BONHOEFFER: ISSUES Flashcards
Give two reasons why Christians should not practice civil disobedience.
1) St Paul letter to Romans: “whoever rebels against that authority is rebelling against God.”
2) God’s law is reflected in man’s law.
Give two reasons why Christians should practice civil disobedience.
1) Jesus often spoke out against the status quo.
2) Luther: “Here I stand, I can do no other.”
Give one reason why it is not always possible to know God’s will.
1) Bonhoeffer could be seen as dangerously encouraging individuals with distorted views of God’s will.
Give one reason why it is always possible to know God’s will.
1) Bonhoeffer advocated a life in community, based on shared reflection and readings of scripture.
Give two reasons why Bonhoeffer places too much emphasis on suffering.
1) Bonhoeffer was writing in a period of extreme suffering, causing this overemphasis.
2) Most Christians need to live their lives in ‘everyday’ circumstances.
Give two reasons why Bonhoeffer does not place too much emphasis on suffering.
1) Everyone experiences suffering in their life.
2) Jesus told people to take up their crosses and follow him.
How can Bonhoeffer’s theology be seen as relevant?
Bonhoeffer’s powerful challenge to abandon self-interest might lead to people living a more meaningful life.
How can Bonhoeffer’s theology be seen as relevant? (2)
- Bonhoeffer’s powerful challenge to abandon self-interest might lead to people living a more meaningful life.
- Inequality in the world is a reality.
How can Bonhoeffer’s theology be seen as irrelevant today? (2)
- Bonhoeffer was working in extreme circumstances.
2. Christians should never assume that they will disobey.
What is the link to terrorism?
In an age of terrorism and extremism this feels like a dangerous idea - to encourage disobedience to the state.
What is questionable about civil disobedience?
How would we view those that choose to disobey the British government because it goes against the holy law of their religion.
