6.3 Changing Structure Of Urban Settlements Flashcards
Where is the CBD located?
- often the most centrally located point in the city + is the easiest to access thanks to transport links it has to the rest of the city
- this is because the CBD is often the oldest part of the city - sometimes the history city centre is found next to the CBD
What is the difference between commercial + retail?
- commercial refers to all profit making activities including services such as lawyers + accountants
- retail refers specifically to shops that sell goods to individual customers
- shops that provide goods for other shops are ‘trade’ stores
- both tend to be found in modern CBDs
What are the typical features of the CBD?
- most expensive land in the city - ‘Peak Land Value Intersection’ due to most desirable location because of high pedestrian numbers
- tall buildings (to maximise the rent for the land)
- high density of higher order retail (shops + stores)
- high pedestrian ‘footfall’
- traffic congestion + traffic calming measures - e.g. pedestrianised streets
- important administrative + cultural buildings e.g. govt. buildings + concert halls
- businesses/commercial offices
- banks + other financial services
- public buildings e.g. libraries
- public transport points e.g. bus stop, metro stations + taxi ranks
Why has the CBD developed how it did?
- the CBD is today at the centre of a much larger settlement, which has contributed to its development
- this is part of the positive multiplier effect (or cycle of cumulative causation) as it is both the cause + consquence of Peak Land Value Intersection
- easy to access, therefore highest land value at the PVLI + therefore high bid rent -> leading to high order services + retail can only afford it
- there is also a need to maximise profits, leading to internal zoning (clustering)
What are the key characteristic features of the CBD?
- multi-storey development - high land value forces buildings to grow upwards
- concentration of retailing - high levels of accessibility attract shops with a high range, such as department stores in the most central areas - where as specialist shops are found in less accessible areas (less central)
- concentration of public transport - convergence of bus routes
- vertical zoning - shops occupy lower floors for better accessibility + offices occupy higher floors
- functional grouping - similar shops with similar functions tend to locate together (increasing their thresholds)
- low residential population - Hugh bid rents can only be met by luxury apartments
- highest pedestrian flow - due to attraction of a variety of commercial outlets + services
- traffic restrictions are greatest - pedestrianisation
Why have some CBDs gone into decline?
- investors + businesses are attracted by peripheral sites that have good access + environments, often lower cost - also nearer to customers + workers who live in suburbs
- costs of development + upkeep of CBDs are high (business rates, rents + land cost)
- congestion reduces accessibility to CBDs
- progressive suburbanisation leads to urban sprawl; the city centre might be miles away
- rise in car ownership leads to increased personal mobility + the rise of ‘leisure’ shopping
- planning policies can encourage urban expansion + provide ‘out of town’ developments
- city councils determined to attract new industry/investment offer greenfield sites for development
Problems in the CBD when in decline?
- vacant premises - online shopping so lack of pedestrians
- run down - lack of investment, needs redevelopment
- land intensively used - no room for expansion —> leads to high land costs
- traffic congestion - impacts air quality
What is bid rent?
- refers to the price of the land
- the more the land is desirable, the more competition there is -> more competition mean businesses need to bid more money to beat the others
What is Alonso’s bid rent theory?
- based on the idea that land at the centre of the city is more expensive to rent/buy as it is more accessible so more people want it + will bid for it
- shops + offices can afford to bid for higher rents in the centre of the city than industrial or residential so they occupy the central ring
- ## residential (housing) areas are on cheaper land at the edge of the city - however Alonso did point out that sometimes you find low income groups at the centre of the city but they were in high density cramped residential buildings
What is functional zonation?
- where different land uses + activities (functions) are found concentrated together in certain parts of the urban area, with other functions not found, under-represented or excluded
- e.g. a zone of manufacturing industry or lawyer offices all near reach of each other
- despite difficulties of transport to CBD due to congestion, there are still many benefits for commerce (shops + offices) to be located in the CBD
- two main issues are retail agglomeration + functional grouping
What is an advantage of functional zonation?
similar functions clustered together - more customers as pedestrians go to a specific place for certain shops
What is a disadvantage of functional zonation?
Competition - have to reduce prices to compete with neighbouring shops that sell the same thing - risk of losing customers
What is retail agglomeration?
- occurs when retail outlets of a similar type are found in the same location - e.g. sports clothing stores on the same street or same floor in a mall
- bars + restaurants are also usually clustered together
- this is because by opening close to one another, they can hope to take customers from their competition
- the concentration of the shops will also make that part of the CBD become well known for a specific type of activity + attract more shoppers
- shops that sell the same kind of goods are likely to have the same needs - e.g. jewellery shops need large windows facing the street to entice passing shoppers + major shopping stores need large shop floors so will be located in part of town which have the right kind of buildings
What is functional grouping?
