5 Torts involving land Flashcards
Trespass to land - defences
- License and consent
Robson v Hallett - Lawful Authority
Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984
Access to Neighbouring Land Act 1992 - Necessity
Rigby v Chief Constable of Northamptonshire
Elements of trespass to land
- Land
Is the soil, surface of the soil, any building fixed to the surface and the airspace above the land that is needed for normal use and enjoyment. - Interference with possession of land
- Direct interference
Distinction between trespass and nuisance. Trespass requires sth directly entering the land. - Intentional interference
League Against Cruel Sports v Scott
Some level of carelessness is sufficient
Occupiers Liability - OLA 1957
- Def. Occupier
S. 1 (2) OLA 1957 - reference to common law
Wheat v Lacon & Co ltd - sufficient degree of control
2. Occupier of what S 1(3) - fixed of moveable structure
- Visitor
Wheat v Leacon & Co ltd- anyone with permission to be there
4. Duty owed S. 2 (2) Duty depends on: a. Nature of danger b. length or time danger was in existence c. Steps necessary to remove danger d. Likelihood of injury being caused
- Children
Special precautions to be taken where children are concerned.
OLA 1957 s2(3)a
Jolley v LBC - Defences
Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977
Cannot exclude liability for death and personal injury for businesses
OLA 1984
Duty owed to others than visitors
S. 1(3)
Swain v Natui Ram Puri
Danger or risk must be obvious for duty to arise
OLA 1984 - defences
- Volenti
Darby v National Trust
Risk was obvious to claimant, therefore no liability - No express provisions excluding liability in OLA 1984
- OLA 1984 s 2 modifies Unfair Contract Terms act 1977
Private Nuisance definition
The unlawful interference with a person’s use or enjoyment of land, or some other’s right over, or in connection with it.
Private Nuisance defendant, claimant
- Claimant
Has to have interest in land affected by defendant’s unreasonable use
Hunter v Canary Wharf ltd - Defendant
Those who occupy land on which nuisance originates
Private Nuisance - Elements
Unlawful interference
- Unlawful interference
Hunter v Canary Wharf ltd
a. Interference by encroachment
b. interference by direct physical injury to neighbour’s land
c. Interference with a neighbour’s quiet enjoyment of his land
Private nuisance - elements
Unreasonableness of interference
Reasonable test
- Sensitivity
Robinson v Kilver - no liability for special sensivity - Locality
Character of the neighbourhood - Malice
Reasonable conduct of defendant can be nuisance if bad motive or malice.
Hollywood Silver Fox Farms v Emmet
Bradford Corporation v Pickles
A legal action which a person has a right to perform cannot be converted into an illegal action by an individuals motive.
Nuisance - defences
- Prescription
Sturges v Bridgman
Nuisance has been actionable for period of 20 years and claimant was aware of it.
2. Contributory negligence Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945
- Statutory Authority
- Public interest
Is not a defence, but a factor in assessing reasonablene use of land
Dennis v Ministry of Defence
Nuisance - remedies
- Abatement
- Injunction
- Damages for past interference
Ryland v Fletcher - elements
- Non natural use of land
Substance is not naturally on land
Rickards v Lothian
Transco plc v Stockport Metropolitan BC
Extraordinary unusual use required
- Accumulation of dangerous thing
Anything likely to do mischief if it escapes
Accumulation must be voluntary - Escape
Escape within and escape from control
Smith v Scott - escape from land
Ryland v Fletcher - conditions limiting the application of the rule
Transco plc v Stockport Metropolitan BC
- Claimant
Must have interest in land
Transco plc v Stockport Metropolitan BC - Kind of damage
Transco plc v Stockport
Damages for personal injuries are not recoverable - Foreseeability
Transco plc v Stockport
Damage must be foreseeable
Ryland v Fletcher - defences
- Statutory authority
- Consent of claimant
3. Default of claimant Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945 s 1
- Acts of a third party
- Operation of natural forces
6. Damage caused by fire Fire Prevention (Metropolis) Act 1774, s 86