Chapter 6 Flashcards
What are the four elements of negligence?
(breached duty caused damage)
- a legal duty to use reasonable care,
- a breach of that duty–either negligent performance or failure to act,
- a direct chain of causation from the breach to the injury, and
- monetary damages to the plaintiff as a result of his injury or damage to his property.
What 3 ways are legal duties created?
- statute–‘hit and run’ laws require drivers in accidents to give assistance to anyone injured,
- contract–a surgeon’s contract to perform an operation imposes a legal duty to perform it properly, and/or
- common law–judicial case law requires innkeepers to provide safe premises for guests.
What is the required standard of care based on?
Reasonable person test making allowances for
- physical disabilities–but not insanity or intoxication and
- individual experience–urban surgical specialist vs. rural GP vs. me.
What are the four rules for determining proximate cause?
- the ‘but for’ rule–no injury ‘but for’ the defendant’s act,
- the substantial factor rule–if the acts of two or more parties were substantial factors in causing the plaintiff’s injury, then each is fully liable (A, speeding through a yellow light collides with B, drunk, going through a red light: Both A and B were proximate causes for pedestrian’s injury.),
- the foreseeability rule–if hindsight shows that the plaintiff’s injury was a reasonably probable consequence of the defendant’s act, then the defendant is liable, and
- the proof of defendant’s responsibility rule–the defendant was the person who caused the harm.
When does the burden of proof shift to the defendant?
1) Negligence per se: defendant violates statute. (ex. contractor violates building code, building collapses)
2) res ipsa loquitur (ex: leaving surgical instrument in patient)
a) Whatever caused injury was in defendant’s control
b) Such injuries only normally occur as a result of negligence
Besides proving non existence of one of the four elements of neglilgence, which other defenses does a defendant have?
1) Contributory negligence
2) Comparative negligence
3) Last clear chance doctrine
4) Assumption-of-risk
5) Release of liability
6) Exculpatory agreement
What are the four comp neg rules?
a. ‘pure type’: cannot recover t proportion of damages equal to proportion of negligence.
b. ‘50% type: cannot recover any damages if his proportion of negligence was greater than the other party’s.
c. ‘49% type: cannot recover any damages if his proportion of negligence was at least equal to the other party’s.
d. ‘slight versus gross: cannot recover any damages unless the plaintiff’s negligence is slight compared to the other party’s (relatively gross) negligence.
When is an exculpatory agreement void?
If they involve the public interest or exclude willful or wanton misconduct.
When is an exculpatory agreement upheld?
a. the clause is not adverse to a public interest,
b. the excused party is not under a duty to perform, or
c. the parties had equal bargaining power and the contract is conscionable.
What are the four areas tort immunities may apply?
1) Sovereign or governmental immunity
2) Public official immunity
3) Charitable immunity
4) Intra-familial immunity
This type of immunity is based on the axiom that ‘the king can do no wrong’, excuses the government from tort liability.
Sovereign or governmental immunity
This type of immunity provides a limited waiver of sovereign immunity for claims against the US in cases in which the US, if a private person, would be liable.
The Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA)
What are municipal bodies immune for?
They are immune for their governmental functions (what only the government can do)
What are municipal bodies not immune for?
They are not immune for their proprietary functions (what could be done by private business). Ex. Norwood Light
What type of immunity do judges and legislators have?
Absolute immunity for acts done in their official capacities.
What type of acts do public officials other than judges and legislators have immunity for?
administrative or discretionary acts (which they can choose to do or not to do)
What type of acts do public officials other than judges and legislators NOT have immunity for?
ministerial acts (which they are required to do) that are done improperly.
This type of immunity was granted to promote family peace, preserve family funds, and avoid collusion among family litigants. It applied between spouses and between parents and their unemancipated children–but NOT others (such as siblings). Most states have abrogated this type of immunity.
Intra-familial immunity
What is a statute of limitation?
Bars tort suits initiated more than a stated period after the cause of action accrued. Example: Toyota with defective brakes … vehicle manufactured in 2005 but cause of action doesn’t accrue until the brakes fail and injuries result.
What is a statute of respose?
bar tort suits initiated more than a stated period–often ten to twelve years–after the date of the breach of the duty to exercise reasonable care, regardless of when the injury occurred or was discovered. The statute of repose may expire before the cause of action accrues. Ex. Vehicle was manufactured defectively in 2005 but not discovered until 2014. Suit isn’t allowable because there was a 8-year statute of repose.
When is the only time a landowner may be liable for natural conditions?
If a tree falls and causes damage (in urban areas).
When is a landowner may be liable for artifical conditions?
Interfering with another’s rights.
Not warning others of hidden dangers resulting from an artificial condition.
Attractive nuisance
What level of care does a landowner owe invitees?
Reasonable care to maintain premises, warn of hidden dangers, inspect the premises, and remedy any dangerous condition.