ch5: perceiving groups Flashcards
discrimination
any positive or negative behaviour directed toward a social group and its members
o Discrimination against one group inevitably amounts to discrimination in favour of others
o Economic discrimination victimizes women and people of colour when they try to purchase a used car, rent or purchase a home, or negotiate a salary
prejudice
a positive or negative evaluation of a social group and its members
o Its roots can be traced to the kids of motivational and cognitive processes that guide our every interaction with groups
types of prejudice
o Hot – virulent and emotional hatred for other groups
o Cold – calm assumption that certain groups just “don’t have what it takes” and should be excluded from desirable positions
stereotype
– a mental representation or impression of a social group that people form by associating particular characteristics and emotions with the group
o Basis for prejudice and discrimination
o Can be changed but not easily
social group
two or more people who share some common characteristic that is socially meaningful for themselves or for others
socially meaningful
individuals who believe they share socially significant attributes
categorization
the process by which we group things or people, an intrinsic part of the way we think about and try to understand the nonsocial world
social categorization
the process of identifying individual people as members of a social group because they share certain features that are typical of the group
why does social categorization occur
o It’s a useful tool – we can master our environment and function effectively in society
Ex: we categorize a man as a librarian – allows us to ignore unimportant information, focus on what’s relevant
o It allows us to feel connected to others – dividing the world into those who’re like you and those who aren’t
effects of categorization
o Makes all members of a group seem more similar to each other when they would be if they were not categorized – overestimate group members’ uniformity and overlook their diversity
o Exaggerates differences between groups – more aware of the characteristics that make one group different from another rather than of those that make them similar
1922 definition of stereotype
- Walter Lippman – 1922 introduced the current meaning of stereotypes as “pictures in the head” – simplified mental images of what groups look like and what they do
what do stereotypes incorporate
physical appearance, typical interests and goals, preferred activities and occupations, and similar characteristics + personality traits the group members are believed to share
o Also – positive or negative emotions that group members arouse in others – feelings of digust and repulsion, fear and apprehension or respect and admiration
problems of “positive” stereotypes
o The implication that everyone in the group is the same, and ignores people’s individuality
o Stereotypes may set unreasonably high standards – an Asian student who gets average grades may be regarded as especially dull
o A positive stereotype might be part of an overall pattern of paternalistic attitudes towards a social group that actually reinforces the group’s weakness and dependence
Benevolent sexism – women are pure, moral, delicate, in need of protection – positive connotation, but these beliefs are held by people who also hold more hostile beliefs about women
benevolent sexism research
19 nations – nations whose citizens have higher average scores on benevolent sexism also tend to have more gender inequality (lower representation of women in powerful and well-paying jobs)
are some stereotypes accurate
- Some stereotypes have some accuracy in the sense that they reflect small differences between groups or small differences that group members themselves feel to be true about their groups
o Ex: Black and White college student’s stereotypes of their respective groups on attributes such as “dance well”, “have high SAT math scores” and “self-centred” – differ in the same direction as the group member’s self-descriptions
o People often join together in clubs, political parties, professional associations, and other groups because they share attitudes, feelings and beliefs – this creates real group differences
Californians and Armenians
Californians’ stereotypes of Armenian Americans
o Compared official statistics on this minority with popular stereotypes about their behaviour
o Only about 1.5% had arrest records compared to 6% of the rest of the population
o Only every 1/500 Armenians had applied for welfare, 5 times more Californians
gender leadership research
belief that men are more effective leaders, but research found no sex differences or a small preference towards women
when was the firs systematic approach to explain stereotypes
triggered by genocidal policies of Nazis – called for equally extreme explanations and led to the idea that hatred of other groups is abnormal
authoritarian personalities theory
- Freud, Theodor Adorno – authoritarian personalities – people who’re prejudiced because they cannot accept their own hostility, believe uncritically in the legitimacy of authority and see their own inadequacies in others
o Attempt to protect themselves from an awareness of their painful inner conflicts and self-doubts
o Doesn’t stand up against the accumulated evidence
o Some individuals’ extreme prejudice may in fact flow from deep inner conflict, but stereotypes seem to be the rule and not the exception – grow out of the same social and cognitive processes that affect all aspects of our lives
rude confederate experiment
white students observed a confederate who behaved in a rude and hostile manner towards the experimenter: white, black or no rudeness
o Conduct a mock interview of another student for a position of residence hall counsellor – given a list of questions, told it could last up to 20 minutes
o Black – ended the interview much sooner (8 minutes) vs the two other conditions (10 minutes)
can bringing to mind positively evaluated group members make feelings about a group more positive?
