#7 Caries Diagnosis Flashcards
Are caries dichotomous (as in black and white)?
No, they are a continuum from incipient to advanced.
What are common methods for caries diagnosis?
- Explorer stick (can be damaging!)
- Visual exam and gentle exploration with probe
- Bitewing radiography
What are the best conditions for a visual exam?
- clean tooth
- dry tooth
- good light
- sharp probe (light touch, stroke across surface)
- magnification?
What should you look for in a visual examination?
o frank cavitation
o decalcification (whitespot) refractive index of air >water> tooth
o opalescence (deep caries)
o discontinuities in surface
Is brown or black staining a reliable indicator of caries?
No!
What are some considerations when diagnosing caries?
- Currently caries rates are declining. This decline is decline mostly in smooth surface lesions, so there is a predominance of fissure caries.
- Accurate diagnosis of fissure caries is more difficult than smooth surface caries. Fissure cavitation is easily recognized, but incipient or early fissure caries are much more difficult.
- Caries may be slowly progressing, and may be arrested, so a measurement of progression is appropriate
What is are treatment planning considerations for caries?
- There is a spectrum of opinion on how early lesions should be managed. This ranges from:
1) highly aggressive– “exploratory” excavation & enameloplasty, seal/restore
to
2) seal deep fissures and excavate & seal/restore chalky or soft enamel
to
3) highly conservative– seal incipient decay and intact fissures
Are we overtreating caries?
To quote some important guy, “inappropriate decisions to restore teeth are frequently made, with concomitant negative resource and patient care implications.”
What is the reliability of a diagnostic test?
reliability relates to the reproducibility of measurements
For example, a group of new dental students each take a blood pressure reading on the same patient, and due to problems with their first try, they get widely varying results. These measurements are not reliable.
What is the validity of a diagnostic test?
validity is the degree to which a measurement expresses the true value
Later when they have mastered the technique, they all take a blood pressure reading on the same large adult using a small-sized cuff. They all get the same number, but since the cuff is too small, the readings are high, and the measurement is not valid.
What is the gold standard for validity in caries diagnosis?
A histologic exam, which isn’t possible in the mouth.
What metrics do we use to rate the validity of a diagnostic test such as a caries exam method?
Sensitivity and Specificity
What is sensitivity?
The proportion of people/teeth with caries who have a positive test result. How likely we are to say disease is present when it’s there.
Perfect sensitivity= 100% (no false negatives)
What is specificity?
The proportion of healthy people who have a negative test result. How likely we are to say disease is absent when it’s not there. Perfect specificity = 100% (no false positives)
How is inter-observed agreement (reliability) determined?
by measuring how often the same answer is achieved using a kappa statistical test.
Look at the table of Evidence on Diagnosis of Fissure Caries.
Okay!
T or F: Small lesions on radiographs are not likely to be cavitated.
True! We may consider trying to reverse them by conservative methods such as fluoride treatments in conjunction with a total prevention program.
T or F: Studies show decrease in viable microorganisms in lesions under intact sealants, & caries progression is significant.
False! It is negligible. Effects result from blocking nutrients from reaching bacteria within the teeth.
This is why bacterial numbers significantly decline in incompletely excavated carious dentin after sealing.
Simply sealing cavitated lesions was __% successful after 9 years.
84%
Sealed conservative amalgams were __% successful after 9 years.
97.5%