Chapter 11 - Reporting on Non-Financial Issues, Including Corporate Resposibility Flashcards
What are the main problems with traditional corporate reporting (per King and Roberts)?
- Too heavy for the postman (increasing reqs/reporting requirements, so long - indecipherable to average reader)
- Yesterday’s news (historical reporting)
- Report on financials only (can lead to short-termism as companies strive to meet the quarterly or six-monthly basis of the markets) - ommits other important information just because it is non-financial
- Some intangibles excluded (ex. brand recognition, Corp Gorv, good reputation and sound risk management). Difficult to assign monetary values but so much of market value relies on such factors - meaning much a company’s worth/value sits outside the balance sheet.
- Some costs excluded - ex. environmental cost of using up natural resources
- Different reports for different users - (Ex. sust report/CG Report) - each tries to meet a certain groups needs - leads to ‘silos’ - each report showing a different stakeholder group a different aspect of the organisation
What is Narrative Reporting?
Describes the additional non-financial information which is included in companies’ annual reports, providing a wider and more meaningful picture of the company’s business, its strategy and future prospects.
What major players are there demanding that organisations report on the economic, social and environmental impact of their business operations?
- Shareholders/investors - assist in their investment decision making
- Employees- want to work for companies based on good CSR practices/reputations
- Businesses (suppliers) - may have to meet with org’s sustainability criteria/may impose their own on the businesses they engage with
- Governments - dealing with social/environmental issues and seek economic development
- Banks - look to lend money to organisations with good corporate practices
- Consumers - looking to buy products from sustainable resources.
- Stock market analysts - if company is listed
- Social & environmental activists
What are the requirements for a CG Report?
- Required by UK LR (9.8)
- How applied code principles (not boilerplate)
- Context of co circumstances / how board set purpose and strategy
-
Compliance with code provisions and if not
- Background
- Rationale
- Impact
- If time restricted, when will comply - Consistent/complimentary to strategic report - and any other governance information provided
- FRC GBE provides info on how to apply/further guidance on specific issues such as ACs/RM/IC
What are additional reporting requirements for listed companies re CG?
- For listed companies, DTR
- Ex. DTR 7.8.2A - diversity disclosures (description of policy, objectives, results, if no policy why not)
What is the purpose of the strategic report?
Introduced for all companies (other than those small co regime) by CA2006 (Strategic and Directors Reports) Regulations 2023 - the purpose of the strategic report is to provide (narrative) information for shareholders to help them assess how directors have performed their duty under s.172
What information should be included in the Strategic Report?
- Strategy, objectives and business model;
- Trends and factors
- Principle risks and uncertainties
- Analysis of development/performance of business including KPIs
- Info on environment, social, community, human rights, anti-corruption and anti-bribery matters, where material
- Info on gender diversity
What are the requirements (generally) for the strategic report?
- Fair, balanced and understandable
- Concise: information included only where material/does not obscure the report’s message
- Include company-specific information
- Link to related information elsewhere in the AR
Describe the new safe-harbour relating to director liability introduced by s.463 CA2006?
S.463 CA 2006 - new safe harbour for directors’ liability for the directors’ report, strategic report and directors’ remuneration report. Response to director concern over their liability for negligeance - ex. when making forward-looking statements (particulary in the strategic report)
They will only be liable to compense company for loss where
* Result of an untrue/misleading statement made deliberately or recklessly
* Omission of statement/fact amounts to dishonest concealment of a material fact
Their liability will be restricted to the company rather than to third parties.
What parts of a company’s annual report and accounts are examples of narrative reporting?
Chair’s statement, Directors Report, Strategic report, CG Statement, directors’ remuneration report .
Why might potential investors prefer to invest / look to invest in a company with good ESG activities?
Advocates argue that a company’s ability to manage ESG factors is a proxy for prudent risk management;
- Investors seek to avoid companies that aggravate world issues and risk;
- ESG investors organisations providing solutions, decreasing risk & driving long-term value
Why has there been a rise in interest / focus on ESG reporting in recent years?
- Many OECD countries (and EU) have put sustainability and ESG at the heart of their economic recovery effort.
- Investor appetite for ESG funds and ESG-conscious companies is increasing
- Seen as more resilient to economic downturns; and
- More reliable in the longer term.
- Investors views differ as to what they consider material in narrative reporting
- This issue can be overcome by aligning ESG reports with a leading global framework such as Global Reporting Initiative or the UN Global Impact.
- Connecting ESG issues/performance with strategy, business model, financial and operational performance will assist in ensuring investors are provided with information they require
List some common drivers for voluntary CSR Reporting.
- Reputation of brand
- Improve market position
- Ethical reasonings
- Growing understanding of impact of ESG over financial performance and corporate value
- Changing attitudes to climate change (and its being a driver of corporate risk)
- Close to being universally adopted: risks of being seen as out of step/misalignment
Main introductions by COMPANIES ACT 2006 (STRATEGIC AND DIRECTORS’ REPORT) REGULATIONS 2013.
Listed companies must report on GHG emissions in directors’ report/strategic report if consider information tp be of a strategic nature
- Actual quantity
- From activities of company, including fuel use
- From purchase of heat, electric and steam cooling
- Disclose method of calculating - in future years, comparative information
Main introductions by COMPANIES, PARTNERSHIPS AND GROUPS (ACCS & NON-FINANCIAL REPORTING) REGS 2016 - re STRATEGIC REPORT
Implemented EU Directive regarding disclosure and reporting of non-financial information into UK Law
Where a company has >500 employees and is
- Traded (inc. debt securities)
- Banking company
- Authorised insurance company
- Carry on insurance market activity
For financial years on/after 1 Jan 2018, must include the following disclosures of non-financial ionformation in their strategic report to extent required for shareholders to understand company’s performance/development/position and impact of its activites on the matters outlined:
* Environmental
* Employee
* Social
* Respect of human rights
* Anti-corruption
* Anti-bribery
And describe:
* Business model
* Policies pursued re the above
* DD on implementation of policies
* Outcome of policies
* Principal risks to matters arising out of company’s operations
* How principal risks managed
* Non-financial KPIs
Main introductions by COMPANIES, PARTNERSHIPS AND GROUPS (ACCS & NON-FINANCIAL REPORTING) REGS 2016 - re DTRs
Listed companies should disclose following diversity information in their CG Statements
- Policy
- Objectives of policy
- How implemented policy
- Progress achieved towards objectives in the financial year
Main introduction by COMPANIES (MISC REPORTING) REGULATIONS 2018 ***
Large companies to report on the adoption of s. 172 requirements in strategic and directors’ reports
s.172 statement as part of Strategic Report that should include:
- Issues, factors & stakeholders directors consider relevant to comply with s.172(1)(a)-(f);
- Main methods used to engage & understand issues to which they must have regard;
- PROV. 5 - info on the effect of that regard on the company’s decisions and strategy during the financial year; and
- This statement must also be published on the company’s website;
Large companies (over 250 employees) to make a statement in directors’ report summarising how directors have engaged with employees and they have had regard to their interests/how this has impact decision making in the financial year,
What does good sustainability reporting require?
- Deep professional knowledge
- Expertise
- Being backed up with robust sustainability strategic and risk management processes
- “The laggards soon will be left behind”