yes, When people have recently thought about well-liked black people their opinions became more positive
what feelings can influence stereotypes
- Feelings of uncertainty and concern when people interact with novel groups
dutch adults experiment
Dutch adults described these feelings when asked about their everyday interactions with Surinamese, Turks and Moroccans – anxiety and irritation (especially Moroccans and Turks)
us student interactions with people of different race
US college student reported irritation, dislike, apprehension and anxiety when talking to a person of different race
o The presence of a gay man can make straight men nervous and uncomfortable
why are interactions across groups full of anxiety
o Lack of knowledge of or familiarity with members of other groups – the less Asian Americans and White ppl in Hawaii knew about each others’ groups, the more anxious and irritated they felt when they met
Latinos and White ppl in New Mexico – awkwardness, frustration and impatience
o Members of different groups may be pursuing different sorts of goals during cross-group interactions
When white and black ppl interact, black ppl are hoping to be respected and seen as competent and white ppl want to be seen as unbiased and liked – the stronger they feel about this, the more they feel anger and irritations
classical conditioning
a form of learning in which a previously neutral stimulus, when paired with a stimulus that elicits an emotion or other response, itself comes to generate that response
o After several uncomfortable interactions, the emotions arising from the encounter become associated with the group
the desire to appear non-prejudiced may become salient creating stress
o Ex: white US students interacted with a white or black research assistant
o Those highly motivated to appear non-prejudiced for external reasons showed greater cortisol activity when talking to the black assistant
o Ex: white us students provided saliva samples early in the fall term and then in the spring term + questionnaires regarding that day’s social interactions – externally motivated individuals who had more interracial contact over the academic year showed cortisol patterns that diverged from what’s typical and healthy
men vs women crimes experiment
read a list of the actions of 50 men, 10 of whom had committed nonviolent crimes, others read the same list but 10 men committed violent crimes
o Exposed to the violent crimes – estimated that more group members had committed crimes
illusory correlation
a perceived association between two characteristics that aren’t actually related
A vs B list
series of sentences describing a desirable or undesirable behaviours performed by a member of group A or group B, ratio being 2:1
o Disliked group B more – less information about them in general
explanation for AB list
- When one of the behaviour descriptions involves two distinctive characteristics occurring together it really stands out – disproportionate impact when people combine what they know into judgements about the groups
examples of how stereotypes come to be
o In the middle ages, Jewish people were allowed to handle money and not a lot else – now are seen as sharp as frugal – same for Chinese in Indonesia, Muslim merchants in Africa, Korean merchants in black neighbourhoods in the US
o Socioeconomically disadvantaged groups are seen as ignorant, lazy, dirty, loud, carefree – poor Irish immigrants, poor Italian immigrants and now Latino immigrants
o Stereotypes adapt rapidly as a group’s role change – as peace is replaced by war stereotypes about Germans change
how do males’ and females’ differing social roles contribute to gender stereotypes
o Men are employed outside the home (requires task-orientation, assertiveness, rationality), while women are more likely to be responsible for home and family (requires interpersonal-orientation, sensitivity, warmth)
Men and women act in ways that are appropriate for their roles
Corinthians vs ackmians
Orienthians (childcare) vs Ackmians (employed)
o All child care workers described as nurturant, affectionate, and gentle while employees are competitive and ambitious
o Assumed that all Orienthians even those who’re employed are nurturant and the other way around – seen as having psychological characteristics appropriate for the group’s typical role
representation in media
- Tv: crimes committed by black people are overrepresented + crimes that white ppl committed were underrepresented
o Video games: systematic overrepresentation of whites, men, adults and underrepresentation of women, Hispanic ppl, native Americans, children, elderly - Tv ads: Asian Americans appear frequently (8% vs 3.6 of the US population) but are cast in stereotypic ways in business settings
o Latinos are 12.5% of the us population but only about 4% characters were Latino – often portrayed as unintelligent and inarticulate - 2.9% of the characters are gay or bi, but 3.5% of the adult US population identified as gay or bi while 8% reported participating in sexual behaviour with a person of the same sex
- In the UK: 4.5% of 126 hours analysed showed gay, lesbian or bi characters – positively and realistically less than 15% of their time
- Media messages about women – contradictory (strong female characters but sexist ads)
ads about women
o Male voice-overs dominate when the voice of an “expert” is required + men sell lawnmowers and computers while women sell shoes and toilet bowl cleaners
o 70% of internet ads portrayed women in stereotypic ways as sex objects or housewives