Category 2 - Programming & Design Flashcards
True or False: Programming services are part of the Scope of Architect’s Basic Services
False. Programming should not be confused with Schematic Design, which is included in basic services. The Owner will either provide the Architect with a program or hire the Architect to perform the programming service as an additional service.
What are three important duties of the Architect during Administration of Programming Services?
- Confirm scope and intent of project with Owner.
- Prepare a schedule for Programming Services, including milestone dates, services furnished by the Architect, and completion of documentation provided by the Architect.
- Submit programming documents to the Owner for evaluation and approval.
How can the Architect determine the values, goals, and objectives of the Owner and users during the programming phase?
- Conduct a visioning session to discuss and prioritize values and goals that will impact the project. Prepare a written evaluation for the Owner’s review.
- Meet with the Owner to confirm and finalize the priorities, values and goals of the project.
- Identify and evaluate the constraints and opportunities that will have an impact, such as government requirements, finances, and access to name a few.
After reviewing and analyzing the project data during programming, what should the Architect do next?
- Identify any major unresolved programming issues.
- Make recommendations for solutions to the unresolved programming issues to the Owner.
- Prepare and present initial report of findings for Owner’s review.
What is included in the Architect’s final program document?
- Executive summary.
- Value and goal statements.
- Facts, data analysis, and conclusions.
- Relationship and flow diagrams.
- Matrices identifying space allocations, relationships, functions and sizes.
- Special requirements and equipment such as HVAC, plumbing, acoustics, furnishings, etc.
Describe how the Architect gathers programming project information and indicate what information is collected.
Architect shall compile and review existing project related documentation, such as:
Reports on existing facilities, site surveys, applicable codes, historical documents, and planning standards.
Architect shall conduct a walkthrough of the existing facilities and/or site with the Owner to prepare a space inventory, identify traffic and circulation patterns, and use levels.
What are three ways the Architect determines the specific space requirements of the project during programming?
- Identify all required spaces and establish sizes and relationships.
- Establish space efficiency factors (ration of net square footage to gross square footage).
- Document particular space requirements such as HVAC, plumbing, lighting, acoustical, furnishings, equipment or security needs.
What are considered additional services during the programming phase?
- Multiple Site Evaluation
- Site Suitability and planning
- Master planning
- Preliminary design and cost estimating
- Scheduling and market analysis
- Detailed existing facility evaluation
- Environmental suitability
- Services in support of Owner’s other consultants
Site Evaluation and Planning is considered an additional service during programming. What are the Architect’s first steps during the process?
- Prepare a schedule for site evaluation and planning services that identifies milestone dates, services furnished by the Architect, and completion of documentation provided by the Architect.
Name five services that could be specifically designated as the Architect’s responsibility during Site Evaluation and Planning.
- Program Analysis - area required for building, parking, circulation, open space, etc.
- Site Analysis and Selection - existing conditions study, assist Owner in selecting site.
- Cultural Factor Analysis - research history of the site and analyze impact of development.
- Environmental Studies - determine impact of project on environment.
- Economic Analysis - impact on development cost.
Who is responsible for all decisions regarding design during programming?
The Owner.
The Architect is mainly responsible for collecting design information and presenting the data to the Owner for review and decision.
The Architect and Owner are in disagreement on which design layout would be most appropriate for a project. Who makes the final decision?
The Owner.
The Architect mainly provides information and data to support a certain layout or design. It is ultimately the Owner’s decision for which design to choose.
When should the budget for the project as well as the cost estimate be prepared during programming?
The budget should be supplied by the Owner at the beginning of the programming phase.
If specifically designated by the Owner, the Architect supplies a preliminary cost estimate for the project as an additional service. This would occur once the program is complete.
You have received conflicting instructions from the project manager and superintendent, both hired by the Owner. Whose instructions should you follow?
Though both parties are hired by the Owner, generally one person has been designated as the authorized representative on the Owner’s behalf and so should be the lead contact for information by the Architect. If, however, a dispute arises the Owner should be contacted for final direction.
What are five ways in which an Architect can involve the client, users, consultants and stakeholders in developing the project design?
- Attend community meetings.
- Hold private meetings with clients and end users.
- Hold public meetings with stakeholders and clients.
- Hold town hall type meetings for the community.
- Hold a charette to encourage input on design.
