even without intent to deceive.
How do implicit memory tests challenge the idea that personalities in DID are completely separate?
Even when personalities report amnesia, implicit memory tests (e.g., word priming) show shared memory between them. This suggests that memories persist across states, contradicting the idea that identities operate with total independence.
What evidence supports the idea that DID symptoms can be influenced or reinforced by therapy or suggestion?
People can role-play DID convincingly in lab settings, producing distinct personality profiles. Many patients only discover alternate personalities after starting therapy. The number of identities often increases during treatment, especially when suggestive techniques are used. Notably, therapists who use hypnosis or probing techniques tend to diagnose more DID cases.
What are the key principles in the treatment of Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID), given the lack of strong evidence for specific treatments?
Key principles include:
- Empathy and gentleness: Establishing trust and a non-threatening environment.
- Integration of personalities: Helping the person understand that splitting into different personalities is no longer needed.
- Coping skills: Teaching more effective ways to manage stress and emotions.
- Psychoeducation: Educating the person on dissociation and its triggers.
- Intensive care: Hospitalization may be required to prevent self-harm.
Why can psychodynamic treatment using hypnosis for DID be problematic?
Psychodynamic treatment aims to uncover repressed memories of trauma using hypnosis and age regression. However, these techniques can exacerbate DID symptoms by suggesting false memories or intensifying dissociation. More than 100 patients have sued therapists for harm caused by this approach, leading to a decline in the use of hypnosis in treatment.
Somatic symptom disorder
Excessive thought, distress, and behavior related to somatic symptoms
Illness anxiety disorder
Unwarranted fears about a serious illness in the absence of any significant somatic symptoms
Functional neurological symptom
disorder
Neurological symptom(s) that cannot be explained by
medical disease or culturally sanctioned behavior