Challenges to Elizabeth at home and abroad, 1569–88 Flashcards
What was known as a key turning point in Elizabeth’s reign?
the Revolt of the Northern Earls (1569-70)
Why did the Northern Earls rebel?
- the earls and their followers wanted to make England Catholic again; they especially resented
the appointment of James Pilkington, a Protestant, as Bishop of Durham in 1561 - the earls had lost much of their influence at court under Elizabeth; they resented the ‘new men’, such as William Cecil, John Forster & Robert Dudley.
- Elizabeth’s refusal to name an heir, or to marry & have a child, created uncertainty; the earls
feared civil war & loss of power & wealth under a future Protestant monarch
Who were the ‘rebels’ of 1569-70?
- Charles Neville
- Jane Neville
- Thomas Howard
- Mary, Queen of Scots
- Ann Percy
- Thomas Percy
Who was Charles Neville & who was he connected to?
- Earl of Westmorland - a major Catholic northern landowner
- connected to Jane Neville
Who was Jane Neville?
- the wife of Charles Neville
- Duke of Norfolk’s sister
Who was Thomas Howard & who was he connected to?
- Duke of Norfolk
- senior noble & Protestant
- family links to the old, northern Catholic families
- planned to marry Mary, Queen of Scots
- connected to Jane Neville & Mary, Queen of Scots
Who was Thomas Percy & who was he connected to?
- Earl of Northumberland - a major Catholic northern landowner
- connected to Ann Percy
Who was Ann Percy?
wife of Thomas Percy
What was Mary’s marriage plan?
- Mary would marry the Duke of Norfolk,
depose (remove) Elizabeth & become
queen herself; she told the Spanish
Ambassador in 1569 that she “shall
be Queen of England in three months”
& that “mass shall be said all over
the country” - Robert Dudley told Elizabeth of the
plot, leading to Norfolk’s arrest &
imprisonment in the Tower
Describe the progress of the Revolt of the Northern Earls
- Northumberland & Westmorland, with
their wives’ support, continued with
the revolt; they took control of Durham
Cathedral, celebrating mass there, as
well as in other northern churches, &
began to move south - Elizabeth moved Mary to Coventry, to
stop her escaping to join the rebels - Though the rebels captured Hartlepool,
support from Spain never arrived
Why did the Revolt of the Northern Earls fail?
- support from Spain never arrived
- many northern landowners, especially those
in Lancashire & Cheshire, remained loyal
to Elizabeth - many landowners did not want to risk losing
wealth gained from the dissolution of the
monasteries under Henry VIII by backing a
failed revolt
What is the significance of the Revolt of the Northern Earls?
- it showed Mary, Queen of Scots, could not
be trusted – & she remained in prison - the Pope excommunicated Elizabeth &
called on loyal Catholics to depose her; this
encouraged further Catholic plots against her - the loyalty of England’s Catholics was now
in doubt, forcing the government to take harsh
steps against them - Elizabeth’s control over the north of England
was strengthened
Give an example of a Catholic plot against Elizabeth post-1570
the Ridolfi plot
Describe the background of the Ridolfi plot
- the failure of the revolt of the Northern Earls & the Papal Bull of 1570 meant that Elizabeth & her Privy Council treated Catholics with suspicion
- The Earl of Huntingdon, a committed Protestant,
led the Council of the North; he implemented
laws against Catholics in the north of England; this angered many Catholics, who were now
prepared, with the Pope’s backing, to plot
against Elizabeth - The Ridolfi plot (1571)
- Narrate the events of the Ridolfi plot
- Roberto Ridolfi was an Italian banker who lived in England
- worked as a spy for the Pope
- Narrate the events of the Ridolfi plot
- in 1571, Ridolfi plotted to murder Elizabeth, start a Spanish invasion & put Mary, Queen of Scots, on the English throne
- Mary would then marry the Duke of Norfolk
- Narrate the events of the Ridolfi plot
- in March 1571, Ridolfi travelled to the Netherlands (which, at that point, was Spanish controlled) to discuss the plot with the Pope, Philip II & the Duke of Alba
- Ridolfi had a letter signed by the Duke of Norfolk in which Norfolk declared himself a Catholic & pledged to lead the rebellion with Philip II’s support
- Narrate the events of the Ridolfi plot
Philip II instructed the Duke of Alba to prepare 10,000 troops to send across the English Channel in support of the revolt
- Narrate the events of the Ridolfi plot
- Sir William Cecil discovered the plot &, by autumn 1571, was able to prove that Norfolk was guilty of high treason (plotting against Elizabeth)
- Ridolfi remained abroad & never returned to England
- Narrate the events of the Ridolfi plot
- when parliament reconvened (came together) in May 1572, it demanded the execution of both Norfolk & Mary, Queen of Scots
- Elizabeth signed Norfolk’s death warrant leading to his execution in June 1572
- yet, Elizabeth was reluctant to punish Mary, & even refused to remove her from the succession
Why was Elizabeth reluctant to punish Mary?