Name four ways an Architect can communicate design ideas and collect feedback from users and stakeholders
- Present plans, elevations, models and 3D sketches.
- Show a Power Point presentation.
- Conduct interviews with stakeholders and end users.
- Distribute questionnaires to clients, end users, and stakeholders.
What are the main concerns stakeholders and community groups may have related to a project’s impact on the surrounding area?
Impact and effect on:
- Environment (increase in pollution, displacement of animals and plants on site, alteration of water movement on site).
- Increases in traffic, noise, and density.
- Inappropriate uses for the neighborhood.
What are some common materials that may contain VOCs? Name two methods for controlling their effect on indoor air quality.
Off-gassing of VOCs may come from glues and adhesives from carpet, millwork, and hardwood flooring as well as paint.
To mitigate this hazard, the Architect should specify low/no VOC products as well as provide adequate passive and mechanical ventilation to continually bring fresh air into the building.
What are three ways the Architect determines the specific space requirements of the project during programming?
- Identify all required spaces and establish sizes and relationships.
- Establish space efficiency factors (ratio of net square footage to gross square footage).
- Document particular space requirements such as HVAC, plumbing, lighting, acoustical, furnishings, equipment or security needs.
What are considered additional services during the programming phase?
- Multiple Site Evaluation
- Site Suitability and planning
- Master planning
- Preliminary design and cost estimating
- Scheduling and market analysis
- Detailed existing facility evaluation
- Environmental suitability
- Services in support of Owner’s other consultants
Site Evaluation and Planning is considered an additional service during programming. What are the Architect’s first steps during this process?
- Prepare a schedule for site evaluation and planning services that identifies milestone dates, services furnished by the Architect, and completion of documentation provided by the Architect.
Name five services that could be specifically designated as the Architect’s responsibility during Site Evaluation and Planning.
- Program Analysis - area required for building, parking, circulation, open space, etc.
- Site Analysis and Selection - existing conditions study, assist Owner in selecting site.
- Cultural Factor Analysis - research history of the site and analyze impact of development.
- Environmental Studies - determine impact of project on environment.
- Economic Analysis - impact on development cost.
Who is responsible for all decisions regarding design during programming?
The Owner.
The Architect is mainly responsible for collecting design information and presenting the data to the Owner for review and decision.
The Architect and Owner are in disagreement on which design layout would be most appropriate for a project. Who makes the final decision?
The Owner.
The Architect mainly provides information and data to support a certain layout or design. It is ultimately the Owner’s decision for which design to choose.
What should the budget for the project as well as the cost estimate be prepared during programming?
The budget should be supplied by the Owner at the beginning of the programming phase.
You have received conflicting instructions from the project manager and superintendent, both hired by the Owner. Whose instructions should you follow?
Though both parties are hired by the Owner, generally one person has been designated as the authorized representative on the Owner’s behalf and so should be the lead contact for information by the Architect. If, however, a dispute arises the Owner should be contacted for final direction.
What are five ways in which an Architect can involve the client, users, consultants and stakeholders in developing the project design?
- Attend community meetings.
- Hold private meetings with clients and end users.
- Hold public meetings with stakeholders and clients.
- Hold town hall type meetings for the community.
- Hold a charette to encourage input on design.
Name four ways an Architect can communicate design ideas and collect feedback from users and stakeholders.
- Present plans, elevations, models and 3D sketches.
- Show a Power Point presentation.
- Conduct interviews with stakeholders and end users.
- Distribute questionnaires to clients, end users, and stakeholders.
What are the main concerns stakeholders and community groups may have related to a project’s impact on the surrounding area?
Impact and effect on:
- Environment (increase in pollution, displacement of animals and plants on site, alteration of water movement on site).
- Increases in traffic, noise, and density.
- Inappropriate uses for the neighborhood.
What are some common materials that may contain VOCs? Name two methods for controlling their effect on indoor air quality.
Off-gassing of VOCs may come from glues and adhesives from carpet, millwork, and hardwood flooring as well as paint.
To mitigate this hazard, the Architect should specify low/no VOC products as well as provide adequate passive and mechanical ventilation to continually bring fresh air into the building.
A site is located near an industrial center with a high level of air pollution. What are some measures to protect building users from harmful air borne particulates?
- Install air filter equivalent to MERV (Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value) 13 or better.
