Booklet 1 - Theories Of Religion Flashcards
Functional definition of religion
The social and physiological functions it performs for society - integration and comfort
How does Durkheim define religion?
In terms of the contribution it makes to social integration rather than any specific belief in God or the supernatural
Yinger definition of religion
Identifies functions that religion performs for individuals such as answering ‘ultimate questions’ about the meaning of life and what happens when we die
Substantive definition of religion
Focuses on what religion actually is
Weber definition of religion
Belief in a superior or supernatural power that is above nature and can’t be explained scientifically
Construct definition of religion
The focus is on a process of understanding how a set of beliefs comes to exist
What does Aldridge show about Scientology?
For its followers Scientology is a religion whereas several governments have denied legal status as a religion and sought to ban it - shows definitions of religion can be contested and are influenced by who has the power to define a situation
What are the functions of religion according to Durkheim?
- Social integration/ cohesion
- Collective conscience - provides moral values for stability
- Agent of secondary socialisation
What are Durkheim 4 main ideas on religion?
- The sacred and the profane
- Totemism
- Collective conscience
- Cognitive functions
The sacred and the profane
- sacred things inspire feelings of awe, wonder and fear
- profane = no special significance
- humans place significance on sacred objects or symbols
- religion tells us what’s sacred and normal e.g. bottle of wine at mass and at a supermarket
- religion seperates the profane and sacred
Totemism
- Durkheim studied the Arunta Aboriginal Tribe - worship a totem which is the clans emblem representing their identity or origins
- rituals reinforce the clans sense of belonging and solidarity
-Durkheim - when worshipping their totem they are worshipping society - feelings of awe and wonder are the groups power
Collective conscience
- shared norms, values and beliefs and knowledge that make living possible
- Durkheim - regular rituals and moral codes reinforce the collective conscience and maintain social integration
- breaking moral codes brings consequences
- religion helps the individual feel a part of something bigger than themselves
Cognitive functions of religion
- Durkheim believed religion was the origin of concepts and categories we need for reasoning, understanding the world and communication
- argues people need concepts to make sense of the world and we share these concepts to communicate effectively
- religion provides these concepts and so religion is the origin of human thought, reason and science
Durkheim on Nationalism
Durkheim argues that nationalism was a type of religion - a civil religion because it has similar functions to more conventional religions
Criticisms of Durkheim
- stretched the definition to include beliefs with no supernatural element
- despite similarities nationalism doesn’t provide ultimate meanings about the purpose of life or explanations of the origin of the universe
What did Malinowski believe about religion
He agreed with Durkheim that religion reinforces social norms/ values and promotes social solidarity however religion also has a psychological function
What did Malinowski argue was the main reason for rleigion?
to help individuals and society deal with the emotional stresses which occur during life crises e.g. birth or death
What did Malinowski argue was the second function of rleigion?
to help people deal with situations or events which could not be fully controlled or predicted.
What are the 2 functions of religion Parsons identifies?
- Creates and legitimises society’s values - ingrained through socialisation - breaking religious and social rules = a guilty conscience having an almost controlling influence over people
- Provides primary source of meaning- answers big questions to maintain a sense of justice and social stability - ‘mechanism of adjustment’ to help people make sense of uncontrollable life events
What did Bellah argue about civil religion?
it integrates society in a way other religions and denominations can’t
How do Marxists see religion?
As a feature of only class divided society
What is an ideology?
A set of values shared by a social group that:
- Provides a particular view of seeing and interpreting the world
- Presents only a particular or incomplete or false view of reality
- Expresses and justifies the interests of a particular group (social or political)
Religion as part of the dominant ideology
Marx - bourgeoisie control the creation and spread of ideas through institutions like the church and media
- Dominant ruling class ideology creates a false consciousness preventing the poor from taking action
Power as divinely appointed
- Religious teachings encourage the proletariat to believe the way society is organised is Gods will.
- Whilst some struggle in this life they are blessed and will be rewarded for their faith.
- Religion also makes the power of the dominant class appear divinely ordained e.g. 16th century idea of the divine right of the King