Block 3 SocPop Flashcards
Define bias
Any trend in the collection, analysis, interpretation, publication of review of data that can lead to conclusions, that are systematically different from the truth
Define confounding factor
A confounding factor is something that is associated with both the exposure and the outcome
Compare deterministic vs stochastic approaches to causality
Deterministic:
- Inevitability
- Validation of hypothesis by systematic observations to predict with certainty future events
- Newtonian thinking
- Mechanistic - can take apart to study
- Objective, quantifiable and certain
- Whole is sum of parts
- Very useful in thinking about a single cause for a single disease
- Eg. tubercle bacillus is the the cause of tuberculosis
Stochastic:
- Probability
- Assessment of hypothesis by systematic observations to give risk of future events
- Quantum thinking
- Whole greater than sum of parts
- Probabilities
- Systems theory; complexity theory, the observer influences the observed, emergent phenomena
- eg. overcrowded accommodation increases incidence of tuberculosis
Describe Bradford Hill’s Criteria for Inferring Causality (1965)
Bradford Hill’s Criteria for Inferring Causality (1965)
Group of minimal conditions necessary to provide adequate evidence of a causal relationship between an incidence and a consequence.
Criteria that make a causal link more likely:
Association features:
1. Strength of association – commonly measure by rate ratio or odds
ratio
2. Specificity of association – disease associated with one specific factor
3. Consistency of association – observed in different studies and
different sub-groups
Exposure/outcome
- Temporal sequence – exposure to the putative cause has be shown to precede the outcome
- Dose response – different levels of exposure to the putative factor lead to different risk of acquiring the outcome
- Reversibility – removal or prevention of the putative factor leads to a reduced or non-existent risk of acquiring the outcome, strongest evidence for a causal link
Other evidence
1. Coherence of theory – association confirms with current knowledge
2. Biological plausibility – biologically plausible mechanism is likely or
demonstrated
3. Analogy – analogy exists wit other disease, species or settings
o E.g. epidemiology of Hepatitis B virus was successfully used to predict how HIV virus would spread
Describe reverse causality
Reverse Causality
High correlation between unemployment and mental illness o Is it because mental illness causes unemployment
OR
o Is it because unemployment causes mental illness o Both are true!
What is the hierarchy of evidence?
- Systematic reviews
- Experimental studies
a. Randomised Controlled Trials
b. Controlled trials - Observational studies
a. Cohort studies
b. Case control studies - Descriptive studies
a. Cross sectional
b. (Qualitative studies)
What are the different types of bias?
- Selection
- information
- Confounding
Selection - Design phase, execution
- Admission
- Prevalence/incidence
- Detection
- Volunteer
- Loss to follow up
Information – data collection phase
- Interviewer
- Questionnaire
- Recall
- Diagnostic suspicion
- Exposer
What are lay beliefs/knowledge?
- Beliefs are things we believe to be true
- Perspectives of ‘ordinary’ people
- Often complex and sophisticated
- May be sensible or irrational
- E.g. I’m thin therefore I’m not at risk of heart disease
Where do lay beliefs/knowledge come from?
- Rooted in socio-cultural contexts in which we live
- Shaped by people’s:
a. place in society
b. culture
c. personal biography (experience)
d. social identify eg gender, sexuality, ethnicity, occupation - Can be informed by medical and health knowledge
Define culture. And what is culture’s role in health beliefs?
Definition
values, norms, and traditions that affect how individuals of a particular group perceive, think, interact, behave, and make judgments about their world (Chamberlain 2005 p197).
Role in health beliefs:
Culture shapes the way we think, feel and experience our lives.
Why is it important for doctors to know lay beliefs/knowledge?
- Insights into needs of your patients: a. information and support
- Influence health seeking behaviour:
a. How people respond to symptoms
b. Decisions about consulting
c. Expectations about treatment
d. Concordance with treatment plans
How does health seeking behaviour ‘symptom iceberg’ influence on whether patients visit a doctor?
1/3 will respond to symptomSee GP (or other healthcare professional)
2/3 will NOT respond to symptoms by seeing a clinician even if they indicate something serious:
1. Do nothing
2. self medicate
3. consult someone else e.g. parent, friend
What are some social triggers to seeking medical help?
- Interference with social and personal relationships
- Interference with vocational or physical activity
- ‘Sanctioning’ by others – influence of lay referral system
- A ‘temporalising’ of symptomology
- Interpersonal crisis
Define health behaviours. What are the 3 types of health behaviours?
“Behaviours that are related to the health status of the individual” (Ogden, 2007).
3 types:
- Good health behaviours e.g. sleeping 8 hour/day
- Health protective behaviours e.g. wearing seatbelt
- Health impairing habits e.g. smoking
What is the dual pathway model?
Two broad ways in which psychological processes may influence physical health
- Direct path: stress having a direct impact on physical health
- Indirect: stress resulting in change in Behaviour e.g. drinking alcohol impact on physical health.
What are the four groups of determinants of social behaviour?
- Background factors: Characteristics that define the context in which
people live their lives - Stable factors: Individual differences (personality) in psychological
activity that are stable over time and context - Social factors: Social connections in the immediate environment
- Situational factors: Appraisal of personal relevance that shape
responses in a specific situation
What are individual differences (stable factors)?
Stable factors: Individual differences (personality)
1. variations between people in psychological activities that, within
people, produce responses that are stable across time and context
2. Influence appraisal in 3 ways:
a. they determine if, and to what extent, an event is salient, i.e. sensitivity towards particular types of event
b. they provide a generalised framework for understanding and evaluating the event, e.g. as threat or challenge
c. they make available, or suggest, potential responses, i.e. initial response options
Types of individual differences
- Emotional dispositions: Psychological processes involved in both the experience and expressionpresent
- Generalised expectancies: Psychological processes involved in formulating expectations in relation to future outcomes future
- Explanatory styles: Psychological processes involved in explaining the causes of negative eventspast
What are the 5 different emotional dispositions (OCEAN)?
Openness to new experiences - Intellect and interest in culture; artistic, curious, imaginative, wide range of interest.
Conscientiousness - The will to achieve; self disciplined, efficient, organised, reliable, thorough
Extroversion - Outgoing; talkative, enthusiastic, seeking excitement, assertive and active
Agreeableness - Loving, friendly and compliant; sympathetic, appreciative, trusting, kind, forgiving, generous
Neuroticism - Experience more negative emotions; anxious, tense, worried, hostile, self-pitying, vulnerable
What is locus of control?
- Expectations that future outcomes will be determined by factors that are either internal (self) or external (powerful others, and chance)
- associated with more favourable outcomes, and performance of health behaviours, but is dependent on situational factors
- People with an internal locus of control believe:
a. they are responsible for their own health,
b. Illness can be avoided by taking care of themselves
c. ill health results in part from not eating correctly or not getting
enough exercise (Hayes and Ross, 1987).
What is self-efficacy?
Belief in one’s own ability to organise and execute a course of action, and the expectation that the action will result in, or lead to, a desired outcome
What are the social cognition theories?
• attempt to explain the relationship between social cognitions (e.g. beliefs, attitudes, goals, etc.) and behaviour • there are 3: 1. health belief model HBM 2. theory of planned behaviour 3. transtheoretical model
What is the difference between social carers (paid carers) and unpaid carers?
Paid carers (social care workers): include staff who work with people in residential care homes, in day centres and who provide personal care in someone’s home.
Unpaid carers:
‘Carers provide unpaid care by looking after an ill, frail or disabled family member, friend or partner
What are the main types of carers?
- Unpaid or paid
- Non-contractual or contractual
- Private or public