- means that related economic activities group together to be near each other - e.g. sandwich ships might be located near their customers in lawyer’s offices - lawyer offices are often located near the courthouse - the courthouse is often located near the headquarters of the city authorities
- the result is a chain of associated businesses that rely on one another
- another example - night life - nightclubs are often located near bars because the clientele will move on to the nightclub after drinking in bars
Adv to retail agglomeration + functional grouping?
- time or cost saving for the function
- aids the customer
- comparison shopping
- reduces pollution
Disadv to retail agglomeration + functional grouping?
- increased competition for businesses
- further to travel for consumers
What changes are taking place in the CBD?
- pedestrian zones have been made to make it easier + safer
- indoor shopping centres have increased, modernisation + are multifunctional spaces to meet increasing demand
- public transport has become more coordinated greener transport strategies e.g. trams, park + ride schemes, bike hire stations
- multi-storey car parks have increased - allows more space
- some areas of the city have declined + others have expanded - meaning the CBD’s location can change over time
Why are CBDs changing?
- economic -> e.g. to minimise the use of limited space, increased profits, remain competitive, develop new functions or services
- social -> e.g. to reflect new living + working patterns, for recreation
- environment -> replace outdated infrastructure, greening of urban area, reduce congestion, urban renewal
- political - prestige projects, planning decisions, 24hr city, change in governance, after conflict/terrorism
What regeneration strategies did Leicester do?
- Leicester was aiming to compete with regional retail competition from Birmingham and Nottingham and attract a certain demographic
- east of Charle street, the city centre was dominated by factories + warehouses -> converted into residential accommodation - making space for people working in new businesses
- business area created near the railway station - including the re-use lf the old police station + renovation of the Leicester Mercury Building
- £60 million Curve theatre
- made more ‘trendy’ through creative industries - Leicester Creative Business Depot - attracting a wider range of graduates helping the city to economically grow
What was the Neighbourhood Renewal strategy in Leicester
- Leicester city council has been involved in the scheme, spending in areas which show multiple deprivation
- raise the living conditions + prospects of the less privileged citizens of the city; designed to “even up” areas of multiple deprivation or disadvantaged groups - improving the overall economic status of the city
- wanting to preserve + enhance leciester’s regional position as one of the three key cities in the east
What is the urban structure?
- the arrangement of land use in urban areas - how the land is set out
- urban planners, economists and geographers have developed several models that explain when different types of people + businesses tend to exist within an urban setting
- Burgess Model, Hoyt Model, Multiple nuclei model
What does the burgess model show?
- created by socialist Ernest Burgess in 1924
- first used to explain distribution of social groups within urban areas
- according to the model, the city grows outward from a central point in a series of concentric rings
- the inner ring represents the CBD, the next ring is factories + industries, and then as you get further out you move from low class residential to high class residential
What does the Hoyt model show?
- by economist Homer Hoyt in 1939
- a sector model that proposed that a city develops in sectors instead of rings
- certain areas are more attractive for various activities - whether by chance or geographic and environmental reasons
- as the city grows + these activists flourish + expand outward, they do so in a wedge + become a sector of the city
What is the theory of the Multiple nuclei model?
- developed in 1945 by geographers
- accorded to the model a city contains more than one centre around which activities resolve - some activities are attracted to particular nodes while others try to avoid them
- e.g. a uni node will attract well-educated residents, pizzerias, bookstores - whereas an airport might attract hotels + warehouses
- other businesses might also form clusters - e.g. garages
- incompatible activities will avoid clustering in the same area - explains why heavy industry + high income housing rarely coexist in the same area
What does the multiple nuclei model show?
- CBD still exists but not always at centre of the settlement
- low residential housing tends to be in areas of cheaper land around industry
- high class residential + medium class can afford to avoid living in industrial areas so these are normally on a different side of the city
- there are areas of development outside of the main settlement around new nuclei like out of town shopping centres
Location of transport in urban areas
- as settlement grows, they often do so outwards from the centre
- as all transport routes radiate from this central point, the CBD was historically the most accessible point
- modern infrastructure (highways + railways) has changed this, but the CBD has retained its important position as the commercial central
- however historically narrow streets + large numbers of people wanting access to the CBD leads to traffic congestion - causing a decline of the CBD
Location of retailing in urban areas?
- functional zoning -> set areas of the city have set functions e.g. offices are found in the centre of the city
- retail agglomeration -> very noticeable in city centres - shops of similar functions are found in the same area
Examples of the patterns of retailing?
- complimentary shops tend to cluster due to function zoning
- within cities there will also be secondary shopping parades (shopping streets within suburbs) - shops that can’t afford the high bid rent of the CBD
- within the suburbs there will also be many corner shops that sell low order goods
Example of high order shops?
John Lewis -> high threshold -> high range
Example of a low order shop?
Convenience shop -> low threshold -> low range
What is the threshold?
The number of people needed to keep a shop open