Bond Issues Flashcards

1
Q

What is a Bond?

A

A negotiable debt instrument representing a chose in action.

Lecture Notes.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

What are the Chief Commercial Differences between a Bond and a Loan?

A
  • Privacy: Loans are private transactions, unlike Bonds, making them better for confidential objectives.°
  • Anonymity: Bondholders are often anonymous to the Borrower, unlike with Loans.°°
  • Transferability: Bonds are significantly more exchangeable than Loans.°°°
  • Flexibility: Loans are more customizable than Bonds, offering multiple currencies or revolving structures that Bonds cannot.
  • Legal Status: Certain types of firms are disallowed from publicly issuing Bonds, whereas no such restriction exists for Loans.°°°°
  • Cost of Capital: Due the diffusion of risk among more investors, Bonds are safer than Loans, and therefore, less costly for Borrowers.
  • Terms and Conditions: Loan provisions (particularly R&Ws, EODs, and Covenants) are usually more favorable to Creditors than Bond provisions.°°°°°

I define ‘Investors’ as Propsective Bondholders.

P. 538.
° Bear in mind the exception of Private Placements.
°° Bear in mind the exception of Funded Participations.
°°° This is despite the various Methods of Transfer available to Lenders.
°°°° §755 – Companies Act (CA) 2006; §75(3) – Financial Services and Markets Act (FSMA) 2000.
°°°°° Bond provisions are usually looser because of the form factor’s inherent issues with collective action.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

What are the Chief Commercial Differences between a Bond and a Share Issuance?

A
  • Security: Bonds may be secured, whereas shares are not.
  • Creditor Priority: Bonds rank ahead of Shares in insolvency.
  • Repayment: Bonds must be repayed, while Shares do not (winding up and capital reduction notwithstanding).
  • Interest vs. Dividends: Interest repayment is mandatory, whereas dividends distribution is optional.
  • Issuing at a Discount: Bonds may be issued at a discount, whereas a Shares cannot be issued below their par value.

P. 542.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Who are the Parties Involved in a Bond Issuance?

A
  • Issuer.
  • Bondholders.
  • Manager(s).
  • Underwriter(s).
  • Lead Manager.
  • Lead Underwriter.
  • Fiscal Agent.
  • Paying Agent.
  • Bond Trustee(s).
  • Security Trustee(s).
  • Centralized Security Depository.

This list is comprehensive, not exhaustive.

Lecture Notes.

Hereafter, the term ‘Syndicate of Managers’ will be used to refer to both the Lead Manager and all other Managers.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

What are the Documents Involved in a Bond Issuance?

A
  • Indenture.
  • Mandate(s).
  • Legal Opinions.
  • Escrow Agreement.
  • Underwriting Agreement(s).
  • Prospectus / Offering Circular.
  • Credit Rating Agency (CRA) Reports.
  • Bond Trust Deed / Fiscal Agency Agreement / Paying Agency Agreement.

This list is comprehensive, not exhaustive.

Lecture Notes.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

What are the Various Stages of a Bond Issuance?

A
  1. The Mandate: The Issuer hires the Lead Manager (among other parties) to arrange the Issuance, who will create the Prospectus.
  2. Due Diligence: The various parties exchange data to inform their decision-making.
  3. Launch: If it is a Public Offering, the Lead Manager announces the Issuance to the markets, or otherwise invites investors to subscribe.
  4. Listing: If it is a Public Offering, the Lead Manager follows the relevant procedures to obtain permission to list.
  5. Signing: The Subscription Agreement (SA) and Agreement Among Managers (AAM) are executed.
  6. Closing: The Issuance comes into effect, the Issuer receives the proceeds, and the Bondholders receive their securities.

P. 557.

Repeated direct reference is made to the Lead Manager, but other parties are involved to varying degrees throuhgout the stages.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

For the Secondary Purchaser of a Bond, what is its Chief Concern?

A

Obtaining good title and treatment as the unencumbered owner.

Really, this applies to all trades, but is especially improtant here.

