Ch. 9 Flashcards
reporter’s privilege
source confidentiality
grand jury
determines if crime has been committed and whether to file charges; DOES NOT DETERMINE GUILT
Branzburg v Hayes
- Branzburg wrote about illegal drug sales
- Grand jury issues subpoena to reveal sources
- uproar caused states to pass shield laws
shield laws
state laws that protect journalists form being found in contempt of court for refusing to reveal a source
Cohen v Cowles Media Co
- Editor published a source’s name and breached an agreement w/ the source
- the FA does not shield press from the requirements of promissory estoppel
Promissory estoppel
Legal doctrine requiring liability when a clear and unambiguous promise is made and is relied on, and injury results from the breaking o the promise
Generally applicable law
law that is enforced evenly across the board and doesn’t exempt journalists
Branzburg test
Reporter’s privilege to withhold info unless gov demonstrates:
- probable cause to believe that the reporter has info clearly relevant to a specific violation of law
- that the info sought cannot be obtained by means less destructive of FA values
- that there is a compelling & overriding interest in the info
civil contempt
journalist is jailed until he/she discloses information
Judith Miller case
Journalists: jailing miller would bring good reporting to an end
court: Branzburg law has been around for 33 years and hasn’t stopped the media
Zurcher v Stanford Daily
Police got a warrant to investigate unpublished photos of a demonstration
- searches will be physically disruptive
- confidential sources will dry up
- reporters will be deterred from recording and preserving recollections for future use
- Processing & dissemination of news will be chilled by the prospect of searches
- The press will reort to self censorship to conceal its posession of info of potential interest to police
Privacy protection act
prohibits search & seizure of journalist’s work product or documentary materials in the journalist’s possession as part of a criminal investigation