CD: The Media and Crime Flashcards
How do the media portray crime? Through..
- News Values
- Fictional Representations of Crime
How is crime portrayed in the media?
Media sensationalize and overexaggerate crime.
Crime and deviance makes up a large proportion of news coverage. Which researchers found evidence to support this?
WILLIAMS AND DICKINSON
found that British newspapers devote up to 30% of their news space to crime.
What type of image to the media give of crime?
The media give a distorted image of crime, criminals and policing compared to the official statistics.
What types of crime do the media over-represent?
The media over-represent violent and sexual crime. 46% of media reports violent or sexual crime though only 3% of violent and sexual crime is actually recorded.
How do the media distort the image of crime?
- Portray criminals and victims as older and more MC.
- Exaggerate police success.
- Exaggerate risk of victimization (eg. Sarah Everard)
- Overplay extra ordinary crimes. FELSON calls this the ‘dramatic fallacy’ where the media makes out you have to be clever to commit/solve crime: the ‘ingenuity fallacy’
Provide an example of the media’s portrayal of crime as a ‘dramatic fallacy’
TV programs like Criminal Minds, NCIS, Luther. All portray crime to be unusual, complex and so forth. Dramatic.
How is crime reported in the media?
Crime is reported as a series of separate events without structure or underlying cause.
The distorted picture of crime painted by the media reflects…
The distorted picture of crime painted by the media reflects that NEWS IS A SOCIAL CONSTRUCTION.
Which sociologists support the concept of the news being a social construction?
COHEN AND YOUNG note that the news is not discovered but manufactured.
A key element in the social construction of news is news values. What are news values?
The criteria that journalists use to decide whether a story is newsworthy enough for the newspaper or media. If crime can be told in relation to a news value, it is more likely to make news.
What are the 8 news values?
- Immediacy (provide news as it happens - eg. Strangeway Riots)
- Dramatization (Action and excitement)
- Personalization (Human interest stories about individuals)
- High status persons or celebs (Kim K)
- Simplification (Eliminate shades of grey)
- Novelty or unexpectedness (A new angle)
- Risk (Victim-centered stories about fear or vulnerability)
- Violence (visible and spectacular acts)
What are the 8 news values?
- Immediacy (provide news as it happens - eg. Strangeway Riots)
- Dramatization (Action and excitement)
- Personalization (Human interest stories about individuals)
- High status persons or celebs (Kim K)
- Simplification (Eliminate shades of grey)
- Novelty or unexpectedness (A new angle)
- Risk (Victim-centered stories about fear or vulnerability)
- Violence (visible and spectacular acts)
Fictional Representations of Crime:
What fictional forms of media influence our perception of crime?
Fictional representations from TV, cinema and novels are important sources of our knowledge of crime because so much of their output is crime related.
What did MANDEL find about Fictional Representations of Crime?
- Big business. Mandel found that from 1945 to 1984, 10 billion crime thrillers were sold, whilst about 20% of movies are about crime.
What did SURETTE find about Fictional Representations of Crime?
- Surette found that fictional media follows the law of opposites - the fictional media is opposite to statistics and similar to the news.
Eg. Sex crimes are often committed by psychopathic strangers in fiction, when the reality is that it is more likely to be committed by someone you know.
Eg. Fictional cops usually get their man.
What did Surette mean by the law of opposites?
The fictional media is opposite to statistics and similar to the news.
A03 Fictional Representations of Crime
More recently, changes have been made with ‘reality’ shows featuring young, non-white, ‘underclass’ offenders. Increasingly showing corrupt and brutal police and victims have become more central.
Eg. Secret Policeman. Police were found to be racist, sexist, corrupt.
Eg. When They See Us about Central Park 5 - 5 young people were wrongly accused of rape, facing racial discrimination and so forth.
How might the media cause crime? Through..
- Negative influences
- Fuelling relative deprivation
What might the media have a negative effect on?
The media has negative effects on attitudes, values and behavior -especially those of the young, who are more easily influenced.
What media examples are there that might cause negative attitudes?
‘Video nasties’
Rap lyrics
Computer games (eg. GTA, Call of Duty)
Negative influences: The media have been criticized for encouraging..
The media have been criticized for encouraging violence and criminality.
Negative influences: How may the media cause deviance?
- Imitation (providing deviant role models)
- Arousal (viewing violent or sexual behavior - eg. porn)
- Desensitization (repeated viewings of violence)
- Transmitting knowledge of criminal techniques
- Stimulating desire for unaffordable goods
- Glamourizing offending
Negative influences: Provide an example of how IMITATION may cause deviance
Eg. Chucky had supposedly influenced the children that murdered James Bulger in the splashing of the paint on the face and the beating.
Negative influences: Provide an example of how DENSITIZATION may cause deviance
Eg. Viewing of violence such as school shootings or graphic horror films/games.
Negative influences: Provide an example of how TRANSMITTING KNOWLEDGE OF CRIME may cause deviance
Eg. Documentaries on crime may reveal criminal techniques used, or TV shows such as How To Get Away With Murder.