P. 543.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What is the Difference between a Standalone and a Programmed Issuance?

A

A standalone is a singular instance of selling Bonds, whereas a Programme is a series of instances.

P. 556.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Standalone and Programmed Issuances?

A

Standalone Issuances are:
* More customizable because they need not accommodate future iteraitons;
* More costly due to their smaller scale but similar transaction costs;
* Less liquid because there are fewer securities; and
* Less diversified because there are fewer types of securities.

The exact opposite applies to Programmed Issuances.

Lecture Notes.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

What is the Difference between a Private Placement and a Public Offering?

A

A Private Placement distributes securities to a limited number of investors, whereas a Public Offering distributes them to the investing public.

P. 556.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Private Placements and Public Offerings?

A

Private Placements are:
* Less regulatorily involved due to their private nature;
* More customizable for the same reason;
* Catered toward a specialist class of investors, which should increase efficiency;
* Less liquid due to the small investor base;
* Smaller in quantum for the same reason;
* Less visible to capital markets; and
* More costly due to the specialized demographic and lower liquidity.

The exact opposite applies to Public Offerings.

Lecture Notes.

Public Offerings may also be more tax-friendly.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Listing a Bond Issuance on an Exchange?

A

Advantages:
* Greater liquidity, visibility, and lower cost of capital due to exposure to a deeper pool of investors.
* Greater reputation, due to the act of listing itself and association with the Exchange.

Disadvantages:
* Greater transaction costs, due to listing costs and increased regulatory compliance.
* Greater exposure to market volatility.
* Loss of control over the pricing and distribution of bonds.

Lecture Notes.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Who Arranges the Issuance?

A

The Lead Manager, who coordinates with the Managers and other members of the Selling Group to perform this function.

Lecture Notes.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

What is the Selling Group?

A

The collective responsible for marketing and selling Bonds to investors, usually comprised of (Lead) Managers and (Lead) Underwriters.

Lecture Notes.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

What governs the Issuer’s relationship with the Lead Manager and Selling Group?

A

Its Mandate with each respective party.

P. 556.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

What will the Mandates collectively address?

A
  • How the Issuance will be priced.
  • The Issuance’s target demograhpic
  • The Prospectus, what it will contain, and how it will be legally treated.
  • The scope of the counterpartys’ rights and obligations (incl. other T&Cs).
  • Whether the Issuance will:
    • Be listed.
    • Be underwritten and to what extent.
    • Use a Bond Trustee or a Fiscal Agent.
    • Be secured, indemnified, or guaranteed and to what extent.

This list is general, not comprehensive.

Lecture Notes.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

What is the Prospectus?

Otherwise known as an ‘Offering Circular’.

A

A document for Investors that provides detailed legal and financial information regarding the Issuance.

Lecture Notes.

An Offering Circular, or Offering Memorandum, is effectively a Prospectus used in a Private Placement.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

What is the Commercial Purpose of the Prospectus?

A
  • Facilitate due diligence.
  • Comply with regulatory requirements
  • Establish the Issuer and Issuance’s credibility.
  • Generate Investor interest and market the Issuance.

Lecture Notes.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

Is it Compulsory to create a Prospectus?

A

Yes. Offering a security to the public or listing a security on a regulated exchange requires a Prospectus.

Exceptions nothwithstanding

Lecture Notes.

Art. 3 – EC Prospectus Regulation (ECPR) 2017; LR 4.2 – UK Listing Rules.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

What constitues an Offer of Securities to the Public?

A
  • A message, delivered in any format;
  • That provides enough detail about the terms and conditions of a security;
  • To allow the recipient to make an informed decision on whether to purchase.

Art. 2(1)(d) – ECPR 2017.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

When is an Issuance exempt from having to create a Prospectus?

A

When it is offered:
* Solely to Qualified Investors.
* By governments or local authorities.
* To fewer than 150 persons per Member State other than Qualified Investors.
* With a minimum denomination of at least €100,000.
* While already trading on a regulated EU market.
* In a continuous or repeated manner where the total consideration per credit institution is less than €75m p/a.

