Ancillary Remedies Flashcards
Ancillary Remedies: What are they?
Remedies to enforce remedies.
Ancillary Remedies: Contempt: What does it do?
Enforces injunctions.
Ancillary Remedies: Contempt: What is it NOT?
It is NOT like the contempt seen on TV.
Ancillary Remedies: Contempt: WHAT IS IT (if not like TV):
It is Non-Summary Contempt.
Ancillary Remedies: Contempt: When is it issued?
it is issued after some proceedings.
Ancillary Remedies: Contempt: What are the 3 kinds of Non-Summary Contempt?
1) Criminal Contempt
2) Civil Coercive Contempt
3) Civil Compensatory Contempt
Ancillary Remedies: Contempt: Criminal Contempt: What does it look like?
Looks like jail time or a fine, and it is a punishment for prior failure to obey.
Ancillary Remedies: Civil Coercive Contempt: What does it look like?
it is usually a per diem fine (pay this daily until you obey); Imprisonment until they agree to obey
There is an ability to purge (ability to make it stop).
Ancillary Remedies: Civil Compensatory Contempt: What does it look like?
Looks like damages.
Ancillary Remedies: Criminal Contempt: Purpose:
Criminal punishment for past offense.
Ancillary Remedies: Civil Coercive Contempt: Purpose:
Coerce compliance with an injunction; operates prospectively to coerce behavior.
Ancillary Remedies: Civil Compensatory Contempt: Purpose:
Compensate (either with damages or restitution) for noncompliance.
Ancillary Remedies: Criminal Contempt: What does it only apply to:
It only applies to willful violations.
Ancillary Remedies: Criminal Contempt: Who can prosecute?
Criminal contempt can only be prosecuted by a non-interested party.
(A state official, not a plaintiff)
Ancillary Remedies: Criminal Contempt: Procedural Protections:
Right to a jury trial if imprisonment may be greater than 6 moths or If the fine is enough money.
Ancillary Remedies: Criminal Contempt: Collateral Bar Rule: What does it do?
Cannot attack merits or the constitutionality of the issued injunction in the contempt proceeding.
Ancillary Remedies: Criminal Contempt: Collateral Bar Rule: What is the answer to an unconstitutional TRO?
The answer to an unconstitutional TRO is anything other than violating it.
Ancillary Remedies: Criminal Contempt: Collateral Bar Rule: What if you want to attack merits or unconstitutionality?
If you wish to attack merits or constitutionality, then you have to go back to where the injunction was issued.
Very often this is the same judge.
Ancillary Remedies: Criminal Contempt: Collateral Bar Rule: What about civil compensatory and civil coercive?
You can attack the merits and constitutionality of civil compensatory and civil coercive contempt.
Ancillary Remedies: Criminal Contempt: Collateral Bar Rule: Any exceptions to the rule?
The only (MAYBE) exception is if the violation is one which is transparently valid.
Ancillary Remedies: What if a client wants to violate an injunction?
Do not be passive or encourage it.
Ancillary Remedies: Criminal Contempt: What CAN be argued at a criminal contempt hearing?
Argue that:
-The trial court blatantly lacks jurisdiction (difficult).
-Did not have notice of the injunction, therefore the defendant is not bound by the injunction.
-Problems with the language of the injunction being too vague or unclear.
-The violation was not willful (which is a requirement of criminal contempt).
Ancillary Remedies: Civil Compensatory Contempt: What is it?
Compensation (damages/restitution) for plaintiff for damages caused by non-compliance.
Note the timeframe—the injunction is in effect, and the harm is not doing something—how long determines the compensation.
Ancillary Remedies: Civil Compensatory Contempt: Simplified Calculation:
(Looks like damages)
The money is based on plaintiff’s losses or defendant’s gain (restitution).
Ancillary Remedies: Civil Compensatory Contempt: What type of violations does it apply for?
Applies to inadvertent violations, and willful violations.