C1 - Democracy And Participation Flashcards
what is direct democracy
when the electorate vote directly on an issue
what is representative democracy
when people elect representatives to make decisions on their behalf , represent them
what is a manifesto
a statement of a parties policies
what is a mandate
permission to govern
examples of direct democracy
referendums, recall of MPs act 2015 (voters directly vote to recall MP or not), E-petitions
examples of representative democracy
general elections / constituencies
who is Chuka Umunna and what is he an example of
was MP for Streatham, resigned from Labour because 80% of his constituents wanted to remain in EU. Example of constituency representation.
advantages of direct democracy (4)
- all votes have equal weight
- encourages popular participation in politics by expecting people to take their duties as citizens seriously
- removes need for representatives
- develops a sense of community and encourages genuine debate
disadvantages of direct democracy
- impractical in large, heavily populated state, where decisions are complex
- many people won’t want (apathy) to or not feel qualified to take part in decision making, so political activists decide what happens
- will of majority isn’t mediated by parliamentary institutions, so minority viewpoints disregarded
- open to manipulation by the most articulate speakers who can persuade people
advantages of representative democracy
-Practical in large states where issues are complex and need rapid response.
- reduces chances of minority rights being overridden by “tyranny of the majority”
- politicians are (theoretically) better informed than the average citizen about many issues
- politicians form parties, bringing coherence and give people a real choice of representative. pressure groups form to represent different interests and promote debate.
disadvantages of representative democracy
-may lead to reduced participation as people hand power to politicians
-parties and PGs are run by elites who pursue personal agendas
-Minorities may still be underrepresented as politicians are more likely to follow majority views (to be elected)
- politicians may be corrupt, incompetent, may betray promises and put party loyalty before the electorate.
what is a pluralist democracy
a type of democracy in which a govt. makes decisions as a result of various ideas from contrasting arguments and competing groups.
advantages of referendums
everyone gets a say in decision
equal weight to all votes
encourage popular participation (turnout often exceeds general elections)
they develop a sense of community and responsibility
encourage genuine debate
example of referendum turnout exceeding that of general elections
Scottish independence ref - 85% turnout , wheras 2019 general election was 67%
example of referendums developing a sense of community
Good Friday referendum - paved way for Catholics and Protestants to share power
disadvantages of referendums
-lead to “tyranny of majority”
- pose questions to voters that are too complex (EU ref , people didn’t know what a custom union was, people didn’t know how much UK payed into EU budget)
-may not actually develop a sense of community (NI govt. isn’t functioning, EU ref deepened divides between regions/ age groups - Scotland wanted to leave England wanted to remain - 27% of 18-24 voted leave, that was 60% for those 60+)
e-petitions advantages + example
-can allow ordinary people to have an impact on decisions (e.g “end period poverty” campaign started as an e-petition to scrap tampon tax. Ended with scrapping of V.A.T on sanitary productsin 2021)
e-petitions disadvantages
- many aren’t debated in parliament (460/8200 e-petitions created between 2017-19 got a govt. response)
- people may not be that engaged after signing the petition - many are created for spurious reasons (e.g. a ban on the game fortnite)
- whole process to dependent on elected politicians, so barely any effect
recall petitions advantages
-allows constituents to hold MPs to account
-can ensure politicians know that the electorate are in charge.
recall petitions disadvantages
- recalled MP can still stand in the by-election after being sacked
- parliament have to approve whether petitions are held (turkeys don’t vote for Christmas)
example of politician standing in the by election after they were sacked
Chris Davies - stood in by election in 2019 despite being recalled for falsifying expense claims. He almost won.
example of parliament not voting for a recall election
Boris Johnson held onto seat for over a year after allegations that he lied to parliament about partygate
what are the different meanings of representation
-social representation
-representing national interests
- constituency representation
-party representation
-functional representation
-causal representation
what is social representation
representative bodies being made up of people that reflect society as a whole. They should be microcosms of society, where characteristics of members represent characteristics of society.
what is constituency representation
1) representing constituency interests as a whole
2) representing individual constituents interests - called redress of grievances
3) representatives listening to constituents views when deciding on national issues
what is representing national interest
representatives that sit at a national parliament have to take national interests not just local ones into account when deciding on issues
what is party representation
candidates belonging to a party campaign on the basis of their parties manifesto and represent them.
what is functional represntation
elected representatives representing a particular social or occupational group.
what is causal representation
representative bodies represent ideas, principles and causes rather than people. this type of representation doesn’t target groups of people, rather entire communities. usually related to environment, equality or animal rights.
what forms of representation are there in the UK (how are people represneted in the UK)
-constituencies
-parties
-mandate and manifesto
-govt. representation
-pressure groups
constituency representation
-every MP has a constituency
-constituency interests given a hearing in a representative assembly
how do parties aid representation in the UK
1) a representatives party tells us about their views and most party members hold similar views
2) one party governs the UK (normally)
how does the mandate and manifesto aid representation in the UK
mandate means that the winning party is given permission to govern and represent the nation, as they are the party with the most seats in the HoC. The manifesto allows for people to see what views parties hold and which party is best to represent them.
what is a manifesto
a statement of a parties policy
mandate/manifesto positives
- gives govt. legitimacy
- allows voters to judge govt. performance
mandate/manifesto negatives
-parties often have <50% of the vote
- those who voted don’t necessarily support all manifesto points
govt representatation
-people are represented by elected govt. as they represent the whole nation
how do pressure groups aid representation in the UK and give specific examples (different types of pressure groups)
1) may have formal membership like parties and so represent their members e.g. BMA ( British medical association )
2) may not have formal membership but represent a section of society - although they wont be able to find out what demands there are e.g. Stonewall ( gay people )
3) may be engaged in causal representation , promotional rather than sectional groups e.g. ASH ( acting on smoking health )
they are also a part of a pluralist democracy
1980 vs 2016 % of electorate political party members
4% in 1980
1% in 2016
voter turnout in 2019
67.3%
voter turnout in 2001
55.7%