Basic Legal Concepts Flashcards
Diversity jurisdiction
$75K and different states
Summary Judgement Standard (Rule 56)
No material disputes of fact; case can be decided as a matter of law.
Ninth Amendment
The people retain all rights not enumerated in the constitution
Tenth Amendment
Those powers not given to the federal government remain with the states or the people.
Seventh Amendment
Codifies the right to jury trial in civil cases
Third Amendment
No quartering of soldiers without consent
Where does standing requirement come from?
Article III cases and controversies rule
Where does venue requirement come from?
Article III venue provision and statutes congress enacted
Areas where originalism has been applied
Second Amendment (Heller, Bruen)
Confrontation Clause (Crawford)
Establishment Clause (1A) (recognized in Kennedy)
Judicial Activism
Where a judge decides a case based on
1. Personal preferences or
2. Issues beyond the scope of the case
Neither is appropriate
Formulation of strict scrutiny
Is the law narrowly tailored to achieve a compelling governmental interest?
Formulation of intermediate scrutiny
Is the law substantially related to the achievement of an important governmental interest?
Religious Freedom Restoration Act
Prohibits federal government from taking action that substantially burdens the exercise of religion - even in a law of general application - unless it is the least restrictive means of serving a compelling government interest.
1st Amendment Free Exercise Clause
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.
Contexts in which strict scrutiny is applied
- burdens on free exercise of religion (1A) where a law is not neutral and generally applicable (or context shows motivated by religious animus)
- burdens on free speech (1A)
- discrimination based on suspect classes (race, alienage, national origin, religion) under equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment.
Situations where strict liability applies
Strict liability is where a defendant may be liable without a showing of mens rea - where consequences of an action are so grave we want to discourage entirely. Products liability, animal bites, ultra hazardous activities.
Article I of the Constitution
Establishes Congress, power of taxation
Article II of the constitution
Establishes the Executive Branch, gives President the treaty power and includes take-care clause.
Article III of the constitution
Establishes the judicial branch, includes cases or controversies requirement
Article IV of the Constitution
Establishes federalism - states must give full faith and credit to the acts of other states and federal government.
Article V of the Constitution
Gives method for adopting amendments, including 3/4 of state legislatures ratifying or 2/3 of states proposing.
Article VI of the Constitution
Supremacy Clause (also Establishes validity of all debts against the United States)
Article VII of the Constitution
Makes the Constitution effective on ratification of the nine states
Dormant Commerce Clause
Limits states’ authority to enact legislation that may impact interstate commerce even though the commerce clause only technically gives Congress the power to pass federal laws.
Originalism
Looking to the general public understanding at the time of enactment
Fed. R. Civ. P. 65
Provides for the issuance of injunctions and temporary restraining orders
Stay vs. injunction
A stay preserves the judicial status quo, whereas an injunction is an order compelling a person to carry out, or refrain from carrying out, a specific action.
Political Question Doctrine
The theory that a court should decline to act when a charged question is pending before a legislative body.
Pullman Abstention
Where a federal court abstains from deciding a question because it turns on state law and the state courts need to be given a chance to decide it.
Younger abstention
Where federal courts abstain from deciding a case where its decision may impact proceedings that are currently pending in state court.
Burford Abstention
Where federal courts defer to state courts to resolve state agency questions.
Rooker-Feldman Doctrine
While federal courts may review the constitutionality of state-promulgated statutes and rules, they DO NOT review state Supreme Court decisions on them. That power is reserved for the Supreme Court. Do not sit as a kind of super Supreme Court over state court decisions.
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act
Employers must accommodate employees’ religious practices unless doing so would impose “undue hardship.”
How has the Supreme Court defined a fundamental right?
A right that is so “deeply rooted in our nation’s history and tradition” and “implicit in our conception of ordered liberty” that it should be beyond the reach of the political process. Eg free speech, right to trial by jury. (Washington v. Glucksberg)