Before Midterm (end at cost benefit) Flashcards
what are the roles of government in terms of business & society (5) & Examples
- Provides a stable trading environment, ie rule of law, macroeconomic policy, interest rates.
- Provides certain goods & services, i.e. National defence, education & health care
- Regulations: Labour laws, finances, competition
- Taxes & Subsidies: Funding, reduce unwanted behaviour
- Redistribution of wealth & provides funding for under privileged sectors
Economic Rational Agent means
Selfishly maximizing my own anticipated utility
Surplus Transaction
The extra benefit that arises feom the difference between the utility of having the good & the utility of the transaction price
Social Welfare
The sum of everyone’s utility
A free Market is one where transactions are
Voluntary
The outcome from trade will not be Pareto-Efficient when (4)
- Imperfect competition
- Asymmetrical info
- Externalities
- Public Goods
What is a problem associated with rational agents participating in a free market
They may fail to maximize social welfare
Why do we create institutions?
Govern how transactions take place
What are the drawbacks of institutions and policies
Costly & we need to make trade-offs against gains we get from fixing market failures against the costs.
We have to be wary that they may be serving the special interests of certain groups or bureaucrats
What are policies?
A set of rules creates and enforced by a governing body.
Normative Analysis
What policy should do
Positive Analysis
What policy actually does
What type of rules do we want to design and what does that mean?
We want them to be “fair” and “efficient”, this means we often need to make trade-offs between adding additional welfare with the cost of implementing the policy
Incentives
Linking an agent’s utility to some action or outcome
Opportunity Cost
The utility an agent gets by doing the next best alternative with their time/effort
Willingness-to-pay
The total utility an agent gets from a good, expressed in dollars
Being a rational agent, I get paid a flat wage for teaching this class. How hard should I work?
Bare minimum to collect your pay cheque due to opportunity costs & incentives
I decide to sell you your grades. I know your willingness-to-pay (for each of you). I can name one price for everyone. How much should I charge?
You should charge everyone a price above the minimum of our willingness-to-pay. “Imperfect competition” & “monopoly pricing”
I assign you all to groups and say that I’ll assign you a collective grade for the debates based solely on your collective performance. You value an A more than a B, and so on, down the grade scale, but failing means your parents will yell at you forever (so
you experience −∞ utility). Effort is costly to you. How much effort should you exert in your group?
Some effort but not enough to do my fair-share to get my group an A. There is a problem in regards to information, externalities & an incentive to free-ride
Opportunity Cost
The opportunity cost of X is the amount of Y given up to get X, where Y is the best alternative to X.
Opportunity versus “accounting” costs. (3)
- Units of measurement (opportunity costs might not be express in $)
- Opportunity costs EXCLUDE sunk costs.
- Opportunity costs INCLUDE costs for which there is no observed outlay.
Your rich aunt gives you $200 to spend in NYC. Broadway shows cost $98. Movies cost $14. What is the
opportunity cost of the Broadway show?
7 movies
Suppose you spend $98 on a ticket. Upon arriving at the theatre, you
realize you forgot the ticket at home. There is no time to get it.
Someone offers to sell you a ticket for $126. Movies (at $14 each) are
still your next best alternative. What is the opportunity cost
of the show?
9 movies
Marginalist Principle definition.
Any policy should be carried out as long as the marginal benefit exceeds the marginal cost.
If a scare resource has more than one use what would the Marginalist Principle suggest?
It should be divided among it’s potential uses such that the marginal benefits are equal.
Draw a graph of Marginalism applied to budgets
Two mirrored graphs where MB of A and MB of B intersect at point Q*, X axis is total budget divided by spending on B and Spending on A. Y axis is dollars. See photo album on phone for references
What is the paradox of value? How does it relate to the marganalist principal.
Water vs diamonds, prices are determined on marginal utility not at the unit of utility.
