Chapter 3 – Project Integration Management Flashcards
Types of Project Selection Models
- Nonnumeric Models
* Numeric Models
Nonnumeric Models
• Do not return numeric value
- Cannot be compared
• It is a justification
• Does not make them all ‘bad’
Types of Nonnumeric Models
- Sacred Cow
- Operating Necessity
- Competitive Necessity
- Project Line Extension
- Comparative Benefit
Sacred Cow
• Project has taken life of its own
• Not due to any justification
- but “Just because”
Operating Necessity
• A project required to:
- Protect lives or property - Keep company in operation
Competitive Necessity
• Project required to:
- Maintain company’s position in marketplace
Project Line Extension
• Project expanding a product line:
- How well the new product meshes with existing product line (new <> old)
Comparative Benefit
• Projects:
- Subjectively rank ordered based on perceived benefit (to the company)
Numeric Models
• Returns a numeric value - Can be easily compared • Two major categories: - Profit/profitability - Scoring
Profit/Profitability Models
• Looks at: - Costs - Revenues ~ Payback period ~ Discounted cash flow (NPV) ~ Internal rate of return (IRR) ~ Profitability index • More common: - NPV - IRR
Payback Period
• Length of time - Until project’s original investment has been recouped - Shorter payback period is better • Drawbacks: - Time value of money: ~ Not considered - More difficult to use ~ Cash flow change over time - Less meaningful ~ Over longer periods of time
Discounted Cash Flow
• Value of cash: - Inflows - Outflows • Also known as: - Discounted cash flow - Discounting • Widely used to evaluate: - Projects - Time value of money - Inflows - Outflows - Payback point • Requires a percentage - To reduce future cash flows • Discount rate: - Hurdle rate - Cutoff rate • Usually be one overall discount rate
Internal Rate of Return [IRR]
• Discount rate (k) - Causes NPV to be equal to 0 • Higher the IRR = better - Possible to have multiple IRR’s - Not a practical issue • Finding the IRR requires: - Financial calculator - Computer
Profitability Index
• Benefit cost ratio • NPV: - Divided by initial cash investment • Ratios: - Greater than 1.0 ~ Good
Advantages of Profitability Models
• Easy to: - Use - Understand • Based on: - Accounting data - Forecasts • Familiar & well understood • Give: - Go/no-go indication • Can be modified: - To include risk