See Art. 1(4) – ECPR 2017.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

Should Investors assume the Prospectus contains all Relevant Information regarding the Issuer or Issuance?

A

No. It should not be taken as containing, “everything that anyone might think relevant.”

Accordingly, claiming misrepresentation will prove quite difficult.

Raiffeisen v RBS [2010] EWHC 1392 (Comm) at [92]-[93].

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

In Principle, what Information must a Prospectus contain?

A

All information necessary for an Investor to evaluate the Issuer’s financial condition, the Issuance’s terms, and its purpose and impact.

Art. 6(1) – ECPR 2017.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

How must the Prospectus be written?

A

In an easily analysable, concise and comprehensible way.

Art. 6(2) – ECPR 2017.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
Q

Must the Prospectus be presented in a single document?

A

No, in which case, it must be divided into a:
* Registration document;
* Securities note; and
* Summary.

Art. 6(3) – ECPR 2017.

This is important for Programmed Issuances, as it allows the Issuer to draft a Base Prospectus (see Art. 8) that it may amend with time, rather than create a new Prospectus with every instance.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
26
Q

Regarding the Prospectus, what is the Regulator’s role?

A

It must approve the Prospectus before it may be published.

The relevant Regulator is the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).

Art. 7 (among others) – ECPR 2017.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
27
Q

Who must accept Responsibility for the Information contained in the Prospectus?

A
  • Those involved in the Issuance who control what information the Prospectus contains.
  • These persons must be clearly identified by name, function, and registered office; and
  • They must declare that, to the best of their knowledge, the information presented is true and no material omissions are made.

Art. 11 (1) – ECPR 2017.

The Issuer, and to a lesser degree the Lead Manager, are most susceptible to claims of misstatement or misrepresentation under §90 & Sch. 10 – FSMA 2000.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
28
Q

What is Stabilization?

A

The process of preserving a security’s price near its offering price, usually following an intentional over-allotment.

This takes place at, or near, the time the Issuance closes.

P. 569.

This is permitted by Art. 5 – EU Market Abuse Regulation (MAR) (2014) and §137Q – FSMA 2000.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
29
Q

What is the Commercial Purpose of Stablization?

A
  • Decrease price volatility.
  • Decrease market volatility.
  • Maintain investor confidence.
  • Reduce Underwriters’ risk of price-related losses.
  • Increase the Issuance’s probability and appearance of success.

Lecture Notes.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
30
Q

Who is usually Responsible for Stablization?

A

The Lead Manager, in its discretion, as outlined under the SA and AAM.

The Lead Underwriter, Underwriters, and Managers may also be involved.

P. 569.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
31
Q

At closing, what Instruments are created to represent the Issuance?

A
  • The Temporary Global Bond (TGB).
  • The Permanent Global Bond (PGB).

The latter follows the former usually after 40 days.

P. 573.

These are Bearer Instrument, meaning whoever holds them, in theory, is also entitled to payment under them.

32
Q

Which Document governs the TGB’s and PGB’s form, terms, and conditions?

A

The Trust Deed or Fiscal Agency Agreement, as the case may be.

33
Q

Who holds the TGB and PGB?

A

A Common Depository.

P. 573.

34
Q

What is a Common Depository?

A

A firm that provides centralized custody and settlement services for securities.

This role is usually filled by a Centralized Security Depository (CSD).

Lecture Notes.

35
Q

What is a Clearing System?

A

A system for the settlement of securities.

This role is usually filled by a Centralized Security Depository (CSD).

P. 548.

36
Q

What is a Centralized Security Depository?

A

A system for the depositing, settlement, and safekeeping of securities.

P. 547.

They are either Domestic (DCSD) or International (ICSD). Prime examples include Euroclear and Clearstream.

37
Q

What is the Function of Centralized Secuirty Depositories?

A

To electronically represent whole Issuances, thereby facilitating transferability, transparency, and efficiency.

