Booklet 2 - Religious Organisations And Participation Flashcards
What is Troeltsch’s typology based on?
- Organisational structure
- Relationship with wider society
- Commitment required from members
- Attitude to different religious groups
Church organisation structure
Troelsch and Weber
- Large organisations
- Often have millions of members
- Run by an organised, bureaucratic hierarchy of professional paid clergy
- Clear lines of seniority within clergy
- Often wealthy
- Leaders have power within wider society
- Worship tends to be formal and ritualised
Troeltsch and Weber
Church attitudes to wider society
- World-accommodating.
-Conservative. - Likely to accept the dominant norms and values of society.
- Some churches have clear links to the state and are considered an ‘official religion’ or state religion.
Example of a state religion
Anglican Church in the UK where the sovereign is head of state and head of the church and bishops sit in the house of lords.
Troelsch and Weber
Membership requirements - churches
- Universalist and inclusive.
- Many born into it and assumed to be a member unless they opt out.
- Integrated with political and economic structures accepting the social environment they live in.
Troelsch and Weber
Churches attitudes to other religions
- Churches can be intolerant of other religious groups as most claim a monopoly of truth.
- Clearly seen in Roman Catholic Church who work with other faiths on social justice projects however maintain the ‘one true church’ claim.
Toelsch and Weber
Church membership demographics
- Can generally fit around a normal, working life so accessible to a range of people from social backgrounds.
- Churches tend to be more attractive to people on higher incomes who are interested in keeping society as it is and resisting social change.
Niebhur
Denominations organisational structure
- Less exclusive than a sect but don’t appeal to the whole of society like a church.
- Hierarchy of paid officials and a bureaucratic structure but some degree of democratic participation.
Niebhur
Denomination attitude to wider society
- World accomodating
- Broadly accepting societys values but usually not linked to the state.
- Usually more concerned with spiritual behaviour and everyday morality than ‘other worldly’ or entirely focused on the mortal realm.
- Accept and integrate with secular culture, living conventional lives outside their religious activities.
- May impose minor restrictions such as forbidding alcohol.
Niebhur
Denominations attitudes to other religions
- Tolerant
- Don’t claim a monopoly of truth
- See themselves as one denomination among many.
Examples of denominations
Pentecostalism
Methodism
Lutheran Church
Wilson and Troelstch
Sects organisational structure
- small exclusive group.
- No hierarchy in terms of aid officials and structure.
- More egaliatrian power structure - under the control of a single charismatic leader.
- Some are short lived e.g. when the leader dies so does the sect.
Wilson and Troelstch
Sect attitudes to wider society
- World rejecting.
- often iewed as radical groups in opposition to the wider world.
- Dominant norms and values replaced with alternative beliefs and practice.
- Schiasmatic so viewed as radical in opposition to the wider world.
Wilson and Troelstch
Sect membership requirments
- Strict entry requirmets expecting a high evel of commitment.
- Often expected to change their lifestyle and break with conventional ife becoming insular.
- Can engage with society when taking part in reruitment and fundraising.
- Tight social control of members with a risk of expulsion if people fail to conform.
Wilson and Troelstch
Sect membership demographics
- Small elitist, exclusive and close-knit memebrship
- Requires self-selection or family tradition
- Requires initiation ceremonies to show dedication.
- Often draw members from alienated minorities, the poor and marginalised communites who are looking for a sense of connection in opposition to the state.
Wilson and Troelstch
Sect attitudes to other religions
- Claim a monoply of the truth.
- Only members have access to the religious knowledge that offers the only true path to salvation.
- Usually intolerant of other religious groups and non-members.
Examples of sects
Peoples temple
Jehovas Witnesses
Mormonism
Stark and Bainbridge
Cult organisational structure
- Highly individualistic
- loosely structured
- usully small grouping around shared themes and interests but without a sharply defined belief system.
- Lack some features associated with religions e.g. buildings.
- Uually led by practitioners/ therapists who claim special knowledge acting as trainers who assist members into realising internal truths and forces.
Stark and bainbridge
Cult attitudes to wider society
- World affirming
- Offering special knowledge. insight and access t spiitual and supernatural powers within.
- Provide opportunity to be more succesful, secure and happy in society.
- No other wordly focus.
- No opposition or links with the state but some disapproval or persecution.
Stark and bainbridge
Cult membership requirments
- Little social cotrol over members.
- Highly individualistic.
- Selling services to individuals so that people can gain ‘salvation’ or other rewards.
- Little or further involvment with the cult once they have acquired their beiefs or techniques it offers.
Stark and bainbridge
Cult membership demographics
- Followers often have above average incomes.
- Feel something lacking in their otherwise succesful lives.
- Scientology has well known celebertities following and lthough they are secretive about their practices some sociologists argue the air of secrecy aims to incraese the ‘selling price’ of membership/ services.
Stark and bainbridge
Cults attitudes to other religions
- Usually tolerant f other organisations ad don’t demand strong commitment.
- Followers may belong to/ support and buy services from other religious organisations or cults.
Examples of cults
The human potential movement
Transcendental meditation movement
Scientology
Wallis
Two significnt characteristics of religious organisations
- How they see themselves
- How they are seen by wider society
How do churches and sects see themselves?
Claim that their interpretation of faith is the only correct one.
How do denominations and cults see themselves?
Accept that there can be many valid interpretations.
How are churches and denominations seen by wider society?
Seen as respectable and legitimate.
How are sects and cults seen by wider society?
Deviant
Criticisms of Troeltsch’s typology
- A lot of overlap and rigid definitions which makes categorisingorganisations difficult.
- Created based on Christian organisations so don’t work as well for different contexts.
- Outdated in postmodern society as they don’t consider an incraese in religious pluralism or the growing disconnect between religion and the state.
What does Bruce think the concept of Church is?
Outdated and should only be applied where a single religious organisation dmiates society and can reasoably clim to be adminestering to all members of society.
Bruce
Why are religions becoming absolute?
- Many Western societies are experiencing religious pluralism.
- This, alongside secularisation means organisations don’t expect/receive high levels of commitment.
- It becomes difficult for a state to lend exclusive support.
- Churches are historical phenomena
which will fade out of modern society.