4. Reproductive choices Flashcards
What is a reproductive choice?
- Any choice concerning the outcome of the reproductive process
- Before reproduction
- During reproduction
Unplanned pregnancy
meaning and prevalence
Unplanned
- Around 25-40% of women in Australia have had an unplanned or unwanted pregnancy
○ Half of this population continue the pregnancy
- Around 40-50% of women in Australia with an unplanned pregnancy continue it (Rowe et al 2016; Taft et al 2018)
- ‘Unplanned’ means different things to different people
Studies on unplanned pregnancies in Australia indicate contraceptive failure as primary cause
Problematic pregnancy
meaning
Problematic
- Pregnancy can be made problematic by physical causes: poor health, pre-eclampsia, cancer
- In developed countries, pregnancy usually made problematic by a much wider range of social and economic factors:
○ fear of poverty or financial hardship
○ workplace intolerance of pregnancy
○ parental and extended family rejection
○ personal fear, shame, doubts about being a competent parent
○ anxieties about educational disruption
○ lack of accessible child-care
Human embryogenesis Days 1-13
- Day 1: sperm meets egg - fertilisation
- Day 2 to6
- Day 7: blastocysts implants in the endometrium. The endo lining is hostile and serves as a screening process for any weak blastocysts body will do everything it can to continue pregnancy
- Day 8 - 22
- Day 23: start to see the placenta develop. A temporary organ, keeps both mother and foetus alive. Forms the mother’s blood supply and the foetal blood supply. Screen everything that passes between them because of different blood types etc
Fetal growth day 23 to 8 weeks (carnegie)
- Usually cannot tell pregnant until stage 23
- see diagram in notes
From 8 to 40 Weeks
see diagram in notes
When is neonatal viability in WA
- Gestational viability in WA is currently considered to be 23 -25 weeks gestation
- 2021 systematic review of neonates at 22 weeks’ gestation = 29% survival rate
- 22 -week survival rates have increased from 2000 onwards
- Earlier 2013 systematic review and meta -analysis found survival rates of <24 weeks ranging from 40 to 46%
- Very premature neonates have higher disability rates
‘radical autonomy’ on abortion
‘radical autonomy’:
- only a pregnant person should have the right to decide to terminate, not a doctor; abortion drugs or surgical abortion on demand should be readily available for this
- See the recent WA proposal to loosen all legal restrictions on abortion until birth
‘safe, legal and rare’: on abortion
‘safe, legal and rare’:
- abortion is not the best solution, but it’s the only one for some people, and should be managed carefully by law and the medical profession
- Possibly the majority opinion?
‘pro-life’: on abortion
‘pro-life’:
- abortion is a violent/male solution that sustains the patriarchy; instead, we need to reshape society to accept and support pregnancy and all pregnant people
- Increased participation of non-religious, sexually and gender diverse, disabled people in the pro-life movement
Abortion in australia
Surgical abortion
Surgical abortion
- vacuum aspiration, dilation and curettage, late-term surgery
- vacuum curettage
- up to 14 weeks
- Dilation and curettage (below)
Takes 4-5 hours in total at clinic (procedure is very short, but prep with sedation and recovery are longer)
Abortion in Australia
Medical abortion
- combination mifepristone/misoprostol
- Mifepristone:
○ blocks progesterone, which is needed to sustain a pregnancy
○ Changes the lining of the uterus -> causes the pregnancy to detach from the uterine wall
○ Softens and opens the cervix - Misoprostol:
○ causes contractions and the cervix to soften further
○ pregnancy tissue expelled from the uterus - Clinic or hospital follow-up needed for the incomplete procedure
- high risk of septicemia
- Available at private family planning clinics ($400-$1000)
- Some experimental therapeutics to reverse abortion if woman changes mind after mifepristone but before taking misoprostol
- some risk of heavy blood loss if process is stopped
- Must be done pre 9 weeks gestation
criticisms of medical abortion
Criticisms of medical abortion
- Reports of side effects, pain levels, incompletions vary significantly in the literature
- Anecdotally, distressing to see fetus when expelled
- Data is still being collected on incompletions and side-effects
○ Reported incompletion rates between 10% and 40%
○ Literature suggests that incompletion rate is higher in later gestation
- Some maternal deaths were reported – especially with poor instruction on correct use
- Medical contraindications include peanut allergy (and others)
- March 2022: UK government voted to keep self-administered medical abortion without in-person doctor consultation permanently available (COVID19 emergency measure)
- strong criticism of the policy:
medical abortions may weaken protections for sexually exploited minors or other women who are manipulated or coerced into abortion
late-term abortion
Late-term abortion
- Rare (less than 1% of all terminations in Australia)
- Surgical/high intervention multi-stage and multi-day process:
○ injection to stop foetus’s heart (feticide)
○ evacuation via labour or surgical extraction
○ feticide is practised to reduce the risk of live birth
○ survival rates of live births post-abortion are very low
- Provided at public hospitals like KEMH - all post 20-week abortions performed at KEMH are managed as a perinatal loss through the Perinatal Loss Service
- One private facility in Australia: MSI branch just outside Melbourne
- 2005 to 2015: 8154 Medicare-rebated late term private procedures at +13 weeks
data on abortion in australia
who
how many
risk factors
- Varying estimates of around 70,000 – 90,000 abortions a year in Australia (public and private health care)
- Estimated 1 in 3 or 4 women will have a termination by age 45
- Most commonly women aged 20-29 but also uptick in later age groups
- Risk factors in the literature for adverse psychological effects are consistently identified as:
○ perceptions of stigma
○ need for secrecy
○ low or anticipated social support for the abortion decision
○ prior history of mental health problems
○ ambivalence about the decision - belief that an abortion conflicts with personal values