Chapter 11 Flashcards
Job discrimination occurs when
(1) An employment decision harms or disadvantages an employee or a job applicant.
(2) The decision is based on membership in a certain group, rather than on individual merit.
(3) The decision rests on prejudice, false stereotypes, or the assumption that the group in question is in some way inferior and thus does not deserve equal treatment.
Forms of discrimination:
Discrimination can be individual or institutional, intentional or unwitting.
Arguments against discrimination
It involves false assumptions about a group and harms its members so:
- utilitarians reject due to ill effects on overall human welfare.
- Kantians reject as it fails to respect people as ends in themselves.
- Discrimination is also unjust.
Statistical evidence
Studies reveal the persistence of discrimination in American life.
- wide economic disparities between whites and racial minorities.
- significant occupational and income differences in white males as compared to women and minorities.
- Few women and minorities found at the very top of the business world.
Attitudinal evidence:
- Widespread racist and sexist attitudes and biased institutional practices and policies come into play.
- Women and minorities often find themselves measured by a “white male” value system.
The Supreme Court ruling in Brown v. Board of Education (1954)
declared racially segregated schooling as unconstitutional and helped launch the civil rights movement in the U.S
The Civil Rights Act of 1964
(later amended by the Equal Employment Opportunity Act of 1972)
prohibited all forms of discrimination based on race, color, sex, religion, or national origin.
The Age Discrimination in Employment Act (1967 and 1978), and the Americans with Disabilities Act (1990)
further defined illegal discrimination.
By the 1970s, companies contracting with the federal government were required to …
develop affirmative action programs.
Affirmative action programs
1) reflect the court’s recognition that job discrimination can exit even in the absence of conscious intent to discriminate
2) Many companies believe that they benefit from affirmative action by becoming more diverse
Critics say that it has often meant…
illegal quotas, preferential treatment of women and minorities, or reverse discrimination against white males.
The Supreme Court has adopted a case-by-case approach to affirmative action (3 things considered)
- majority of the Court has upheld programs that are moderate and flexible.
- Race can be taken into account for employment decisions, but only as one factor among many.
- Programs that demand rigid and unreasonable quotas or that impose excessive hardships on present employees are illegal.
3 Arguments for affirmative action:
(1) Compensatory justice demands affirmative action programs.
(2) It is necessary to permit fairer competition.
(3) It is needed to break the cycle of minorities and women locked in low-paying, low-prestige jobs.
3 Arguments against affirmative action:
(1) It injures white men and violates their rights.
2) Affirmative action itself violates the principle of equality.
(3) Nondiscrimination alone will achieve our social goals; stronger affirmative action is unnecessary
comparable worth
women and men should be paid on the same scale for:
- doing the same or equivalent jobs, and also
- for doing different jobs involving equal skill, effort, and responsibility