all questions Flashcards
True or False - The Lochner Era was a 40 year period of time in which the US Supreme Court struck down nearly 200 federal and state economic regulations.
True
True or False: Joe Lochner tried to avoid running afoul of the Bake Shop Act by making all of his employees partial owners of his bakery
False
True or False: police powers describe the legal authority that states have to enact measures to protect the health, safety, and welfare of their citizens.
True
Fill in the blank:
“The majority opinion in Lochner held that the right of ___ is protected by the ___ prong of the Due Process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
contract, liberty
True or False: One criticism of the majority opinion in Lochner is that is created a fundamental, unenumerated right.
True
Which of the following factors contributed to the pass of New York’s Bake Shop Act?
Public exposés revealing the unsanitary conditions in bakeries
Lobbying by the Journeyman Bakers union for better working conditions and shorter hours.
Justice Pekham’s majority opinion in Lochner, holding that the due process clause of the 14th amendment protects the right to contract.
New York legislators’ belief that employees and employers should have the right to contract.
- Public exposes revealing the unsanitary conditions in bakeries.
- Lobbying by the Journeyman Bakers union for betting working conditions and shorter hours.
Who said “The Supreme Court’s decision in Holden v. Hardy, upholding a maximum-hours law on miners, does not apply to the facts in the Lochner case because bakers do not work in an occupation that endangers their health..”
Justice Peckham’s Majority Opinion
Who said “There is a real and substantial relationship between the “means” employed by the state (i.e., the Bake Shop Act) and the “end” the legislation sought to accomplish (i.e., protection of health).”
Justice Harlan’s Dissenting Opinion
Who said “The Constitution does not embody a particular economic theory”
Justice Holme’s Dissenting Opinion
True or False: The right to contract is a federal right granted by the Privileges or Immunities clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
False
Which argument does Justice Holmes’ make in his dissent in Lochner?
The 14th Amendment Equal Protection clause is violated when employees and employers have unequal bargaining power with regard to labor contracts.
A reasonable person would think that limiting the hours of employees in bakeries is legitimately related to public health.
The Constitution protects the right of employees to work on Sunday.
The majority opinion adopts the economic theory of labor that was advanced by the bakers’ union.
A reasonable person would think that limiting the hours of employees in bakeries is legitimately related to public health.
True or False: Griswold v. Connecticut struck down Connecticut’s contraceptive statute on the grounds that it violated a right to privacy guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment’s Due Process Clause.
False
True or False: In Whole Women’s Health v. Hellerstedt and in June Medical Services v. Russo, the court added a proportionality element to the undue burden standard, which required it to weigh the benefits of the state action against its costs.
True
Who said in Griswold: “The right of privacy emanates from the penumbras of the Bill of Rights”?
Justice Douglas
Who said in Griswold: “The ninth amendment provides strong textual support for a right to privacy”?
Justice Goldberg joined by Justices Warren and Brennan
Who said in Griswold “The right to privacy is located in the liberty prong of the Fourteenth Amendment’s Due Process Clause”?
Justice Harlan
Who said in Griswold “There is not a right to privacy in the Constitution or its amendments”
Justice Black joined by Justice Stewart
True or False: In Eisenstadt v. Baird, the Court relied on the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to strike down a Massachusetts law that prohibited distribution of contraceptives to unmarried people.
True
According to the Court in Gonzales v. Carhart, which represent legitimate government interests in regulating abortion?
Safeguarding the dignity of all human life, born and unborn.
Upholding the integrity of the medical profession.
Drawing a bright line between abortion and infanticide.
None of the above
- Safeguarding the dignity of all human life, born and unborn.
- Upholding the integrity of the medical profession.
- Drawing a bright line between abortion and infanticide.
Which provisions of Pennsylvania’s abortion statute did the Court uphold in Casey?
- The informed consent requirement
- Parental notification with optional judicial bypass
- The medical emergency exception
- The 24 hour waiting period
Which provision of Pennsylvania’s abortion statute did the Court strike down in Casey?
Spousal notification
In which case does the majority opinion state that there is a right to decide whether to bear or beget a child?
Eisenstadt v. Baird
What is true with regard to the Court’s holding in Roe v. Wade?
After the first trimester, states can regulate abortion procedures and facilities as long as those regulations reasonably relate to the preservation and protection of the pregnant person’s health.
The state can prohibit abortions after viability, but it must include an exception for the life or health of the pregnant person.
The state’s interest in the potential life of the fetus becomes compelling at viability.
The state’s interest in the health of the pregnant person becomes compelling at the beginning of the first trimester.
- After the first trimester, states can regulate abortion procedures and facilities as long as those regulations reasonably relate to the preservation and protection of the pregnant person’s health.
- The state can prohibit abortions after viability but it must include an exception for the life or health of the pregnant person.
- The state’s interest in the potential life of the fetus becomes compelling at viability.
True or False, under the holding in Casey, states could ban abortion after viability if the law included an exception for the life or health of the pregnant person.
True