P. 548.

38
Q

Are all Centralized Security Depositories also Clearing Systems and Common Depositories?

A

As so defined herein, yes. However, bear in mind that this is not necessarily true in practice.

Lecture Notes.

I have chosen to define them as such because the largest CSDs, like Clearstream or Euroclear, that experience the most traffic are also Clearing Systems.

39
Q

What is a Dematerialized Security?

A

An entirely digital security, i.e. one without a physical underlying instrument to evidence its authenticity.

P. 547.

40
Q

Which Document contains the Issuance’s Terms and Conditions?

A

The Indenture.

Lecture Notes.

41
Q

Broadly, what does the Indenture pertain to?

A

The Parties’ rights and obligations, most importantly:
* Events of Default.
* Interest and Principal.
* Covenants and Undertakings.
* Voting and Bondholder Meetings.
* Title, Status, and Ranking of the Bonds.
* Redemption, Purchase, and Payments by the Issuer.

This list is not exhaustive.

P. 575.

42
Q

In an Indenture, what does Title pertain to?

A

Who the Bearer is, i.e. who is owed the payment obligation.

P. 575.

This will usually be the Common Depository.

43
Q

What is a No-Look-Through Clause?

A

A provision stating that:
* The Issuer’s payment obligations are owed solely to the CSD (Bearer); and that
* Each Accountholder (Bondholder) must look to the CSD for payment.

P. 549; Secure Capital v Credit Suisse [2015] EWHC 388.

44
Q

In an Indenture, what does Status pertain to?

A

Whether the Bonds are secured, and if so, by what.

P. 575.

This may be referenced separately in the Security Trust Deed.

45
Q

In an Indenture, what does Ranking pertain to?

A

Whether the Bonds are subordinated, and if so, how.

P. 575.

This may be referenced separately in the Bond Trust Deed or Fiscal Agency Agreement.

46
Q

In an Indenture, what does Redemption pertain to?

A

The Issuer’s ability to repurchase, and thereby cancel, its debt.

P. 576.

47
Q

In an Indenture, what do Voting Provisions pertain to?

A

The Parties’ ability to call Bondholder Meetings and make decisions thereat.

This may be referenced separately in the Bond Trust Deed or Fiscal Agency Agreement.

48
Q

Usually, who may call a Bondholder Meeting?

A
  • The Issuer; or
  • The Bond Trustee, whether:
    • Of its own volition; or
    • On behalf of specified proportion of Bondholders:

P. 576.

49
Q

Why would the Bond Trustee elect to a call a Bondholder Meeting?

A
  • Either because it cannot act without the Bondholders’ express direction; or because
  • It seeks clarification regarding what they wish it to do in a given situation.

P. 576.

This is a way to minimise its discretion, and thereby, its potential for liability.

50
Q

In a Vote, must the Majority pay mind to the Interests of the Minority?

A

Yes. The Majority owes them a duty of good faith, which entails acting fairly and accounting for their legitimate interests.

BAN Corp. v MJ O’Brien [1927] AC 369.

51
Q

In a Vote, when may the Majority pursue its own Interests?

A

When, after acting farily and considering the Minority’s interests,° the Majority still finds a bona fide commercial justification for its actions.°°

° RBS v Highland Financial [2013] EWCA Civ 328.
°° Redwood v TD Bank [2002] EWHC 2703.

52
Q

Can a Bondholder enjoy Disproportionate Voting Powers?

A

Yes, but only if it is transparent and freely negotiated by all parties.

Re Southern Pacific [2013] EWHC 2485 (Ch).

53
Q

When is an Inducement to Vote considered Legitimate?

A

If it:
* Is openly and equally promised to all Bondholders; and
* Is not intended to unduly influence or unfairly advantage any one Bondholder or class of Bondholders.

Re ST Property Investment Trust [2003] EWHC 2237 (Ch); BAN Corp. v MJ O’Brien [1927] AC 369.

54
Q

When can the Court intervene in a Vote, or otherwise, on Grounds of Unfairness or Oppression?

