3.6 Government Intervention Flashcards
Which 5 elements of the firm does government intervention have an impact on
Prices
Profits
Quality
Choice
Efficiency
What are the aims of competition law?
In a truly competitive market, consumers benefit from price competition, greater product development, improved product specifications and better quality of service between competitors.
Which types of behaviour does UK competition law seek to prevent?
- competitors likely to restrict competition
- non-competitors likely to restrict competition (supplier/consumer - monopsony power link)
- prohibiting abusive practices with those with high market power
- when a market doesn’t appear to be functioning effectively
- prohibiting/modifying mergers that are likely to restrict competition
- preventing the grant of a subsidy which is likely to restrict competition
State the role of the regulator in competition law
The regulator is the industry specific specialist with extensive knowledge who work alongside the CMA.
What are the penalties for infringement of UK competition law
5 year imprisonment
Unlimited fines
Directors are disqualified from any director role for 15 years
contracts will become void and unenforceable
Which actions (investigations) can the CMA take against infringement of UK competition law
Dawn raids: unannounced
Take documents, emails and electronic file
Inspect any premises which may have information
Interview anyone who could be involved
CMA reviewing mergers conditions
EVAL link to 3.1 (Business Growth): success of a merger depends on (a) whether CMA intervenes and (b) how…
There is an automatic review if:
- The merger involves a takeover of a firm with more than £70m assets
- The mergers would create a firm with more than 25% of the market
- The merger involves a firm with an existing 25% market share
If the merger is deemed to cause a ‘significant lessening of competition’ in one or markets, it will not be allowed to proceed (CMA blocks it).
Alternatively, the merger may proceed subject to conditions such as disposal of assets (eg stores of the enlarged group), a price cap for a specified period, and a commitment to a certain amount of R&D funding.
4 ways that the government can control monopolies
Price regulation
Profit regulation
Quality standards
Performance targets
Price regulation
Draw a price cap on a graph
Draw a horitontal curve under the equilibrium line.
show new/old CS/PS
PS falls CS rises
Shortage of QD-QS
Deadweight loss
All is level 4
Define profit regulation
The government can set a maximum level of profit that can be earnt by a monopolist . A profit cap is introduced to an industry where supernormal profit is regarded as excessive, or in industries where there is little competition/collusion is possible.
Draw a graph for profit regualtion
(like limit pricing)
Initially the firm is profit maximising and making a large profit
Profit cap is put in place
the business will no longer profit max and instead choose another point to operate at
lower price, increased quantity
they will still make SNP, just less
Effect of profit regulation on price
+ price is lower so CS increases
- less retained snp, less likely to be dynamically efficient
- less attractive to new entrants
Effect of profit regulation on profit
+ because profit falls, they are more liekly to be efficient, closer to AE
- less investment, less dynamic efficiency
Effect of profit regulation on choice
+ Choice increases from Q1 to Q2
- more firms exiting the market because of the decreased SNP will mean less choice
Effect of profit regulation on efficiency
+ Closer to allocatively efficiency
+ x-efficient
- less dynamic efficiency
Define Quality Standards
A monopolist may not have an incentive to produce the highest quality goods, the govt will intervene by setting quality standards.
royal mail example
Define Performance Targets
Similar to quality standards - govt sets targets for a variety of different outputs for a firm
Effect of QS/PT on choice
+ if more efficient, more quantity, choice increases, increased labour mobility
- lack of tangible evidence of improvement