Aggression Flashcards
Define limbic system
Subcortical structures in the brain (including the hypothalamus and amygdala) thought to be involved in regulating emotional behaviour including aggression
Define serotonin
A neurotransmitter with widespread inhibitory effects throughout the brain. It has a key role in aggressive behaviour and regulates impulsive behaviour at normal concentrations in the OFC (Denson 2012)
Define testosterone
A hormone from the androgen group produced mainly in the Male Testes associated with aggressiveness
Summarise the research conducted by Gospic (2011)
- Study involving ultimatum game
- When responders rejected unfair monetary reward (a social provocation), activity within the amygdala increased as seen by fMRI scans
- Benzodiazepines reduced this activity of the amygdala and reduced rejection offers by 50%
- Suggests a strong link between autonomic nervous system (amygdala) and aggression
Summarise the research by Virkunnen (1994)
- Level of serotonin break down product in spinal fluid of violent and non violent offenders
- Lower levels in violent offenders, with
- Suggests less serotonin to start
- Serotonin also controls sleep patterns
- Implies lower serotonin has a link to aggression
- However, research was only correlational
AO3: Why may there be an over-reliance of the limbic system in the explanation of aggression?
- OFC may also have a rule due to its link with serotonin
- May be more effective to focus on neural connections between OFC and limbic system as suggested by Gospic
AO3: What is the evidence for increasing serotonin and decreasing aggression?
- Berman found P’s who were given a serotonin agonist paroxetine (also binds to serotonin receptors), less aggressive behaviour was seen compared to control
- Measured by playing video games and how many electric shocks were given
Summarise the research by Dolan (2011)
- Violent prisoners in maximum security prisoners displayed higher levels of aggression
- Suggests positive correlation
AO3: Why has it been argued that testosterone does not act alone?
- Carre and Mehta (2011) suggest a dual hormone hypothesis
- Cortisol is the antagonist
- Aggression is only present with high testosterone AND low cortisol levels
- Implies different hormones have different predictive values and should be taken into account
Summarise the research by Eisenegger (2009)
- P’s with testosterone made better offers than placebo
- Placebo offers actually acted more aggressively thought to be because of demand characteristics
- Suggests hormone affects sensitivity to status, and in simple animals aggression works unlike in humans
Define genetic factors
Factors that affect gene production and expression and hence may have an impact on the psychological features of a human such as intelligence and mental disorders
Define MAOA gene
The gene responsible for the activity of the enzyme monoamine oxidase in the brain. The low activity variant of this gene is associated with aggressive behaviour
Summarise research by Coccaro (1997)
- MZ 100% and DZ 50%
- Concordance rate of 50% for MZ and 19% for DZ in terms of physical acts of aggression
- Strongly suggests genetic basis for aggression
Summarise research by Rhee and Waldman (2002)
- Meta analysis of adoptees suffering from aggressive behaviour and APD
- Genetic influence accounted for 41% of variance in aggression
- Suggests genetic basis and supports twin studies
What is the role of the MAOA gene in aggression
- Codes for monoamine oxidase which breaks down serotonin in synaptic cleft leading to 5HIAA metabolite
- Less enzyme = more serotonin = more aggression
Summarise the research by Brunner (1993)
- Studied 28 males from large Dutch family who were all aggressive (rape)
- All had low MAOA levels, suggesting less serotonin broken down and hence more attaches to receptors
What did Frazzetto (2007) suggest?
- More beneficial to take an interactionist approach
- Low MAOA only caused aggression when accompanied by traumatic childhood
- Gene and environment interaction should be considered
- Supports diathesis stress model where the MAOA is the diathesis and the stress is abuse
AO3: What is the problem with the diathesis stress model in aggression research?
- Distinguish between effects of nature (MAOA) and nurture (Abuse)
- Which has more of an influence
- McDermott (2009) found provocation in a money lending game triggered aggression in low MAOA gene people
- Before, they displayed the same levels of aggressive behaviour
- Although interactionist better than bio determinism, there is still a lack of clarity of the stressor
AO3: What is the evidence for more MAOA gene and more prosocial behaviour?
- Mertins (2011) found P’s with high MAOA were more compassionate in a money lending game with fewer provocations and refusals
- Suggests link between MAOA and aggression is valid as correlations in both directions can be supported
AO3: What is the evidence for the link between MAOA and serotonin?
- Animals studies where researchers prevent MAOA expression
- Godar (2014) found when MAOA was off, mice were hyper-aggressive due to less serotonin break down so more stimulation
- Increases validity of MAOA aggression link
Define ethological explanation
An explanation that seeks to understand the innate behaviour of animals by studying them in the natural environment
Define innate releasing mechanism
A biological structure or process which is activated by an external stimulus that triggers a fixed action or pattern
Define fixed action patterns
A sequence of stereotyped pre-programmed behaviours triggered by an innate releasing mechanism
What are the adaptive functions of aggression?
- Aggression increases chance of survival as defeated animal must find other territory so more resources available
- Aggression increases social status in a hierarchy which gives special status such as mating rights
Summarise research by Pettit (1988)
- Studied groups of children
- Found they use aggressive tactics in playgrounds to assert authority and have their way
Summarise ritualistic behaviour in aggression
- A ritual is a set of behaviours
- Lorenz found little physic damage caused in animal fights in a species
- The fights end with ritual appeasement to accept defeat which ultimately inhibit aggression
- Adaptive as if every aggressive encounter ended in death, the existence of a species could be threatened so survival increased
Summarise IRM
- Built in process or structure
- Stimulus causes IRM which releases a fixed action pattern
What did Lea (1984) conclude about FAPs?
- Stereotyped and unchanging
- Universal as found in all species
- Unaffected by learning
- Ballistic as it follows an inevitable course
- Single purpose
- A response to identifiable, specific sign stimuli
Summarise the procedure of Tinbergen (1951)
- Male sticklebacks highly territorial during mating season with a red spot that develops on belly
- If another male enters their territory, a sequence of aggressive behaviours occur
- Sign stimulus that causes IRM is the red spot
- Tinbergen made different wooden models
Summarise the findings of Tinbergen (1951)
- Regardless of shape, a red spot would activate an IRM
- No red spot caused no aggression, even when the model was realistic
- Aggressive FAPs unchanged from one encounter to another and always ran its course
AO3: What is the evidence against the ethological explanation of aggression?
- Goodall (2010) found chimpanzees systematically slaughtered all members of another group
- Shows evidence for FAP running its course
- However, the chimpanzees still slaughtered when appeasement was shown
- These did not inhibit aggression and hence do not coincide with the ethological explanation
AO3: Why may FAPs be modal rather than fixed?
- Hunt (1973) provided evidence to show duration of FAP may change within individuals and within the same animal from encounter to encounter
- Suggests environmental and social factors have an influence of the course of an FAP
- Reduces validity of the universal nature FAPs as an ethological explanation of aggression