- Regular maintenance of the building ventilation systems, such as cleaning filters, and replacing outdated equipment.
- Incorporate dehumidification or humidification equipment.
What is the difference between carbon monoxide and radon and what are mitigation measures for each?
Carbon monoxide is generated from fires or combustion equipment.
Mitigation measures - vent combustion equipment directly to the outside, install detectors in sleeping rooms & hallways.
Radon naturally occurs in the soil as uranium and thorium decay.
Mitigation measures - conduct testing, increase under floor and basement ventilation, install a radon sump pump in basement.
What are the main causes of mold and mildew growth and how can this problem be avoided?
Mold and mildew growth occurs most often in wet areas such as bathrooms, kitchens, laundry rooms, and shower rooms. In order to grow, mold requires an environment with excessive moisture, lack of ventilation, organic compounds to serve as a food source, and warm air temperature.
Installing passive ventilation (operable windows) and mechanical ventilation (direct venting to exterior) can help avoid many mold issues.
During schematic design of a preschool, you are approached by a group of parents who request a certain finish material for the playground. How should you respond?
As the Architect, it is important to receive input from end users during the design process. However, an Architect should not take direction from an end user but rather forward the request or concern on to the client for review and final direction.
What are similar design characteristics that would be utilized in the design of a nursing home and an elementary school?
Both user groups, the elderly and children, require more security, adult supervision, are sensitive to material finishes, and higher indoor air quality should become a priority.
For the elderly, other concerns include less mobility and increased lighting levels.
For children, other concerns include use of softer surfaces and accommodating higher levels of activity.
How does contracting with an individual homeowner differ from a building project with a corporation?
When designing for an individual homeowner, the Architect interacts directly with the Owner for all project decisions and direction.
A business or corporation generally employs a board of directors, of whom an authorized representative will be designated to act on behalf of the board for all project related matters.
You have been hired to design a synagogue, however you have no knowledge of the Jewish culture. How can you ensure your design will meet the needs of your client and end users?
- Hire a cultural consultant.
- Conduct studies of the culture through research, travel or interviews.
- Attend an assembly or gathering.
- Hold design review meetings.
- Conduct interviews and distribute questionnaires with members of the cultural community.
What is the importance of including input from user groups during programming?
In order to fully understand any assumptions an to verify analysis data, such as space planning, adjacencies and function, it is important that the Architect collect information from end users to make sure the building will function adequately once completed.
What is the difference between a Citizen’s Advisory Committee and a Neighborhood Community Organization?
Citizen’s Advisory Committee is a group of community members appointed by local board or agency to provide input and feedback on project proposals.
How can an Architect determine stakeholder expectation and influence project participation?
To determine expectations, an Architect should conduct interviews, focus groups, workshops, surveys and observation.
To influence stakeholders, an Architect should create partnerships, keep all parties involved and informed, and have regular milestone meetings.
Name three design methods to maintain appropriate internal lighting levels.
1, Daylight sensors - artificial lighting is increased or decreased depending on the amount of natural light entering the space.
- Occupancy sensors - lights turn off when space is not in use.
- Dimmable controls - occupants have control to increase or decrease lighting levels in individual spaces.
Name four site related safety design measures and four building related safety design measures an Architect can incorporate into a project.
- Site Safety - Building lighting at exterior, including entryways and exit doors; site lighting in parking lot; access control (keys, cards, etc.); security cameras.
- Building Safety - Controlled check in area; alarms (fire, smoke, elevator, security); egress (paths clearly marked, emergency evacuation plan); glazing (tempered in stairways, doors).
Name three design methods to maintain the proper internal air temperature.
- Occupancy sensors - HVAC equipment set to properly cool or heat a space based on number of occupants.
- Zoning - “hot areas” receive more cooling while warm areas receive less heat.
- Thermostatic controls - occupants have control over individual spaces.
How do the acoustical design concerns differ between an office building and an auditorium?
An office building will likely require control of noise between loud and quiet spaces (conference rooms vs. private offices) though the use of separation/isolation, metal furring strips, acoustical tiles and insulation.
An auditorium will focus more on directing and reflecting sound as well as absorbing it in necessary spaces, such as backstage areas.
What are four energy efficiency design methods that can be incorporated into a building project?
