Case 2: Beveridge vs Bismarck Flashcards
What is social health insurance (SHI)?
Health insurance with compulsory coverage by nonprofit insurance organisations & not allowed to deny coverage due to age, gender, or poor health
*How are SHI contributions collected?
- on earnings (wages, salaries) & overall income
- Contributions paid by employees, by employers, or both & collected by government or by multiple health insurance funds.
- Non-contributors (e.g. unemployed, retired individuals, non-working dependents) may be covered by contributions, too.
What do do individuals pay compulsory insurance for?
Pay compulsory insurance contributions related to their income & not to their risks
What are the guiding principles of SHI?
- Solidarity
- Redistribution
How has SHI moved toward UHC?
SHI has moved toward UHC & that traditional values of solidarity & social security have even been strengthened over the past decades
How is TFHS funded?
From direct & indirect taxes colled by central, regional or local governements.
What does the size of the budget for TFHS depend on?
Political considerations & negotiating ability of health ministry which allows for control over level of spending on health but can lead to underfunding.
What are the pros of the bismarck model?
- All funds designated to HC
- More choice of providers = competitive market = higher quality
- Higher income often = better health insurance
- Better quality of care than Beveridge
- Less strain on PH care system
What are the cons of the Bismarck model?
- Access to HC is lower, not everybody insured
- Inequalities in insurance types, related to income
- complex & expensive administration
- ageing populations = more pensioners = fewer people working
What are the pros of the beveridge model?
- idea of UHC already implemented in model
- less adminstrative costs
- access to HC with citizenship
- People with higher income = higher taxes
What are the cons of the beveridge model?
- migrants, non citizens, access is difficult
- lower quality of care
- higher OOP for specific diseases
- longer waiting lists
- limited choice of providers
- if unsatisfied with public HC = get private insurance = health inequalities coz not everyone can afford private insurance.
- economic crisis = HC cuts = unresillient HC system
What is health insurance?
Contract that requires your health insurer to pay some or all of your health care costs in exchange for a premium
What is the solution for market failure?
Health insurance is solution to market failure (HC becomes too expensive)
What is people’s demand for health insurance driven by?
- Risk aversion (prevention)
- risk of needing treatment
- level of potential income loss
- price
- ability to pay
Why do people buy health insurance?
- To cover unpredictible health costs
What are 2 forms of market failure in insurance markets?
- Adverse selection
- Moral hazard
Main market failure between health insurers and consumers?
- Moral hazard
- Adverse selection
What is moral hazard?
Tendency of poeple with insurance to change behaviour in way that = higher costs for insurance companies.
dd
delete
What are the problems with moral hazard?
- less attention paid to prevention coz costs for medication covered by insurance. e.g. high BP medication available & covered
- more health care consumption
- individual behaviour is costly to monitor (insurance can’t observe for each individual necessity to see doctor)
When does moral hazard occur?
After insurance purchase & people changer behaviour once they have insurance. e.g. more inclined to visit GP for every small thing if insured.
How is moral hazard solved?
- co-payments
- deductibles
- co-insurance
What are co-payments?
fee paid by insured patient each time they access a medical service (e.g. part of the costs for a drug)