Chapter 1: Rules and policies Flashcards
Civil Law Origin
Roman Empire (27A.C - 1453)
How Civil Law got mixed?
After the collapse of the Roman Empire, law got mixed with local traditions
Importance of Napoleon in Civil Law
He changed, restructured and unified the law. He codified the law of Rome and became the father of civil law tradition.
Heart of Civil Law tradition
Napoleonic code. Law was divided into varios sections
Judges in Civil Law
Do not have the power to make law. They can only interpret it and apply it.
Case Precedent
They did not have the concept, but they begun to make references of the past
Civil Law Trials
Question and answer process, judge leads the trial. The judge is god-like, he has all the power, decides how is the case going to be undertaken.
Common Law Origin
Battle of Hastings, Oct 14th 1066
Heart of Common Law Tradition
Courtroom
Judges in Common Law
They made the law (so they had more interpretations).
They would use case precedents, to take decisions immediately
Legislative law in UK parlament and US congress…
Is almost identical
When judges are interpreting legislative law
They have limitations, they could only interpret and apply
Common Law Trials
Judge acts as a referee, lawyer ask questions and they are allowed to discuss
Civil Law Strength and Weakness
S: Many minds working together
W: Takes time
Common Law Strength and Weakness
S: Judges made laws
W: Judicial Split, Many interpretations (2 judges, different parts, can have different decisions)
How did they solve in Common Law when they had different answers for one problem
Both cases go to a higher level of court
Power of making law is limited by
Cases from the past (Case Precedent)
Judicial Review: Power of a court above them to review a decision. Point to an error that could have changed the course of the case
If judge does not follow a Case Precedent
She has to explain herself
In a will, as long as the document is clear and doesn’t request anything ilegal
We as a state must do it
Most important difference between Civil Law and Common Law
That in Common Law, judges have the power to create law
The role of the trial court is
The first court to hear the case, decide what happened and apply law
Doomsday book
(Doom: End of the time) Record of the possessions and wealth that England had, when William conquer it
Trial by Ordeal
Reserved by witches. Drop people in water, in order to determine if they were guilty
Law
Law are the social rules and policies, that regulate the behavior in society. It describes what is possible and impermissible.