C Rubric Flashcards
What are the 4 parameters for scoring Coherence?
1) Make Sense
2) Connector Usage
3) On Topic
4) Listener’s Comprehension
Coherence 1 - Make Sense?
Can provide mainly isolated phrases
Coherence 2 - Make Sense?
occasionally connect isolated ideas to establish a logical relationship between them.
Coherence 3 - Make Sense?
form linear sequences of points and organize basic statements, though main points not always obvious
Coherence 4 - Make Sense?
recognizable main points with somewhat relevant details and or examples
Coherence 5 - Make Sense?
appropriate control over organizational patterns
Coherence 6 - Make Sense?
use a variety of organizational points and various connectors or other cohesive devices to create well-developed discourse
Coherence 1 - Connector Usage
link words or groups of words with very basic connectors
Coherence 2 - Connector Usage
Can link groups of words with simple connectors like “and”, “but”, and “because”
Coherence 3 - Connector Usage
Use several connectors
Coherence 4 - Connector Usage
use appropriate connectors to present reasonable discourse order
Coherence 5 - Connector Usage
connectors to create clear, smooth discourse flow
Coherence 6 - Connector Usage
Diverse range of simple and sophisticated connector words
Coherence 4 - On Topic
may be some “jumpiness” or rambling in a long contribution
Coherence 5 - On Topic
Some slight rambling, that does not detract from the point being made
Coherence 6 - On Topic
No rambling or jumpiness present
Coherence 1 - Listener’s Comprehension
listener often finds it challenging to follow
Coherence 2 - Listener’s Comprehension
listener often struggles to comprehend
Coherence 3 - Listener’s Comprehension
The listener is generally able to derive the meaning
Coherence 4 - Listener’s Comprehension
Generally, is not difficult for the listener to follow
Coherence 5 - Listener’s Comprehension
The listener can follow main ideas and notice supporting details and or examples
Coherence 6 - Listener’s Comprehension
Comfortable for the listener to follow main ideas and notice supporting details and or examples.
List 2 Barrier to go from Interaction 1 to Interaction 2
- Speech is not connected in any noticeable way
2. Speaks in isolated sentences or phrases
List a Barrier to go from Interaction 2 to Interaction 3
- Not able to provide details necessary for a clear description of their viewpoints
List 3 Barrier to go from Interaction 3 to Interaction 4
1 .Does not provide supporting details or relevant examples most of the time.
- Main point is not obvious and/or is contradicted by later statements.
- Not able to use simple connectors.
List 5 Barrier to go from Interaction 4 to Interaction 5
- Does not consistently give main points first or make their main points immediately obvious.
- Provides only a few relevant details.
- Points made do not necessarily follow a logical order (jumpiness).
- Follow-up information contradicts what has been said before.
- Relies on examples and details, or circumlocution to make their main points obvious (interviewer re-stating or summarizing for them because they cannot concisely state their main points).