A

If the relevant action is both deliberately and manifestly mala fide, although this is a very high bar to meet.

Assénagon v Irish Bank [2012] EWHC 2090 (Ch).

The bar is difficult to meet because of cases like Redwood, which tell us that if the Majority is pursuing a legitimate commercial interest, it will not suffer liability.

55
Q

What is a No-Action Clause?

A

A provision disallowing Bondholders from enforcing against the Issuer unless the Trustee, having become bound to act, fails to do so.

P. 583; Re Colt Telecom [2002] EWHC 2815 (Ch).

56
Q

What is the Commercial Purpose of the No-Action Clause?

A
  • Minimize the Issuer’s legal exposures.
  • Resolve the Mad Bondholder Problem.
  • Prevent fragmentation betwen Bondholders.
  • Promote efficient administration and collective acation.

Lecture Notes.

The Mad Bondholder Problem describes when one Bondholder takes actions that may harm themselves, other Bondholders, and the Issuer.

57
Q

How should a No-Action Clause be drafted?

A

To convey that:
* Bondholders, individually and collectively, are barred from pursuing action both before and after an EOD; with respect to,
* Any claim or procedure it may wish to assert against the Issuer regarding Bonds or Issuance; unless,
* The Trustee, having become bound to act, fails to do so.

P. 589.

58
Q

When may a Bond Trustee modify the Indenture or waive a breach?

A

When the relevant matter is, according to its discretion, formal, minor, technical, or otherwise not materially prejudicial to the Bondholders’ interests.

P. 583.

Something is considered materially prejudicial if it has a significant impact on the Bondholders’ rights or interests, such as their ability to receive payment or to enforce their rights in case of an EOD.

59
Q

When is something considered Materially Prejudicial to Bondholders’ Interests?

A

When it has, or may have, a significant impact on their rights or interests, most notably their ability to receive payment of principal and interest

The classic example is a late payment.

Lecture Notes.

° Re Lehman Brothers [2012] EWHC 2998 (Ch), at [1135].

60
Q

Which Document concerns the Purchase of the Bonds?

A

The Subscription Agreement.

P. 579.

It concerns such things as price, prerequisites to purchase (CPs, R&Ws, etc.), and the like.

61
Q

Who are the Parties to the Subscription Agreement?

A

The Issuer and the Syndicate of Managers.

P. 579.

It is entered into at the signing.

62
Q

How does the liability of a Syndicate of Managers to an Issuer differ from that of a Syndicate of Lenders to a Borrower?

A

A Syndicate of Managers is jointly and severally liable to the Issuer for the whole sum of the Issuance.

P. 579.

63
Q

How does an Issuer’s ability to enforce the Subscription Agreement differ from that of a Borrower and its Loan Agreement?

A

The Issuer has statutory recourse to specific performance.

P. 580; §740, §738 – CA 2006

However, this power is likely confined to companies registered under the Companies Act 2006.

64
Q

Which Document governs the Syndicate of Managers?

A

The Agreement Amongst Managers.

P. 580.

65
Q

Broadly, what do the Agreement Among Managers pertain to?

A

The Parties’ rights and obligations, most importantly:
* The division of fees and commissions.
* Their subscription liabilities to the Issuer.
* Their roles and responsibilities in the Issuance.

This list is not exhaustive.

P. 581.

66
Q

What are the Differences between a Bond Trustee and a Fiscal Agent?

A
  • A Fiscal Agent (and Paying Agent) is appointed by the Issuer and acts as its Agent; whereas
  • A Bond Trustee is appointed by the Bondholders and acts as their Fiduciary.
67
Q

What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of using a Trustee in an Issuance?

A

Advantages:
* Facilitates transferability.
* Perserves Bondholder anonymity.
* Facilitates the use of security.
* Facilitates subordination, particularly in liquidation.°
* Circumvents capital adequacy requirements for Bondholders.
* Allows the Issuer to deal with a single counterparty.
* Facilitates efficiency due to the Trustee’s specialist expertise.
* Mitigates collective action problems for Bondholders, particularly since it must treat them all equally.°°

Disadvantages:
* Trusts are not universally recognized.
* The Trustee will not act in the Issuer’s favor.

