Chapter 4 Flashcards
What are collective rights?
Rights owned by a group of people
- Groups which are considered the founding people of Canada
- Unique people
Collective rights are part of the dynamic relationship between Canada’s government and Canadian citizens.
Anglophone
A person whose first language is English
Francophone
A person whose first language is French
Francaphone and anglaphone people rights
The rights of both groups are protected by the constitution
Why do we have French language schools?
French or English minority populations (of sufficient size) have the right to publicly funded education.
why we have Catholic schools
1867 British North America Act (BNA)
1867 British North America Act (BNA)
-Recognized the rights of Francophones and Anglophones and, as a result, allowed confederation
-At that time, most Catholics spoke French, and most
Protestants spoke English
-Both groups were guaranteed public education
(3) main aboriginal people?
- First Nations
- Metis
- Inuit
First Nations:
- The collective name of Aboriginal Canadians who have their rights covered under the constitutions.
- Use of the term “Indian” is still present in the constitutions keeping the name used at the time treaties were negotiated
- First Nations people do not use the word “Indian” to describe themselves.
The Numbered Treaties
Agreements between the Queen and First Nations
First Nations and the Government wanted to avoid war over territory unlike the United States
What caused disagreement about treaties?
Where Canada’s government recorded Treaties in
writing, First Nations recorded the Treaties in their oral
histories.
“The Indian Act”
In 1876 this act was passed and created rules about the lives of First Nations peoples without consulting them
Canada’s government viewed European ways
as superior to those of First Nations and felt that they
needed guidance
When did Residential Schools start?
1879
Residential Schools
- Canada’s government wanted to provide education but also wanted to assimilate First Nations
- Children were removed from their families
- Lost all connection to their language, culture, and identities
affirm:
to validate and express commitment to something
collective identity:
the shared identity of a group of people, especially
because of a common language and culture
collective rights:
rights guaranteed to specific groups in Canadian
society for historical and constitutional reasons.
Who are collective rights given to? (5)
Aboriginal peoples, including First Nations, Métis and Inuit peoples; and Francophones and Anglophones.
The purpose of collective rights:
- Collective rights belong to groups of people and are entrenched in Canada’s constitution.
- The purpose of collective rights is to affirm the collective identity of groups in society and to create a society where people of different identities belong.
one thing that makes Canada unique:
collective rights.
What are collective rights?
- In this chapter, collective rights are rights held by groups (peoples) in Canadian society that are recognized and protected by Canada’s constitution.
- Collective rights are different than individual rights. Canadians hold because they belong to one of several groups in society.
How are collective rights different from individual rights?
-individual rights under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, such as the right to live anywhere in Canada.
-Collective rights are rights Canadians
hold because they belong to one of several groups in society.
Who holds collective rights in Canada?
-Aboriginal peoples, including First Nations, Métis and
Inuit peoples.
-Francophones and Anglophones.
Why do some peoples have collective rights and
not others?
- Collective rights recognize the founding peoples of Canada. Canada would not exist today without the contribution of these peoples.
- Collective rights come from the roots of Aboriginal peoples, Francophones and Anglophones in the land and history of Canada.
Check the collective rights model
_
What does the constitution refer to for First Nations people?
The constitution refers to First Nations as “Indians,” in keeping with the name used at the time of negotiating Treaties.
Indian:
-Europeans used the word Indian to describe the
First Nations of North America,
-Many First Nations prefer not to use the word
Indian to describe themselves.
sovereignty:
independence as a people, with a right to self-government
What are the Numbered Treaties?
The Numbered Treaties are historic agreements that
affect the rights and identity of some First Nations
in Canada.
What do the Numbered Treaties have roots to?
-The Numbered Treaties have roots in the Royal
Proclamation of 1763.
-
What do the Numbered Treaties have roots to?
-The Numbered Treaties have roots in the Royal
Proclamation of 1763.
the Royal Proclamation of 1763:
-Britain made the proclamation at the end of the Seven Years’ War, as it sought to establish control over lands in North America formerly claimed by France.
-The proclamation recognized First Nations’ rights to
land, and established the principle of making treaties with First Nations through peaceful negotiation.
What are other laws that also affect the collective rights of First Nations:
-the Indian Act and section 35 of the constitution.
Are the collective rights still in progress?
- The collective rights of First Nations, Métis and Inuit peoples are a work in progress.
- Negotiations between Aboriginal peoples and Canada’s government continue today, including negotiations to establish modern Treaties and to clarify rights related to the sovereignty of Aboriginal peoples.
Who were the Numbered Treaties between?
The Numbered Treaties were agreements between the Queen and First Nations.
annuity:
an annual payment. Under the Numbered Treaties, annuities are mostly symbolic today.
For example, the members
of Treaty 8 each receive
$5.00 per year.
reserve:
land for the exclusive use of First Nations
Did all First Nations sign the Numbered Treaties?
- Not all First Nations peoples signed Treaties.
- Their collective rights are affirmed in section 35 of the constitution.
