Chapter 1 - Development of American Law - Concepts Flashcards
Positive law has been called (1), and is enunciated by the (2) and backed by the (3).
- “command of the sovereign”
- government
- coercive power of the state
To be law, a command must take the form of a (1), (2) or (3) that applies equally to everyone. It must be seen as (4), (5), and (6).
1, rule
- principle
- directive
- rational
- fair
- just
The Declaration of Independence’s assertion of “unalienable rights” is based in (1), which is a (2) that often is seen to transcend positive law. As such it often brings about (3) or (4) of positive law.
- natural law
- philosophical concept
- criticism
- disobedience
3 examples in which the biblical concept (natural law) of “Thou Shalt Not Kill” has played into political discussions
- death penalty
- euthanasia
- abortion rights
2 examples of the philosophical interplay between natural and positive law, and the idea that belief in a higher law allows us to evaluate laws of our legal system, using our conscience.
- Civil disobedience propagated by Martin Luther King, Jr. against segregation/discrimination that was at the time authorized by law
- Nuremberg Trials, which tried Nazis for atrocious behavior that fit within the German law during WWII
American writer best known for advocacy of civil disobedience and idea that individual conscience supersedes state law.
Henry David Thoreau
2 criticisms to civil disobedience
- Citizens are obligated to obey law adopted by legitimate democratic procedures
- Individual conscience is insufficient basis for disobedience–law unto oneself
The legitimacy of law depends greatly on (1). In a rep. democracy, this is done by elected representatives serving on a (2). All members have a (3); a (4) is require to enact it. In democracy, legislators are elected through (5).
- how it is made
- legislature
- right to introduce legislation
- majority
- free and fair elections
The United States is more complex than a simple representative democracy, but is a (1) in which (2) is tempered by protections afforded to (3) by law. This also manifests itself in lawmaking abilities vested in other entities than (4).
- constitutional republic
- majority rule
- minority rights
- legislators
The 2 tests of legitimacy of law
- substantive (based on fair, just, reasonable principles)
2. procedural (enacted, applied, enforced according to fair, just, reasonable procedures)
7 major forms of law
- constitution
- statute
- ordinance
- executive order
- treaty
- regulation
- judicial decision
Fundamentally, law protects (1) and their (2)–the (3) as well as the (4),
- people
- property
- weak
- strong
Classical liberals like Thomas Jefferson, (1) and (2) were as important as right to own property and right to engage in private enterprise, but the (3), supported by John Stuart Mill, does not share the view that laws should protect (4).
- freedom of religion
- freedom of speech
- libertarian view of law
- traditional notions of morality
Conservatives see law and morality as (1) and that (2) prevents (3) of society.
- inextricably intertwined
- preservation of traditional morality
- disintegration
A society’s (1) affects its law, and vice versa. Max Weber recognized that a capitalist economy requires a highly developed legal system capable of enforcing (2) and (3) and must generally provide a (4). Uncertainty impedes (5),
- economic system
- contracts
- property claims
- predictable climate in which business can take place
- voluntary economic activity
While law facilitates economic development by (1) and (2), it can serve as an impediment if too many (3) are placed on it.
- regulating transactions
- rationalizing risk
- conflicting demands
Marxists, anarchists and radicals generally see law in a capitalist society as a (1) and an (2).
- tool of oppression
2. agent of inequality
Law picks up where (1), (2) and (3) leave off.
- social norms
- moral principles
- religious precepts
Legal resolution picks up where informal means like (1), (2) and (3) leave off. As societies become more diverse, impersonal, complex and specialized, the requirement for law becomes (4). In a democratic society, law also requires a reasonable degree of (5), which can be hard to achieve.
- discussion
- negotiation
- compromise
- more powerful
- consensus
8 prominent examples of competing values found in law discussions
- private enterprise v. public good
- freedom v. equality
- privacy v. crime control
- private property v. environmental protection
- national security v. freedom of the press
- public order v. the right of public assembly
- freedom of expression v. decency and civility
- majority rule v. minority rights
Primitive, tribal societies had no (1) and relied on leaders who relied on sheer power, charisma and (2). Individual behavior and social and economic relationships were governed by (3) and sanctions based in (4).
- formal systems of law
- claims of supernatural authority
- custom
- vengeance
With the emergence of (1), isolated tribal societies evolved into (2). Leaders, usually (3) began formalizing customs into (4).
- agriculture
- territorial confederations
- monarchs
- written codes of law
The oldest written legal code is the (1), produced in (2) 2000ish BC. In terms of crimes and punishments, this code adopted (3), similar to the Hebrew law calling for “an eye for an eye.” A striking feature was that it provided (4), even for slaves.
- Code of Hammurabi
- Babylonia
- lex talionis
- equal protection of the law
Athenian legislator (1) developed a very strict legal code that is still referred to today. The (2) replaced this later and had a more liberal nature as well as a right to (3)–a precursor to jury by peers.
- Draco
- Code of Solon
- appeal magistrate decisions to public assemblies
Codified Roman Law began with the (1). Before this, customs were simply interpreted by the (2), composed of patrician aristocrats. Roman Law evolved and was again codified in the (3), or Body of Civil Law, also known as the (4) and supplemented by the (5), or New Laws.
- Twelve Tables
- College of Pontiffs
- Corpus Juris Civilis
- Code of Justinian
- Novellae
After the decline of the Roman Empire, the feudal system relied largely on (1) and later on (2). Throughout the Middle Ages, the (3) of the Roman Catholic church exercised control in personal relationships. Roman Law eventually became the basis of law throughout (4).
- customs
- royal decrees
- canon law
- Europe
The (1), a codification of all civil and criminal laws of France, was based largely on the code of Justinian. It was (2), (3), (4) and (5).
- Napoleonic Code
- secular
- rational
- comprehensive
- written in the common language of the people
The Napoleonic Code became a model for a (1) for the nations of Western Europe, known as (2) systems. These systems are characterized by (3) applied with (4).
- uniform system of law
- “Roman law”
- primacy of legislature-enacted statutes
- minimal judicial interpretation
American law is derived largely from (1), which began as a mixture of (2) and (3). Royal courts grew increasingly popular under William the Conquerer, Henry I and Henry II because of their reliance on (4), and courts began to look to decisions of their colleagues in similar cases, giving birth to (5).
- English common law
- local laws applied by feudal courts
- church law applied by ecclesiastical courts
- trial by jury
- common law
In 1215, King John placed his seal on (1) which established a principle that the government is subject to the rule of law–a principle adopted by the Constitution. This document also established (2) in that no man could be “destroyed” without “judgment of his peers or by law of the land.”
- Magna Carta
2. due process of law