- Elizabeth had to proceed cautiously
- executing Mary would further anger English Catholics & possibly unite France & Spain (Europe’s two big Catholic monarchies) against her
What was the significance of the Ridolfi plot for Spain?
- reinforced the threat from Spain, as Philip II would support any plots against Elizabeth
- threat from Spain meant that England needed to improve relations with France, as England could not fight both countries at once
What was the significance of the Ridolfi plot for the government?
- the government now began to monitor Catholics more closely & treat them more severely
- two laws passed in 1581 meant that families could be fined for sheltering priests & charged with treason if they converted people to Catholicism
What was the significance of the Ridolfi plot for Catholics?
it confirmed that English Catholics & Mary, Queen of Scots, remained a threat to Elizabeth
Name examples of plots organised by Catholics against Elizabeth
- Throckmorton
- Babington
Describe the Throckmorton plot
- 1583
- the French Duke of Guise, a cousin of Mary,
Queen of Scots, plotted to invade England
& overthrow Elizabeth, free Mary & make
England Catholic again - Philip II offered to help pay for the revolt
& the Pope approved of the conspiracy. - Francis Throckmorton, a young Englishman,
would pass letters between the plotters &
Mary, Queen of Scots
Why did the Throckmorton plot fail?
- Sir Francis Walsingham, Elizabeth’s Secretary
of State, discovered the plot in May 1583 - in November 1583, Walsingham’s spies found
papers at Throckmorton’s house that revealed
his part in the conspiracy - Throckmorton was arrested and tortured; he confessed to his involvement & was
executed in May 1584
Why was the Throckmorton plot significant?
1) revealed extent of threat posed by
foreign Catholic powers, English
Catholics & Mary, Queen of Scots
2a) Throckmorton’s papers included a
list of Catholic sympathisers in
England, confirming government’s
fears of ‘enemy within’
2b) showed potential threat from France &
Spain; Elizabeth had to take care these
Catholic powers did not unite against her
3a) government treated English Catholics with
greater suspicion; many fled England after the
plot; up to 11000 were imprisoned, or kept
under surveillance or house arrest; an Act of
Parliament of 1585 made helping or sheltering
Catholic priests punishable with death
- Narrate the events of The Babington plot (1586) & the execution of Mary, Queen of Scots
- the Duke of Guise would invade England, murder Elizabeth & put Mary, Queen of Scots, on
the throne - Philip II and the Pope supported the plot
- Narrate the events of The Babington plot (1586) & the execution of Mary, Queen of Scots
Anthony Babington, a Catholic, wrote to Mary in July 1586 about the conspiracy
- Narrate the events of The Babington plot (1586) & the execution of Mary, Queen of Scots
Sir Francis Walsingham intercepted & read Babington’s letters to Mary, which clearly
demonstrated her awareness of, support for & involvement in the conspiracy
- Narrate the events of The Babington plot (1586) & the execution of Mary, Queen of Scots
Babington & the plotters were sentenced to death & hanged, drawn and quartered
- Narrate the events of The Babington plot (1586) & the execution of Mary, Queen of Scots
- in October 1586, Mary was sentenced to death for her part in the plot
- Elizabeth delayed, but signed Mary’s death warrant in February 1587
- Mary was beheaded shortly afterwards
Why was the Babington plot significant?
- Elizabeth’s situation was more precarious than with previous plots
- by 1585, England & Spain were virtually at war
- Elizabeth’s government became determined to crush the Catholic threat
- the persecution of Catholics intensified; in 1585, 11,000 Catholics were imprisoned or placed under house arrest; thirty-one priests were executed across the country in 1586
- the plot led to the execution of Mary, Queen of Scots, ending any hope of replacing Elizabeth with a Catholic heir