Burglary and Aggravated Flashcards
How many forms of burglary are there?
2 types: Section 9(1)(a) and Section 9(1)(b)
Which extract of legislation covers Burglary?
The Theft Act 1968, Section 9(1)(a)
How is burglary triable?
Triable on indictment if ‘ulterior motive’ is triable on indictment, or if committed in a dwelling and violence used; otherwise triable either way
What is the penalty on indictment if the building or part of building is a dwelling?
14 years imprisonment
What is the penalty on indictment if building or part of building is NOT a dwelling?
10 years imprisonment
What is the penalty if tried summarily?
Six months’ imprisonment and/or fine
What is the definition of Burglary, Section 9 (1)(a)?
Enters any building or part of a building as a trespasser with intent to steal anything in the building or part of a building, inflict grievous bodily harm to any person therein or do unlawful damage to the building or anything therein
Under what form of law is “enters” defined under?
Common law
Under common law, how is “enters” defined?
Entry is the insertion of any part of the body, however small, across a threshold which is effective
Who assesses whether an entry is effective?
The jury
For an effective entry, does the defendant need to have entered the building to such extent that the ulterior offence of the original entry can be committed?
No - the ulterior offence does not need to be realised, only acted towards
For a legitimate charge of burglary, must the defendant have succeeded in getting their whole body into a building?
No - any part of the body crossing the threshold, however small, is sufficient to constitute entry, even if only a hand
Under common law, would the insertion of an instrument across a threshold constituent effective entry?
Yes - so long as the instrument is inserted for the purpose of enabling the ulterior motive to take place i.e. a hook inserted to steal property, a gun inserted to cause GBH
Would the insertion of an instrument across a threshold to facilitate entry be sufficient for a charge of burglary?
No - the insertion of any instrument in order to gain entry is not entry itself and would not be sufficient evidence for a charge of burglary
In addition to being effective, what other quality must an entry have for a legitimate charge of burglary?
The entry must be deliberate, not accidental
What two conditions qualify the act of trespass as sufficient for a charge of burglary?
The defendant must either
1) know they are entering as a trespasser (i.e. know they are entering without a right by law, or without express or implied permission to do so);
2) or be reckless as to the fact that they are entering as a trespasser
If a defendant has a general permission to enter a building or part of a building for legitimate reasons in another context, will this nullify a charge of burglary in ALL contexts?
No - so long as the true intention of the defendant when entering (to steal, commit GBH or criminal damage) would not form part of their legitimate permission to enter the building in the usual context. Exceeding these legitimate permissions renders the defendant a trespasser
If X gives Y their house keys for the purpose of feeding their cat whilst on holiday, and Y, intending to steal from X’s home, uses the key to get inside, has burglary been committed and why?
Yes - because X did not give Y the keys for the purpose of stealing. Y’s intention renders his permission of entry illegitimate as soon as the intent is formed and access gained across the threshold.
What additional places does Section 9(4) of the Theft Act 1968 define as a “dwelling” in addition to buildings?
“Dwelling” also applies to any vehicle or vessel which is inhabited, both at times when the person habiting it is there or not there
How is a “building” typically defined?
Generally, a structure of a permanent nature
Can a portable structure ever constituent a “building” for the purposes of a charge of burglary?
Yes - so long as it has most of the attributes of a building
Who ultimately decides what constitutes a “building” in burglary cases i.e. a pile of bricks to build a house ?
The jury
Can tents and marquees be considered “buildings” in respect of burglary?
No - they cannot, event if the tent is somebody’s home
What quality must a vehicle/vessel have to be considered a “building” in respect of burglary?
It must be inhabited, even if the person is not “in” at the time of the crime. E.g. house boats, motor homes.
Can a canal boat which is not inhabited be considered a “building” for the purposes of burglary?
No - whilst capable of habitation, is it not a building for a long as it is not habited
What is meant by “part of a building”?
An area sufficiently physically marked out as segregated from another
Who decides what constitutes “part of a building” in Burglary cases?
The jury
Would a “No Entry” sign or rope designate a “part of a building”
Yes - it mark off one part of a building from another, and associated permissions of access
If a waiter has a legitimate access to a restaurant kitchen, and enters a fridge (reserved only for chefs) through a soft perspex barrier, are they committing trespass?
Yes - the fridge has been physically marked out as a separate space from the kitchen and is a different part of the building to that which the waiter has legitimate access permissions for
For a charge of burglary, when must the intention to enter a building as a trespasser to steal, commit GBH or unlawful damage exist?
At the time of entry (NOT before or after)