- Heating & Air Conditioning - properly seal ducts, install multiple zones and programmable thermostats, use high efficiency furnace.
- Water Heating - insulate hot water tanks & pipes, use solar hot water system.
- Lighting - use daylighting, fluorescent or LEDs, install dimmer controls and occupancy sensors.
- Appliances - select Energy Star appliances.
Other than low flow showerheads and toilets, what are other design methods for water conservation?
- Install a graywater system to reuse irrigation water.
- Install a rainwater harvesting system to reuse rainfall.
- Install drought tolerant landscaping to reduce amount of site water used.
- Drip irrigation or sprinklers on timers and rain sensors to reduce site water used.
What five actions can an Architect take to utilize resource conservation during project design?
- Re-use existing materials on site.
- Re-use recyclable materials.
- Select locally manufactured materials.
- Use rapidly renewable materials.
- Use wood products that have been sustainably harvested.
Which of the following adjacencies is the most appropriate for a day spa?
A. Reception, locker rooms, treatment
B. Reception, treatment, locker rooms
C Entry, restrooms,
D. This flow of adjacencies is the most appropriate for this building function as it moves from more public spaces to more private spaces.
What factors should an Architect consider when developing spatial requirements and adjacencies?
- Assign priority to spaces to determine most important adjacencies.
- Consider furniture and special equipment placement.
- Analyze flow patterns of occupants, vehicular traffic patterns, future needs of building, open space requirements.
What kind of programming requirements would need to be considered for the design of a fire station?
- Needs of the firefighters and staff
- Adequate spaces for necessary equipment
- Administrative and sleeping facilities
- Size and requirements for fire truck bays
The Owner has chosen a site that is long and narrow and asymmetrical in shape. How could this affect the design of the project?
Space sizes could be affected if large rooms are required.
Building orientation will be important in order to maximize site efficiency while still taking advantage of views, sunlight, ventilation, etc.
Parking and other site requirements may be affected if there is not enough land remaining outside of the building footprint.
Name six topographical conditions to consider when evaluating a site.
- Grading - is the site flat, hilly, or sloped?
- Vehicular Access - during & after construction.
- Utilities Access - existing on site or must be extended.
- Site Features - rock outcroppings, cliffs, forests, etc.
- Bodies of water - wetlands, lakes, streams, ocean, etc.
- Views - preserve significant existing views.
A site is located on a steep, undeveloped slope with southern views to the ocean. What are three primary concerns for this location?
- Grading and Foundation type - steep slope will require either extensive grading or a pile foundation system, or both.
- Utilities Access - an undeveloped piece of land will need to connect to existing utilities.
- Views - preservation of southern view may be desired.
How can a site be designed to avoid the ponding of water?
- Reduce the amount of paving on site or use pervious paving materials.
- Include proper grading and swales to direct water away from the building and to the storm drain system.
What is the difference between Topographical Conditions and Geological Conditions?
Topographical conditions occur on the surface of a site.
Geological conditions occur under the surface of a site.
What effect dos a high water table have on site design?
- Site Drainage - dewatering may be necessary as well as storm water runoff management.
- Foundation Type - mat slab floating on upper soil layers or piles extending to bear on stable soil.
- Waterproofing - foundation and basement walls require proper protection from water damage.
What are the similarities and differences between a mat foundation and a pile foundation?
Similarities:
Both foundation types can be used on expansive soils or a site with a high water table.
Differences:
Mat foundation essentially floats a building on the upper soil layers of the site.
Pile foundation is penetrated deep into the site to reach stable soil.
What are three passive design strategies that can be included on a building located in a desert climate?
Deserts are known for extreme temperature ranges, both very hot and very cold.
- Properly insulating the walls and ceilings to help maintain the indoor temperature.
- Using large overhangs on the southern exposure to allow for ample sunlight in winter and shading in summer.
- Use of operable windows to allow for natural ventilation and air exchange.
Name three design methods for protection against water penetration of the building envelope?
- Proper slope and drainage of roof reduces risk of ponding and leakage.
- Overhangs above doors and windows protects the openings from water infiltration.
- A properly designed rain screen envelope minimizes moisture buildup in the exterior skin.
What is the main design concern regarding snow drift?
Snow drift occurs when two adjacent roofs are at different heights and the snow can stack on the lower roof, creating larger loads in that area. This additional weight creates a greater stress on the building structure so a building located in this climate must be designed to accommodate the additional loads.
