AC 4 Flashcards
types of policy
- informal policy
- formal policy
informal policy
non official ideas to prevent crime, may be imposed by informal agents of control (family)
formal policy
official ideas to prevent crime
biological theories informing policy development
- neurochemicals (diet)
- neurochemistry (drug treatment)
- surgery
- eugenics
neurochemicals
- influence brain chemistry and can be altered by diet
- foods with serotonin - salmon, tuna
- Virkkunen (1987) found violent offenders had lower levels of serotonin
- Gesch (2002) - found that supplementing prisoners diets with vitamins, minerals and fatty acids caused reduction in anti-social behaviour - up to 37% in the case of violent incidents
- vitamin B3 has been used to treat some form of schizophrenia - sometimes associated with violent behaviour
eugenics
- inheritance of genes could explain the presence of simple and complex human behavioural characteristics
- aims to improve the genetic quality of human population
- reinforces ideas of biological determinism and claims that biology had contributed towards many of the social problems throughout the 19th century.
- argued that the ‘genetically unfit’ should be prevented from breeding
- eg nazi sterilisation programme - purifying the Aryan master race, 400,000 sterilised, 70,000 killed
- Osborn and West - 40% of boys had a criminal record who father had also one compared to 12% of boys who didn’t
drug treatments
- affecting the bodys biochemical processing
- chemical castration
- alcohol abuse
- heroin addiction
chemical castration
- treating sex offenders
- SSRIS to treat OCD and control of sexual fantasies
- anti-androgen drugs which reduce testerone, stilbestrol making the user impotent
- mandatory in Poland, Russia, voluntary in Germany, France, Sweden
- in Scandinavia has reduced re-offending from 40% to >5%
alcohol abuse
- can trigger violent behaviour
- antabuse is used in aversion therapy to treat alcoholism
- prevents the body from breaking down alcohol immediately causing unpleasant ‘hangover’ symptoms if the user consumes even a small quantity
heroin addiction
- often leads to commit crime to pay for the drug
- methadone used to treat addicts
- long term alternative to prevent withdrawal symptoms
- legal, medically controlled substitute
lobotomy
- cutting connection between the frontal lobes of the brain and the thalamus
- used to treat paranoid schizophrenia and sexually motivated spontaneously violent criminals
- can have serious side effects and very few lobotomys are performed
individualistic theories informing policy development
- psychoanalysis
- behavioural modification
psychoanalysis
- based on the psychodynamic theory by Freud
- aims to access the offenders unconscious conflicts and repressed thoughts so they can be resolved
- free association - patient talks whatever on their mind, lying on a couch
psychoanalysis positive
- can cause closure - may cause them not to reoffend
psychoanalysis negative
- creates power imbalance between therapist and client that could raise ethical issues
- could recover powerful memories that were repressed
- Eysenck found only 44% of psychoanalysis patients treated for neurosis showed improvement, meaning it is unlikely to work for criminals who Eysenck argued are likely to be neurotics
behaviour modification
- focuses on how thoughts and feelings shape behaviour
- techniques to distinguish undesirable characteristics and promote desirable ones
- token economy - token given for desirable actions which is later exchanged for a treat, rewarded for desirable characteristics and punished for undesirable
behaviour modification positive
Hobbs and Holt
- token economy at boys school of delinquents
- aimed to reduce inappropriate behaviour when lining up
- boys separated into 4 cottages and told criteria for token
- all groups showed increase in desirable social behaviour expect the control group (without tokens)