5. us democracy and participation Flashcards
primary definition
- a state based election to chose a party’s candidate for presidency, it shows support for candidates amongst ordinary voters
- they are the most popular way to select a party’s nominee
caucus definition
- a series of sate based meetings to choose a party’s candidate for the presidency
- they attract unrepresentative and low turnouts
- less favoured
when did primaries first begin
- in the 1950s and 1960s, caucuses were the favoured method as it gave powerful party bosses a say in the nomination
- in states where they did hold primaries, parties often overrode the decision of the people and selected a different candidate (e.g. in 1968)
the 1968 democratic nomination
- senator Eugene McCarthy had 38.7% of the total popular vote in the primaries
- vice president Hubert Humphrey (the eventual nominee) had 2.2% of the total popular vote in the primaries
- Humphrey was selected by the party even though he had a poor showing in the primaries
- he had a bad party convention and was eventually beaten by Richard Nixon
- this led to the democrats holding the Frazen-McGovern commission, which recommended that primaries be more widespread and that parties should select a candidate based on their results
caucuses
- in 2016, the republicans held caucuses in 10 states and the democrats in 14
- however, in 2020, the democrats only held them in 4 states
- the only states that usually hold caucuses are geographically large and thinly populated, e.g. north Dakota and Nevada
- in states that hold caucuses, would be voters must physically attend the meetings to put forward their preferences
- as only the hardcore voters bother, caucuses tend to favour more ideological candidates
Bernie Sanders
- runs as a democrat but is an independent senator
- the closest thing america has to a real socialist candidate
- very liberal member of the democrat party and therefore the 2020 caucuses favoured him greatly
- came first in Nevada and North Dakota and second in Iowa and Wyoming
2020 Iowa democratic caucus
- the state introduced an app which was designed to simplify the process
- it didn’t work effectively and the result was initially delayed by three days
- democratic national convention leader was furious and demanded a recount
- some voters had not even been counted which meant the final result came out three weeks later
primaries
- held by states and so can vary greatly from place to place
- they are mainly an election to show preferences for the nomination and to be confirmed at the national party convention
- timings of primaries: mid January - June
- super Tuesday: a day usually in March) where lots of states choose to hold their primaries
- states usually try to shift them earlier in the year so their primary has more weighting on public opinion - this is called ‘frontloading’
different types of primary
- closed primary: only those who are registered member of a party can vote in these types of primary, it ensures that only loyal party members get a say
- open primary: anyone can vote in either primary and this means that cross over voting can occur
- modified primary: this means that some can register as ‘independent’ and can use this to vote in either party’s primary (New Jersey, 2020)
- primaries can also be classified according to how delegates for the party conventions are chosen; in most states, candidates win delegates to represent them proportional to the votes they get in that state’s primary - known as proportional primaries
national party convention
- NPCs meet for about 4 days during the late summer of the election year
- traditionally, the challenging party goes first
- delegates are chosen by primary or caucuses, the democrats use superdelegates
the formal functions of NPCs
- choosing the party’s presidential candidate
- choosing the VP candidate
- deciding the party platform
choosing party’s presidential candidate
- nowadays, the candidates is largely chosen by primaries and caucuses
- the last time that there was any doubt before the convention was in 1976, where Ford beat Reagan by 17 votes
choosing a VP candidate
- since and including 1984, when Walter Mondale made the announcement 4 days before the convention, the Democrats have always announced their choice before the convention
- republicans have followed suit since 1988
deciding the party platform
- more recently, parties have tended to avoid heated debates in policy issues at their conventions
- the media often portrays such debates as evidence of a divided party
- the party platform is now put together by the platform committee under the direction of the party’s national committee
- the platform committee holds hearings around the Jan-June of the election year
- in 2020, the democrats had around 1,600 listening sessions in all 50 states in which 30,000 participated
- the republicans invited visitors to their website to share thoughts
post convention bounce
- the increase in popular support for a candidate between immediately before and after the convention
- e.g. 2000, Al Gore - +8% PCB
informal functions of NPCs
are now significantly more significant
- promoting party unity
- enthusing the ordinary voters
- enthusing the party faithful
- give future nominees a platform to impress
promoting party unity
- the convention gives a prime opportunity for the president and vp candidates to appear unified before the people, following their opposition in the primaries
- 2016 convention was not particularly successful at this, as many prominent Republicans refused to endorse Trump as the presidential candidate
- Ted Cruz, Trump’s main rival in the primary, refused to endorse Trump as nominee, instead telling party members to ‘vote your conscience’ instead of ‘vote for Trump’
enthusing the party faithful
- the convention provides a prime opportunity to enthuse the party faithful through speeches and appearances to help entice them to help with the vast amount of work required in running the campaign
- an example of this was Michelle Obama’s speech at the 2020 democrat convention
enthusing the ordinary voters
- as ordinary voters are not present in the convention hall, they must be enthused over the television
- many voters will have paid little, if any, attention to the primaries, so the convention may be many voters’ first serious look at the candidates and their policies
national party conventions are still important
- public announcement is an important function
- introduce potential candidates for future years, e.g. Obama 2004.
- enthuses ordinary voters and increases participation / interest in the election
- strengthens party unity which acts as good PR
national party convention are no longer important
- the vp candidate is now decided and announced before the convention
- party platform is not as important in America – Trump didn’t change his for 2020
- party unity/affiliation/importance is weaker than in the UK, the concept of a ‘national party’ is a strange
- more style over substance – fail to perform their traditional functions
- TV viewership is declining
from party conventions to election day
- the campaign intensifies
- TV and social media are used primarily
- rallies are held in potential ‘swing states’ identified in 2020 as Wisconsin, Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Georgia, Florida, Arizona
- televised presidential debate and vp debate
- election day is the Tuesday after the first Monday of November
- polls open in every state and Washington DC until 7pm, the count can take a while
the electoral college
- the electoral college is an institution created by the founding fathers to elect the president and the vice president indirectly
- it was thought out to avoid the ‘tyranny of the majority’
- 538 electors in total - 435 (house members) + 100 (senators) + 3 (DC)
- Wyoming has 3 electors, the minimum number, whilst California has 55; this is reviewed every 10 years following federal census
- Washington DC has 3 electors
- 270 EC votes needed to win, therefore it is the electoral college votes not the popular vote that wins office
- in all but 2 states, the winner takes all, however this rule is not in the constitution as it is purely a convention that developed in the 19th century
- Maine and Nebraska are the exceptions where they split their votes between popular winner and the winner in each district
- if no candidate gets more than 270 votes, then the president is elected by the house of representatives
- each state would have one vote and would need an absolute majority (26/50)
- each state sends their votes to the vp, who announces the result to a joint session of congress (this was the moment of the infamous 2021 capitol building storming)
the electoral college is undemocratic
- near impossible for 3rd parties to win as they usually have more spread out sporadic support and therefore get no EC votes, especially as 48/50 states use a plurality system of distribution - e.g. Perot (a 3rd party independent candidate) won 18% of the vote in 1992 and got 0 EC votes because no single state voted for him - reduces voter choice, often making people vote tactically, views go unrepresented
- EC overrepresents voters in smaller states - Wyoming has 1 elector for every 195,000 people in the state population, whereas California has 1 elector for every 719,000 people
- winner takes all, the opposition has a complete loss in representation - in 2000, Bush (50,456,582 - 271) V. Gore (50,996,582 - 267) - Bush still became president despite loosing the popular vote