Chapter 4 Flashcards
Two primary forms of valuation:
- Relative valuation
- Discounted CF Analysis
Price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio
One of the most common ratios used in relative valuation. Typically, the diluted EPS is used in the denominator. The price/earnings ratio of a corporation is a comparison of its current price in the market relative to its earnings per share. It’s an indication of how the market capitalizes a company’s earnings, or what the market is willing to pay for each dollar of earnings. If the market value of the stock is trading at five times its earnings and the corporation’s EPS is $3.20, it’s expected that the price per share will be $16.00. An increase of one dollar in earnings would, in turn, project an increase in the share price by $5.00.
- For companies that are particularly sensitive to cyclicality, the P/E ratio may not provide an adequate reflection of the company. If the trailing P/E is used, it may be especially high at the bottom of a cycle and excessively low at the top of a cycle. This is known as the Molodovsky Effect.
- In order to counter the Molodovsky effect, analysts often use normalized EPS. Often this just simply entails taking the average EPS over a certain period of years.
Trailing EPS vs Leading EPS
Trailing EPS: Price ÷ trailing 12 months’ EPS
Leading EPS: Price ÷ projected EPS
- When comparing two companies, EPS MUST use the same time frame.
- Analysts MUST take into account nonrecurring items. Due to the effects of non-recurring items, the trailing P/E may not always be appropriate for the projection of future earnings. In such cases, it may be more pertinent to use the second method of calculating EPS called leading (forward) P/E.
- One of the drawbacks of using leading EPS is that the projections may not be accurate.
Relative P/E
Investors use P/E as a proxy for earnings growth. If the perceived growth is less than the growth of a benchmark index, it will be reflected in the P/E. This is true for both a trailing P/E and forward-looking P/E. If the market multiple is 15, a company with an identical P/E is considered to have a relative P/E of 1.0.
Trailing P/E example:
A RA is evaluating Firm A’s trailing P/E ratio. Earnings for the first 3 quarters were $0.19, $0.21, and $0.18, respectively. The earnings for the fourth quarter of the prior year were $0.16, however there was an acquisition expense of $0.08. The current price of the stock is $16.40. What is the trailing P/E ratio
Adjusted earnings in Q4 of prior year = $0.16 + $0.08 = $0.24
Sum of earnings = ($0.24 + $0.19 + $0.21 + $0.18) = $0.82
$16.40 ÷ $0.82 = $20
P/E ratio example 2:
Given:
Annual dividend = $1.50
Dividend payout ratio = 40%
Dividend yield = 2%
What is the P/E ratio?
EPS = annual dividend ÷ payout ratio = $1.50 ÷ 0.40 = $3.75
Price = annual dividend ÷ dividend yield = $1.50 ÷ .02 = $75
$75 ÷ $3.75 = 20
True or false: P/E is a good tool when earnings are negative?
False, earnings yield is a better option
Earnings yield
The reciprocal of P/E. Earnings yield is good for ranking companies from least expensive to most expensive in terms of the earnings that one dollar of investment will purchase.
- A lower earnings yield (more negative) indicates which company is more overvalued.
The Fed Stock Valuation Model (FSVM)
A method of valuing the overall stock market by comparing the forward earnings yield of a broad stock market index against the yield on 10-year Treasuries.
- When the 10-year yield is larger than the stock market’s forward earnings yield, the market is overvalued and if vice versa it’s undervalued.
P/E-to-Growth (PEG) Ratio
A ratio that goes a step further than the P/E by addressing expectations for continued operations of the company. When using the PEG, investors will normally look for a ratio of 1.0 or less. A ratio > 1 indicates it’s overvalued, whereas a ratio < 1 indicates it’s undervalued.
Formula: P/E ratio ÷ annual growth rate of the company (in %- DO NOT convert to decimal)
- The forward growth rate can be a projection or use historical data.
- There are weaknesses of the PEG ratio. Mainly, there is an assumption that the growth rate forecast will be accurate or that the historical trend will continue. Also, if the PEG ratio is used to compare firms accross different industries, there might be other factors to consider that would justify a higher PEG ratio (ex: Aggressive investor interest in tech).
- Similar to the P/E ratio, it’s pointless if there are negative earnings.