P. 583.
° See Re British & Commonwealth Holdings [1992] 1 WLR 672.
°° Bristol v Mothew [1998] Ch 1, at [19].

68
Q

What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of not using a Trustee in an Issuance?

A

Advantages:
* Fewer expenses.
* Permits a Divide and Conquer strategy for the Issuer vis-à-vis the Bondholders.

Disadvantages:
* Increases risk of dispute.

P. 583.

In a normal unsecured Issuance with a strong Issuer, there should be no need for a Bond Trustee.

69
Q

Who is Party to the Bond Trust Deed?

A

The Issuer and the Bond Trustee.

70
Q

Broadly, what does the Bond Trust Deed pertain to?

A

The Parties’ rights and obligations, most importantly:
* Security.
* Events of default.
* The Trustee’s discretions.
* Information undertakings.
* Payment of principal and interest.

This list is not exhaustive.

Lecture Notes.

Many of the Bond Trustee’s duties and discretions, like the duty of care or fiduciary duties, and the legal exposures that arise therefrom, are effectively the same as the Agent Bank in a Syndicated Loan. To avoid repetition, simply refer to that Deck.

71
Q

How may a Bond Trustee limit the Legal Risk that arises from its Fiduciary Duties?

A

By restrictively defining, modifying, limiting, or excluding them using clear and unequivocal language.

With the exception of dishonesty or lack of good faith, naturally.

P. 593. Henderson v Merrett Syndicates [1995] 2 AC 145; Armitrage v Nurse [1998] Ch 241.

Contra preferentum applying.

72
Q

What are the Statutory Restrictions on Limiting or Excluding Liability for Fiduciary Duties?

A

The Bond Trustee cannot alter its duty of care

P. 595.

° §750 – CA 2006; Accordingly, if it delegates functions or relies on advice or inforamtion, it will be held liable if it did so unresasonbly.

The Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 would not apply because all this takes place in the realm of equity. See Baker v JR Clark [2006] EWCA Civ 464.

73
Q

Are Bond Trustees held to an Ordinary Duty of Care?

A

No. As Professional Trustees, they are held to a higher standard.

Bartlett v Barclays Bank [1980] Ch 515, at [534].

74
Q

Regarding Events of Default, what role does the Bond Trustee’s discretion play?

A
  • Type 1: Certain events will only constitute EODs if Bond Trustee certifies them as such.
  • Type 2: Certain EODs will only be actionable if Bond Trustee believes they are unremediable.
  • Type 3: Absent instruction, EODs may be accelerated if the Bond Trustee believes it wise.
  • Type 4: The Bond Trustee may demand indemnity against countersuit by the Issuer before enforcing.

This list is not comprehensive

P. 598; Law Debenture v Acciona [2004] EWHC 270 (Ch), at [41]-[56].

75
Q

When may a Type 1 Discretion be exercised?

A
  • When an event is verified to exist; and
  • It is materially prejudicial to the Bondholders’ interests.

P. 599; P. 598; Law Debenture v Acciona [2004] EWHC 270 (Ch), at [41]-[42].

This may require investigation on the Bond Trustee’s part, but it is under no duty to actively monitor the Issuer’s condition, largely relying on Compliance Certificates from its Board.

76
Q

When may a Type 4 Discretion be exercised?

A

When the Issuer’s prospective claim(s), whether under English law or otherwise, may succeed.

P. 601; Concord Trust v Law Debenture [2005] UKHL 27, at [34]-[35], [36]-[45].

77
Q

Can a Bond Trutee’s exercise of discretion be overturned?

A

Yes, if it failed to give proper consideration to the circumstances.

This is known as the Rule in Pitt v Holt.

P. 602; Pitt v Holt [2013] UKSC 26.