Astronomy: Orbital Motion (Unit 3) Flashcards
Who was Aristotle?
Aristotle was a scientists and philosopher, who lived from 384 B.C. to 322 B.C.
What is Aristotle credited for?
Aristotle is credited for using logical arguments to prove that Earth is round. Aristotle also used logical arguments to demonstrate, incorrectly, that the Earth is at the center of the solar system, with the sun and the planets revolving around it. This is a geocentric model of the solar system
Why did no one question Aristotle’s geocentric model?
Because he was so respected
Geocentric Definition
Centered on Earth
According to Aristotle, where were the sun and planets located?
According to Aristotle, the Earth was at the center of the solar system, and the sun and planets were fixed to a crystalline sphere, each nested within another
What was correct about Aristotle’s model? Where were the stars located in his model?
In Aristotle’s model, the order of the planets was correct, with the notable exception that Aristotle had placed the sun’s orbit between that of Venus and Mars. The model included an outermost sphere that held the stars in place
What were Aristotle’s arguments for the validity of his model?
Aristotle’s arguments in favor of the geocentric model made sense at the time. He argued that if Earth were traveling around the sun, the change in location would affect the appearance of the stars. After moving to the other side of the sun, he argued, our angle for viewing the same stars would change. To prove this, Aristotle enlisted the help of assistants with sharp eyesight to observe stellar parallax, but no difference in the relative positions of the stars could be detected. Aristotle concluded Earth could not possibly be moving around the sun
Stellar Parallax Definition
The appearance of movement of a star as a result of the Earth moving around the sun
What is the true reason why Aristotle did not detect stellar parallax, that we now know today?
Today we understand that Aristotle did not detect Stellar Parallax because the stars were much farther away than he considered possible. It was impossible to observe the apparent motion of the stars with the aid of a telescope
What other reasons, other than lack of stellar parallax, did Aristotle have to prove the accuracy of his model?
— If Earth moved, a wind would blow constantly over the planet’s surface
— If Earth moved, when he threw a ball straight up in the air, it would always land behind him on the surface
What did Claudius Ptolemy do in 140 BCE? What was observed about the movement of the planets at the time?
Around 140 BCE, the Greek astronomer Claudius Ptolemy further developed Aristotle’s model. He built on the observations made by astronomers before him about the movements of the planets in the night sky. It had been noticed that the speed of the planets seemed to change. Against the backdrop of stars, at times planets appeared to slow down — and even go backwards — before moving forward again. Today, these motions are known to be a result of our perspective on a moving planet
What did Ptolemy add in his model to explain the planets’ appearances of slowing down and then moving forward again?
Ptolemy’s model used circles upon circles to explain this uneven movement. He proposed that the planets orbit Earth on “epicycles”. As a planet travels around the Earth, it spins around as though on a bicycle wheel. To make this model more closely match the observations of the movements of planets, Ptolemy proposed the Earth was slightly off-center with respect to the orbits of the planets
How did Ptolemy’s model, while incorrect, help astronomers?
Ptolemy’s model, while incorrect, helped astronomers for thousands of years by allowing them to predict the positions of the planets for any given hour or day
Why was the Ptolemaic model the most accurate of its time?
No other model of the motion of the sun and planets was more accurate than the Ptolemaic model. This was because the accuracy of measurements made by astronomers of the time was limited by the technology that was available to them
True or False: An Earth-centered model represents the Geocentric theory
True
Why did Ptolemy’s model stay?
Ptolemy’s model stayed since it allowed astronomers to make accurate predictions given the limitations of technology of the time
What simple instrument did Ptolemy use to observe the planets?
Ptolemy observed the planets using a simple instrument now known as Ptolemy’s ruler
What did early astronomers use to predict planetary motion?
Early astronomers used “computers” to predict planetary motion. One tool was called an astrolabe. The user adjusted circles on the tool based on the time and position of the observer on the planet, and it would indicate where in the sky a plant could be observed
What does the astrolabe consist of?
The astrolabe has two nested circles. The inner circle represents the position of a planet on its epicycle
What was an early “computer” that Ptolemy used?
The astrolabe
What was the armillary sphere?
Another tool early astronomers used was the armillary sphere, which was a set of seven nested rings. The outer rings were adjusted for the position of the viewer, and the inner rings gave the position of the planets
What was the most complex of Ptolemy’s instruments?
The armillary sphere
Why was Aristotle’s ideas appealing to the people of the time?
Aristotle’s idea of perfect circles, and his arguments for a stationary Earth, fit with religious beliefs at the time
What happened to scientific progress in Europe after the development of the geocentric model?
Scientific progress slowed in Europe during the period when the geocentric model ruled. At the same time, Arabic scholars in the East made advances in science and math