You are designing a museum containing artifacts that are sensitive to light and humidity. What measures should you take given these conditions?
- Maximize use of indirect lighting for the spaces containing artifacts, such as clerestory windows.
- Use of effective moisture control such as exhaust fans in toilet rooms to minimize indoor humidity, and utilize exterior details that allow materials to breathe.
- Install special humidification or dehumidification equipment to maintain proper humidity in the gallery spaces.
Why should an Architect be concerned with wind hazards?
Strong winds can damage buildings by introducing lateral forces, particularly on projections such as parapets and overhangs. These elements must be designed to resist uplift and overturning forces. Wind can also propel objects at buildings during hurricanes and tornadoes so a building should be designed to withstand impact forces.
You are designing an office building near a wetland area and the landscape architect wants to introduce a new plant species. What effect may this have on the wetland area?
Non-native plant species can have a negative impact on a wetland by displacing or destroying native species, altering the wetland function or service as well as disrupting the ecosystem. An Architect should take great care to minimize or eliminate construction and disturbance in wetland areas as well as maintain the proper permits for this type of site.
Name four federal agencies that may be involved in the approval process for a wetlands project.
USACE, US Fish and Wildlife Service, US Environmental Protection Agency, National Resources Conservation Service
What are “The Big Four” permits/approvals that may be required for most wetland or stream projects?
- USACE 404 Permit
- RWQCB 401 Cert.
- CDFG Streambed Alteration Agreement
- CEQA Compliance
Define “flora and “fauna” and describe how your design may be affected by their presence on the site.
Flora is plant life. Fauna is animal life. Site design may be affected by needing to designate no disturbance zones, re-planting disturbed areas, minimizing effect on food and water supply, and minimizing night site lighting and wildlife use corridors.
Your client has a site located near a wetland in the coastal zone. Which state agencies may be required for approval to design on this site?
California Coastal Commission, CalEPA, California Dept of Fish and Game, State Water Resources Control Board
Define the Coastal Zone in California according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).
The California Coastal Zone generally extends 1,000 yards inland from the mean high tide line. In significant coastal estuarine habitats and recreational areas it extend inland to the first major ridgeline or five miles from the mean high tide line, whichever is less. In developed urban areas, the boundary is generally less than 1,000 yards.
Which state and federal agencies may be involved in the review process for habitats of endangered species?
State Agencies:
- Department of Fish and Game
- CalEPA
Federal Agencies:
- US Fish and Wildlife Service
- US Environmental Protection Agency
Who performs a soil survey and how does this information affect project design?
Soil surveys are performed by a Geotechnical Engineer and are useful to help determine what types of soils exist on the site, and typically recommends the foundation type or types to be used.
If soils are stable, spread footings may be used. If soils are not stable or if a high water table exists, a mat or pile foundation may need to be used.
Which seismic zone in California poses the greatest earthquake hazard?
Seismic Zone 4. Zone 4 is located nearest to active earthquake faults and poses a greater hazard than Zone 3.
Four seismic zones in the US, higher the number, higher the danger. All of California lies within 3 and 4.
According to the California Geological Survey, what is a fault and how are they defined on fault zone maps?
A fault is a fracture in the crust of the earth along which rocks on one side have moved relative to those on the other side. An active fault is one that has ruptured in the last 11,000 years. Earthquake Fault Zones are plotted on topographic maps at a scale of 1 inch equals 2,000 feet and typically average about one-quarter mile wide.
Name the three fire zones in California and what factors the severity of each is based on.
The three fire zones in California are based on increasing fire hazard: medium, high, and very high.
Zones are based on factors such as fuel (material that can burn), slope and fire weather. Fire burns faster uphill and weather conditions such as high temperatures, winds or low humidity can cause a fire to grow rapidly.
Name five ground effects an earthquake can cause on a site.
- Ground shaking - causes over 90% of all damage.
- Landslide - shaking causes soil and rock to slide off a slope.
- Fault Rupture - crack forms as ground is offset along the two sides of a fault.
- Lateral Spreading - shaking causes soil to break into blocks and separate.
- Liquefaction - loose, wet sandy soil causes the foundation to sink.
What must occur before a project can be permitted in relation to earthquake fault zones?
