6. The Strange Situation Flashcards
Who carried out the Strange Situation and when?
Mary Ainsworth in 1969
What type of observation is the Strange situation?
Controlled, covert, non-participant
Where was the Strange Situation study carried out and with who?
- Unfamiliar playroom with two way mirror & cameras
- 106 children from the USA
Name the behaviour categories observed in the Strange Situation
- Exploration
- Secure-base behaviour
- Stranger anxiety
- Separation anxiety
- Reunion behaviour
What are the 8 episodes of the Strange Situation and what behaviours were measured in each stage?
- Child and caregiver enter playroom
- Child encouraged to explore (exploration and secure-base behaviour)
- Stranger enters and tries to interact (Stranger anxiety)
- Caregiver leaves child and stranger (separation anxiety +stranger anxiety)
- Caregiver returns, stranger leaves (Reunion behaviour, exploration+secure base)
- Caregiver leaves child alone (separation anxiety)
- Stranger returns (stranger anxiety)
- Caregiver returns and. Reunites (reunion behaviour)
How long did each episode last?
3 minutes (unless cut short due to severe distress of the infant)
Describe the observations of a securely attached infant in the Strange Situation
- Explores happily and regularly goes back to mother
- Some discomfort when mother leaves but calms down
- Wary when stranger is present
- Greets mother positively when reunited
What are the behaviours of a securely attached child in the Strange Situation?
- Strong secure-base & exploration behaviour
- Moderate separation anxiety
- Moderate stranger anxiety
- Strong reunion behaviour
What would be observed in insecure avoidant children in the strange situation?
- Explores freely but does not seek proximity with or go back to mother
- Unconcerned with mother’s absence
- No concern when stranger present
- Uninterested when reunited with mother
What behaviours do insecure avoidant children show in the strange situation?
- Strong exploration behaviour, weak secure-base behaviour
- Little/no separation anxiety
- Little/no stranger anxiety
- No reunion behaviour
What would be observed in an insecure resistant infant in the strange situation?
- Not much exploration and seeks proximity with mother
- High separation anxiety
- High stranger anxiety
- When reunited, rejects mother even though they want her
What percentage of children were secure/insecure avoidant/insecure resistant in the USA strange situation study?
- 66% secure
- 22% insecure avoidant
- 12% insecure resistant
Evaluate the strange situation in terms of reliability
- High inter-observer reliability
- Controlled conditions and behaviour categories (standardisation)
- *Bick et. Al found 94% inter-observer reliability with same procedure
- Attachment type consistent between observers
- Reproducible so reliable
Evaluate the strange situation as culture-bound
- Procedure developed in America
- But children treated differently in different cultures
- e.g. Grossman + Grossman (1991) found German children often classified as insecure avoidant as independence is encouraged
- May be culturally biased & lack population validity
- Imposed etic
Evaluate the Strange Situation in terms of ecological validity
- Unfamiliar environment
- May produce unnatural behaviour
- e.g. some researchers found attachment behaviour stronger in lab than at home
- Reduces external/ecological validity