Chapter 16 Flashcards
Summary theories of emotion
- Emotions are multi-faceted
- What is first: bodily changes (James-Lange) or emotion itself (Cannon-Bard)
- Many regions work together to produce emotions, including the subcortical Papez circuit (incl. hypothalamus), hippocampus, thalamus (anterior nucleus), cingulate cortex, and limbic brain.
- Basic emotion categories (Ekman) versus constructive view of emotions being derived from core processes (e.g., autonomic reactions) & dimensions such as valence (from negative to positive) & arousal
Amygdala & Fear Conditioning
Basic Paradigm
auditory tone (neutral stimulus, CS-) + fear evoking stimulus ( e.g. electric shock; unconditioned stimulus that elicits unconditioned response) = tone will come to elicit a fear response by itself (it becomes a conditioned stimulus, CS+)
Results from Mice Studies
- Lesions of amygdala disrupt fear conditioning
- Lesions of amygdala after conditioning also disrupt storage of response
- Lesions do not disrupt fear response to shocks (i.e. involved in learning association between shock and neutral stimulus)
In Humans:
- fMRI shows amygdala activity for CS+ stimuli relative to CS- and this correlates with amount of skin conductance response (SCR) Le Bar et al (1998)
- Similar pattern when humans watch the shock being given to someone else (i.e. socially learned fear conditioning) (Olsson & Phelps, 2004)
- Patients with lesions to amygdala fail to show an SCR to a CS+ but can - verbally report the association (amnesic patients with hippocampal damage show the reverse) Bechara et al. (1995)
- Amygdala damage in humans impairs fear expression recognition in faces and (sometimes) voices but not other types of emotion (e.g. Adolphs et al. 1994)
- Fear expressions activate the amygdala during fMRI more than other expressions
Fear: Beyond the Amygdala
- Fast and slow routes to the amygdala from sensory cortices (Le Doux)
- Fear may lead to enhanced visual cortex activity, as well as activity in regions such as hypothalamus and anterior cingulate (involved in preparing bodily responses), and orbitofrontal cortex (evaluating context)
- i.e. fear circuit with amygdala as a hub
The Amygdala: Beyond Fear
- Animal studies show involvement in reward-based learning, but mechanisms/regions may be different from that in fear conditioning (Baxter & Murray, 2002)
- fMRI shows amygdala activity for emotionally intense stimuli (pictures, tastes, smells, sounds) relative to neutral ones irrespective of whether positive/negative
- Response to happy faces in fMRI greater for extravert personalities (happy faces more intense for these people?)
Amygdala: Summary
Convincing evidence for role of amygdala in fear, but also clear role of amygdala in coding of emotional intensity and certain aspects of reward learning
Other areas are also involved in fear
Insula & Recognition of Disgust
- Insula damage in humans impairs disgust recognition in faces and (sometimes) voices but not other types of emotion
- Seeing disgust expressions activates the insula during fMRI as does feeling disgusted
- Some researchers argue that moral disgust may piggy-back on mechanisms involved in contamination-based disgust
Insula: Beyond Disgust
Involved in bodily perception and bodily feelings in general
Important for taste perception, pain perception
May monitor for bodily feelings (e.g. heart rate, sweating) which are important markers of emotion and may amplify the subjective feelings of an emotion
Basic Emotions: Overview
Different neural circuits with relative degrees of specialisation for different emotions, but also lots of overlap between emotion categories.
The properties of this overlap are in line with constructive view (reconciliation?)
Some widely distributed in brain (e.g. Happiness) others less so (e.g. Fear, disgust)
Orbitofrontal cortex & Reward Values
- Small et al. (2001) PET study of eating chocolate
- Initially = wanted and pleasant
- After excessive consumption = not-wanted and unpleasant
- Activity in OFC follows this transition (shift from medial to lateral activity)
- Blood & Zatorre (2001)
- subjective pleasantness of music correlates with OFC activity
OFC & Current Reward Values
- Computing the current reward value gives behavioural flexibility
- Patients with lesions to the OFC lose this flexibility and they behave impulsively
- Rudebeck et al. (2006) lesioned OFC rats prefer small immediate rewards over larger rewards offered later
- Human patients fail to regulate behaviour using social norms, have inappropriate emotional responses, and poor social relationships
* Rolls et al. (2004) patients fail to shift away from a previously rewarded stimulus that is no longer rewarded - Bechara et al. (1994) patients take higher risk gambles
Ventral Striatum and Reward
- Part of dopaminergic system, in particular nucleus accumbens.
- Increased dopamine release when presented with secondary reinforcers paired with food, or when male rats ‘presented’ with a female
- In humans, implicated in hedonic aspects of drug use (e.g. cocaine)
- In human fMRI, activity in ventral striatum correlates with level of potential monetary reward
Reward or Reward Prediction?
These neurons code the difference between the predicted reward and actual reward, rather than reward itself.
Anterior Cingulate Cortex
Has often been divided into dorsal (‘cognitive’) and ventral (‘affective’) regions
How ‘Cognitive’ is the (Dorsal) ACC?
Cf. “The Executive Brain”: Dorsal ACC detects errors & response conflict.
Rushworth et al. (2007): (dorsal) ACC computes the current value of actions, whereas orbital FC computes current value of stimuli
(Dorsal) ACC also involved in generating bodily responses that characterize emotions
Involved in perception of physical pain and in ‘social pain’ triggered by exclusion
Reading Faces
Faces are not only a visual, but also a social object
Bruce & Young (1986): division between facial identity, expression recognition and gaze processing
Haxby et al. (2000): division between time-invariant (identity) and time-varying (expression, gaze)
BUT, expression recognition seems to depend on integrity of ‘emotional brain’ (amygdala, insula, OFC, etc) and be separate from gaze
Also a role for sensory-motor simulation, e.g….
Related to resonance theory & embodied cognition
What is the Role of Somatic Responses in Face Recognition?
Capgras syndrome: the patient had stated on numerous occasions that her 9-year-old daughter had been placed under custody and was replaced by an imposter. On occasion, she had shown up at her daughter’s school, refusing to pick her up, screaming: “Give me my real daughter!”
An emotional response (e.g., skin conductance) may normally be used to decide whether a person is familiar or not
Capgras delusion =
believe that familiar people are imposters (but can recognize the familiar person)
Reading minds
Our thoughts, feelings and intentions are private and subjective
Nevertheless, humans may have evolved skills that enable us to infer what others are thinking, feeling, etc. from their behavior
E.g. the expression on their face, where they are looking, or by projecting how we might feel in that situation
Empathy and Simulation Theory
Simulation theory = assumes sharing of cognitive resources between action/emotion perception and action/emotion production
Extension of the mirror neuron idea, and of the results with face expression
This may enable us to empathize with others
When we see someone hurt or happy we (literally) feel our own experiences of hurt or happiness that enable us to empathize
Watching somebody in pain activates insula and ACC
System is modulated if the other person is perceived to deserve the pain!