anarchism utopian criticisms

Question 1

crtiticsm of proudhons attempt to reconcile collectivism and individualism

Answer 1

the collectivst aspect of the federalist assmemlises s settlign disputes clearly will undermine the individuaslit autonomous power to make thier own decisions

Question 2

crticism of mutualism. shell of state

Answer 2

proudhon aruges that liberty woudl exisits in the shell of the state but with safeguards like federal assmeblies
it is ahard to see hwo this wont see the re-emergence of the state

Question 3

crticism of mutual aid

Answer 3

his theory is unscienfitic
firstly there is little evidence o suggest mutual aid in the middle ages and the only evidence that he used was stuff that fit his hypotheiss diregading clear evdience that disporved it

Question 4

criticsm of egosism and society

Answer 4

stirners arguemnt that this dissolution of teh satte will lead to be poeple being atomisitic andleaving eachther alone only focused on their wone interests is crtiicsed by woodcock for being dillusional, it is hard to see how a society like this wont descend into complete chaos

Question 5

criticsm of mutual aid that society will be automoatically colelctive

Answer 5

fails to consdier that the generations of psycological conditioning form the state making people be selfish could make humasn continute to act like this even with the corrupting forces of its natures dissaprearing