True or false: If a company has historically traded at 15 times earnings, and is currently trading at 12 times earnings, it might signal a buying opportunity?
True. This is an example of an undervalued stock.
PEG ratio example:
Given:
Market cap = $440mm
NI = $40mm
TA = $400mm
TL = $150mm
Dividend payout ratio = 50%
What is the PEG ratio?
P/E ratio = Market cap ÷ NI = 440 ÷ 40 = 11
ROE = 40mm ÷ (400mm - 150mm = 250mm) = 16%
Growth rate = [ (1 - dividend payout ratio) * ROE ] = [ (1 - 0.50) * 0.16 ] = 8%
PEG ratio = 11 ÷ 8 = 1.375
How to calculate the price target from the PEG ratio
PEG ratio * growth rate = P/E ratio
P/E * next year’s EPS = price target
Rule of 72
To find the growth rate, take 72 ÷ # of years it will take earnings to double
Compound annual growth rate
Formula: ((ending value ÷ beginning value)^(1 ÷ # of years)) - 1
Avg. Annual growth rate
The average growth rate for a period of time
Annual growth rate calculation
((ending value ÷ beginning value) - 1) * 100
Price-to-Cash flow (P/CF)
Measures the price per unit of CF. CF in this context means FCF: CFO - CAPEX.
The free CF yield is equal to the recipracol of the P/CF.
Price-to-sales
Useful for evaluating firms w/ negative earnings, having low margins, or are start-ups. This ratio can be used to mitigate differences in a firm’s capital structure and leverage. Also, this ratio IS NOT influenced by a firm’s accounting decisions.
Formula: Market cap ÷ Sales/revenue
- This ratio can vary substantially by industry.
Price-to-book (P/B)
This is a less volatile # that P/E. P/B is a common metric for financial sector stocks since they hold large amts of liquid assets.
Formula: Price ÷ BVPS
- If P/B is < 1 it means that the firm is selling below its BV and theoretically below its liquidation value.
- Some investors will avoid any companies that trade above 2X BV.
How to calculate BV
Shareholders’ equity ÷ # of shares of stock outstanding
Enterprise value (EV)
The EV is the real tangible price that a company can be purchased. However, EV IS NOT necessarily the price a buyer is willing to pay or a buyer is willing to accept.
Formula: Market cap of CS and PS + debt + capital leases + minority interet - cash & cash equivalents
OR
equity value + net debt
- Cash & cash equivalents are added back since the purchaser will acquire these and thus considered a reduction to the acquisition cost.
- If a firm has cash and no debt OR cash > debt, the EV < market cap.
- If a firm has no cash, the EV is the MV of the stock + MV of debt.
- If a firm has cash < debt, the EV > market cap
Equity value calculation
(EV + cash) - (long-term debt + short-term debt)
EBITDA
EBITDA allows for firms w/ different amts of interest, taxes, and D&A to be compared.
EV-to-EBITDA
When comparing this ratio between two companies, a lower ratio could signal an undervalued firm and if vice versa it could be overvalued.
How to calculate the EV of a company after an acquisition
- To calculate the new market cap: take (the $ amt of the acquisition funded by equity ÷ purchaser’s stock price). This value is the new amount of shares added to the shares outstanding.
- Multiply #1 * market price per share to get the market cap
- # 2 + net debt (debt - cash) of both companies
- # 3 + the $ amt of debt that was used to fund the acquisition.
EV-to-net sales
This ratio measure the economic value of a firm and its use to generate sales. By using this ratio, the RA eliminates the effects of different methods of calculating operating expenses (ex: lease accounting, capitalizing expenses, etc.)
Net sales = revenue - trade discounts - returns & allowances - excise taxes
Value of the firm calculation
CF to the firm ÷ (1 + WACC)
Value of the equity calculation
CF to equity ÷ (1 + COE)
Cost of capital
The required rate of return necessary to enter into and finance corporate projects. It’s the opportunity cost of entering into business decisions.
How to calculate cost of debt
Interest ÷ Principal
- Add IB fees, legal fees, accounting fees, and/or printing costs to the denominator.
How to calculate cost of PS
Preferred dividend ÷ price of PS
True or false: Interest and dividends are after-tax entries?
False, interest expense is a pre-tax entry, whereas dividends are after-tax entries.