6) FORM OF PAYMENT - PART 1 Flashcards
what are 3 things to consider when deciding the form of payment
a) dilution (in terms of control based on shareholders, wealth of shareholders and their relative control)
b) leverage positions (changing D and E on the balance sheet)
c) optimal financing (need to try and get the lowest WACC, must consider the balance sheet)
Always consider what the form of payment does to
the balance sheet of the acquirer
7 forms of payment
1) cash
2) Script (share exchange)
3) cash underwritten share offer
4) loan stock
5) preferred shares
6) deferred payment
7) conditional payment
1) cash
cash in exchange for shares
2) Script (share exchange)
specified number of bidder shares for each target share
3) cash underwritten share offer
Bidder’s shares that may be sold for cash to institution (vendor placing) or bidder’s shareholders (vendor rights)
4) loan stock
Loan stock (debenture) (issuing new debt) in exchange for their shares
5) preferred shares
Convertible to bidder’s shares at predetermined period and rate
6) deferred payment
Payment paid in instalments, may be subject to performance
7) conditional payment
Deferred payment made if pre-specified criteria met
Exchange ratio
no. shares of the buyer’s stock to be received for each share of the target firm’s stock
Need to choose a purchase price and ER in order to avoid
earnings dilution
Maximum ER depends on
expected post-acquisition earnings growth rates of bidder and target
low growth rates lead to
earnings dilution
4 advantages of being paid cash - TARGET’S perspective
- Avoid brokerage costs
- No value uncertainty
- Protected from downside moves in acquirer’s share price
- Avoid synergy valuation risk
3 advantages of being paid scrip - TARGET’S perspective
- Benefit from upside moves in acquirer’s share price
- Benefit from better than expected realised synergy value post-deal
- Avoid capital gains tax
disadvantage of being paid cash - TARGET’S perspective
Do not benefit from upside moves in acquirer’s share price
4 disadvantages of scrip payment - TARGET’S perspective
- Will have to pay brokerage if exiting position
- Offer value implied by value of acquirer (additional uncertainty)
- Exposed to downside moves in acquirer’s share price
- Exposed to worse than expected realised synergies post-deal
3 advantages of being paid cash - ACQUIRER’S perspective
• Lower issuance cost
• Maximise depreciation tax offset
• Deter interlopers (market signal)
A really confident acquirer would be expected to pay for the acquisition with cash so that its shareholders would not have to give any of the anticipated merger gains to the acquired company’s shareholders.