Before a project can be permitted, cities and counties require a geologic investigation to show the building will not be constructed across active faults. If an active fault is found, a structure for human occupancy must be set back from the fault, generally 50 feet.
The Alquist-Priolo Act (1972) is intended to prevent construction of buildings used for human occupancy on the surface of active faults.
What are the two key elements of the Fire Hazard Severity Zone model?
- Probability of burning
- Probability fire behavior
CAL FIRE has developed a model that serves as the basis of zone assignments that is based on factors such as fire history, existing and potential fuel, flame length, blowing embers, terrain, weather and likelihood of buildings igniting.
What are three methods to reduce the chance of building loss due to fire?
- Defensible space - reduce flammable material around homes to keep direct flames and heat away (law requires 100 feet around buildings).
- Exterior wildlife exposure protection - construct buildings of fire resistant materials.
- Green Zone - clearing an area of 30 feet immediately surrounding homes, keep roof clear of flammable material, trim tree branches and keep a spark arrester on the chimney.
What types of disasters is FEMA responsible for?
FEMA has nationwide responsibility for reducing damage from hurricanes, earthquakes, tornadoes, floods, fires, hazardous spills, acts of nature or terrorism. FEMA also creates and maintains Floor Insurance Rate Maps (FIRMs) which delineate both the special hazard areas and the risk premium zones applicable to the community.
What site design measures can an Architect use to mitigate flood damage?
- Locate building pads above 100 year floodplain.
- Avoid large areas of concrete/hard surface.
- Use of swales to direct water runoff.
Define the three wind Exposure Categories from most protected to least protected.
- Exposure B - urban & suburban areas, wooded areas or other terrain with closely spaced obstructions.
- Exposure C - open terrain with scattered obstructions with heights less than 30 feet.
- Exposure D - flat, unobstructed areas & water surfaces not in hurricane prone regions.
Wind Exposure Categories are determined by “ground surface roughness” that arises from natural and constructed site features.
What building design measures can an Architect use to mitigate flood damage?
- Avoid building in a flood prone area unless the structure is elevated and reinforced.
- Elevate the furnace, water heater & electrical panels if susceptible to flooding.
- Install “check valves” in sewer traps to prevent floodwater from backing up into drains.
- Seal walls of basement with waterproofing compounds to avoid seepage.
It is discovered that there are hazardous materials present on a site. What mitigation measures should be followed?
- Removing hazardous material from the site and properly disposing per federal, state and local guidelines.
- Encapsulating and permanently sealing the material on the site per federal, state and local guidelines.
What are the acts, laws, and regulations applicable to hazardous material mitigation?
- Toxic Substances Control Act (Federal)
- Comprehensive Environmental Response Compensation and Liability Act, Superfund (Federal)
- Federal EPA Brownfields Program
- California EPA Brownfields Program
- Federal EPA Clean Air Act
- Federal EPA Clean Water Act
Describe the Entitlement Phase of the approval process for gaining permits from regulatory agencies.
- Submit DD drawings with enough info to show size and scope of project to the local Planning Dept. Drawings will be reviewed for compliance with CEQA, Zoning, Codes, local ordinances, LCP if in coastal zone, and Specific Plan.
- Attend any Design Review Board meetings.
- Submit drawings to state, regional, and local agencies as required.
What step follows the Entitlement Phase during the approval process?
After approval from Planning Dept and other regulatory agencies, the Architect would produce a set of contract documents including architectural and consultant for submission to the local agencies (Planning, Building & Safety, Transportation, Department of Public Works, Fire, Police)
What conditions must be in place in order to obtain a building permit?
All agencies must sign off on the project before a building permit is issued.
- Owner can obtain the Building Permit.
- GC can obtain the Building Permit and will have to show license and proof of workers comp insurance.
- Architect does not obtain the permit
What is the function of a Design Review Board?
Design Review Boards typically consist of design professionals appointed by the City Council to provide advice on new development projects and exterior changes to buildings. The function to make recommendations (advisory in nature) to the Planning Commission, Zoning Administrator, Planning Staff or City Council.
Does a Design Review Board make final permit decisions?
Typically, no. Design Review Boards are advisory in nature and make recommendations. Final permit decisions are usually made by the Planning Commission, Zoning Administrator, Planning Staff, or City Council.