What were the Numbered Treaties to the First Nations?
-For First Nations, the Numbered Treaties are sacred — nation-to-nation agreements, solemnly made, that cannot be changed without their agreement. Treaty rights and citizenship go together
for First Nations now, in the past, and into the future.
-First Nations agreed to share their lands and resources in peace. Canada’s government agreed to terms covering First Nations’ education, reserves, annuities, and other matters.
Treaties and their dates?
- TREATY 1 - 1871
- TREATY 2 - 1871
- TREATY 3 - 1873
- TREATY 4 - 1874
- TREATY 5 - 1875
- TREATY 6 - 1876–1899
- TREATY 7 - 1877
- TREATY 8 - 1899
- TREATY 9 - 1905
- TREATY 10 - 1906–1907
- TREATY 11 - 1921
What were the major Numbered Treaties in Alberta and what were the terms:
Treaties 6, 7, and 8:
TERMS:
- Health Care
- Education
- Hunting and Fishing Rights
- Reserves
- Farming Assistance
- Payments, Annuities, and Special Benefits
What term did Treaty 6 not have?
NONE
What term did Treaty 7 not have?
Health Care
What term did Treaty 8 not have?
Education (Mentioned in the written report of the negotiations, but not mentioned in the written terms of the Treaty.)
Why did the Elders view the Treaties sacred?
It is an agreement between the First Nations in this region and her Majesty the Queen — so, the people of Canada. We saw it as a way to live in harmony with European settlers, and to share the land and its resources. Treaty 8 is fundamental to our people.- Elder Paul Eugene
Why did Elders sign the Treaties?
We signed the Treaty to live in harmony with the people of Canada and their government. To us, this makes all the people of Canada Treaty people, just as we are. -Elder Bruce Starlite,
Reasons why Canada negotiated the
Numbered Treaties
- Canada wanted to build a railway to link the province of British Columbia to the rest of Canada and to open the west to immigration. B.C. joined Confederation on this condition.
- First Nations and Canada’s government wanted to avoid war. Just to the south, Aboriginal peoples and the United States were fighting wars over territory.
-First Nations wanted to secure their future. They
were facing economic and social upheaval from
smallpox epidemics, the eradication of the buffalo,
the end of the fur trade, and the pressures of European
settlement.
-The Royal Proclamation of 1763 recognized the rights of First Nations to their lands in parts of North America claimed by the British.
What were some of the Problems First Nations were facing before the Treaties?
- economic and social upheaval from smallpox epidemics,
- eradication of the buffalo,
- end of the fur trade,
- pressures of European settlement.
Canada’s government vs aboriginals perspective under the Treaties?
-Canada’s government believes First Nations gave up their land under the Treaties.
-Many First Nations disagree,
especially since their worldviews do not think of land as something anyone can “own” or “give up.”
How were the Treaties recorded?
-First Nations recorded the Treaties in their oral
histories in their own languages.
-Canada’s government recorded the Treaties in writing in English.
The oral and written records disagree on key aspects of the Treaties.
Who takes care of the talking sticks?
Darlene LIttlebear- MacIntosh takes care of the talking sticks —the oral record — of Treaty 6 for her people.
Collective rights recognize the _____________________ of Canada
The founding peoples of Canada
Give one example of a group or nation that has worked or is still currently working to achieve sovereignty
Our FN, Bermuda, Guam, US Virgin Islands, American Samoa, Puerto Rico
Numbered Treaties are ___________ agreements that affect the ___________ and identity of some ____________ (two words) people in Canada.
1) Historic
2) Rights
3) First nations
A. Which document announced that Britain had finally won control of North America from the French?
Royal Proclamation of 1763
What two items did this document recognizes specifically for First Nations People:
ROYAL PROCLAIMATION
- rights to land
2. established the principle of making treaties
What were the six areas of discussion/agreement that the treaties covered?
Share lands education annuities Share resources reserves Other matters
Another name for the Numbered Treaties is……..
post confederation
What years have were the Treaties signed between…..
1871-1921
What did the treaties provide the ‘Crown’ with?
land for industrial development and White settlement
What were 5 things promised in return for the First Nations?
- special rights to treaty lands
- distribution of cash payments
- hunting and fishing tools
- farming supplies
What were the 2 main reasons that the Canadian government want to expand westward using the Numbered treaties to do so?
- securing the nation’s economic future
- feared their neighbors to the south would annex these lands
why in some cases the Canadian government and the First Nations disagree about the issue of ‘land ownership
Canada’s government believes First Nations gave up their land under the Treaties. Many First Nations disagree, especially since their worldviews do not think of land as something anyone can “own” or “give up.”
Why do you think the oral and written histories disagree?
Oral tradition can change when being passed down from generation to generation/ Written can also be changed if the writing party is being dishonest
Even though both sides may have had the best of intentions, what could have been the potential problems for both sides when they negotiated using interpreters?
The interpreter’s first language, might mean they don’t catch all of the nuances of the other language they are hearing or speaking