What is the marginalist principal? (4)
Most activities are subject to diminishing marginal benefits and rising marginal costs
Any policy should be carried out as long as the benefits>Cost
Funding should be provided up to the point where MB=MC
Scare resource = dividing up among potential uses such that MBa=MBb
Incentives & Example
Definition: When an agent’s utility is dependent on some action or outcome
Incentives: people do more of something that is rewarded and less of something that is penalized
An example of incentive effect
The demand curve, as an item gets more expensive people buy less of it
What is a problem with incentives and regulations?
They can lead to unintended consequences, or that people can adjust their behaviour to avoid the intended affect of the regulations
Limitations of financial incentives
Can lead out intrinsic motivations
The Invisible Hand
The public interest is promoted when entrepreneurs are acting in their own self-gain by creating high value products
What were Adam Smith’s Conclusions? (3)
- Very Little role for government intervention in competitive business
- Why can’t the private sector do it?
- Government intervention is needed to reduce monopoly power and provide public goods
What is the first welfare theorem?
Under perfect competition, markets achieve Pareto efficiency.
What is “perfect competition”? (3)
- Prices are set by the market (No one has the power to “set prices”)
- Entry of new firms (or exit of unprofitable firms) drives profits to zero.
- Buyers and sellers have all relevant information.
Efficiency
The general meaning of efficiency is the absence of waste, i.e. “getting the most out of what you put in”
What are the two kinds of efficiencies?
- Is a given level of output being produced at lowest input usage (and therefore lowest cost)? If yes, then we have “management efficiency”
or“production efficiency.” - Is the appropriate amount of each good being produced? If yes then we have “allocational” or “Pareto efficiency.”
Economists have given much more emphasis to allocational (or Pareto) efficiency than management efficiency. Why?
The assumption was that market competition would be enough to ensure that most firms minimize costs & the ones who don’t manage efficiently go out of business
a Harvard economist, argued in 1966 that there were many examples where management efficiency was NOT achieved. He called this what?
X-inefficiency
What are the two applications of Pareto Efficiency?
Markets and goods
Explain how markets and goods can achieve Pareto Efficiency?
Goods: allocated efficiently
Markets: no market failure & no deadweight loss
What is Pareto (Allocational) Efficiency?
Pareto efficiency is attained when it is impossible to re-allocate the resources among a group of people in such a way as to make at least one person better off without making anybody else worse off.
There is no dead weight loss
What is a Pareto improvement
A Pareto improvement occurs when at least one person is made better off while no one is made worse off.
Potential Pareto-improvement
A potential Pareto-improvement is said to exist if it a re-allocation of resources allows those individuals who are net gainers to fully compensate the net losers, and still be better off.
There are three people with respective utilities:
Xavier = 10 Yong = 70 Zac = 200
Following a policy implementation their utilities are:
Xavier = 20 Yong = 80 Zac = 200
What describes this policy?
Pareto improvement
There are three people with respective utilities:
Xavier = 10 Yong = 70 Zac = 200
Following a policy implementation their utilities are:
Xavier = 20 Yong = 80 Zac = 185
What describes this policy?
Potential Pareto improvement, increase of welfare by 20 pts and a decrease of 15pts
Pareto Efficiency in Markets as shown on a graph
Supply = MC and Demand = MB and the intersection of the two is the Pareto efficient point
Dead Weight Loss in relation to Pareto Efficiency
DWL is the term we use to measure the deviation from Pareto efficiency.
DWL is what?
DWL is “wasteful” because it means “money was left on the table.” Mutually beneficial transactions were not realized.
Benevolent Social Planners
They try to maximize social welfare.
what is the relationship between social welfare and Pareto optimal allocations?
- Social welfare is the sum of everyone’s utility
- A Pareto improvement must increase social welfare, but a net increase in social welfare isn’t necessarily a Pareto improvement
- Given many different Pareto improvements, we could chose the one that maximizes social welfare
Game
consists of players, actions and pay-offs