2. Ethnicity Flashcards
ETHNICITY
- refers to a social group, categorized by a distinctive way of life with set customary values
- eg. the Bendigo Karen people from the Thai-Burma border
- members of a group can claim an ethnic identity or an ethnic category may be assigned to them by others
Why do sociologists now avoid the use of race as a category I preference for ethnicity?
Race:
- a label that others assign to an individual
- a label created by those outside of an ethnic group
- based on common physical features
- assigned individuals and groups to categories that were ranked or hierarchical, maintaining patterns of power and inequality within society
Ethnicity:
- the cultural heritage that an individual identifies with
- Macionis made the following observations about the use of racial classifications (considered to be both misleading and harmful):
- the meaning and importance of race varies from place to place and over time
- societies use racial categories to rank people in a hierarchy, giving some people more money, power and prestige than others
- despite the creation of broad racial groups, scientific method has established that there are no biological ‘pure’ races
SOCIALISATION
- socialization involves processes that ensure people learn to conform to the social norms that exist within their culture
- this process enables a society to ensure conformity and the transmission of culture across generations
What are some of the factors contributing to the formation of ethnicity?
- language
- history
- religion
- ancestry
- styles of dress
- food
- customs
- While sociologists prefer to use the concept of ethnicity rather than race, it is important to note that there are some issues related to the study of ethnicity that social researchers should be aware of.
These concerns include:
- the way an ethnic group sees itself might not correspond to the way that those outside the group view them
- ethnic communities are often misrepresented as a homogeneous group
- ethnic roles are flexible and may change according to the setting
- the ‘culture’ that ethnic groups are considered to share is often viewed as being ‘traditional’ and fixed, rather than as adapting and changing over time
- research and media reporting of ethnicity tends to focus on migrant or minority groups that have highly visible customs
CULTURAL RELATIVISM
- the practice of judging another culture by its own standards
- eg. understanding the choice Muslim women make when wearing a burqa
ETHNOCENTRISM
- the practice of judging another culture by the standards of one’s own culture
- eg. judging Muslim women as oppressed when wearing the burqa
‘OTHER’
- otherness refers to the labeling of a group of people who are seen as ‘outsiders’ by the dominant culture
- it refers to the experience of exclusion felt by those considered to be outside of the center of societal values and beliefs
- it is an outcome of the various processes through which boundaries are constructed between ‘us’ and ‘them’
- eg. Anti-mosque protesters in Bendigo label Muslims as the ‘other’
HYBRIDITY (ETHNIC)
page 59
- the concept of hybridity refers to new cultural forms resulting from a mixture of two or more cultural influences
- the concept is used to describe the experience of people who have multiple ethnic identities
- eg. Greek-Australian children who have one set of cultural experiences within their homes and local communities and an entirely different identity within their schools
- eg. burqini
- it is common amongst young refugees and second or third generation migrants
- these multiple identities refer the idea that the concept of ethnicity is both temporary and evolving
- What does Stuart Hall suggest about hybridity?
Hall suggests that hybridity involves a process where individuals develop connections across cultural groups. People identify with, and choose elements of, more than one culture that then form a blended ethnic identity.
- What does Homi Bhabha suggest about hybridity?
Bhabha’s theory is informed by the experiences of second-generation migrants. He describes ethnic hybridity as being as a position of ‘in-between’. This period of ‘in-between’ relates to the shift from identification with one culture until the complete assimilation into another.
- It is important to note that not all ethnic groups are able to move freely between cultural identities.
The implication is that often a society attaches a label to an ethnic group and that group then finds it very difficult, if not impossible, to challenge.
The experience of cultural adjustment often generates conflict between young people and their families. This originates from families placing a great deal of importance on cultural maintenance, but at the same time expecting young people to succeed in mainstream society.
According to Berry, there are four common responses by young people to this pressure. They are as follows:
- assimilation - they adopt the new culture and reject the old culture
- withdrawal - they reject the new culture and preserve or exaggerate the old culture
- marginalization - reject both old and new cultures
- integration/biculturalism - maintain important aspects of their old culture while also adopting parts of their new culture
RACE
- a socially-constructed category of people who share biologically transmitted traits that members of a society consider important, such as skin colour and facial features
- eg. African race
In June 2010, there were almost six million migrants …
from over 200 countries living in Australia.
This represents 27% of the estimated total resident population of the nation.
What is the net migration rate in Australia?
6.03 migrants/1000 population
What is the spread of ethnic groups in Australia?
white - 92%
Asian - 7%
Aboriginal and other - 1%
What is the spread of religions in Australia?
Catholic - 25.8%
Anglican - 18.7%
Buddhist - 2.1%
Muslim - 1.7%
What is the spread of languages in Australia?
English - 78.5%
Chinese - 2.5%
Italian - 1.6%
What is the population of Australia?
21,766,711
What is the net migration rate of Japan?
0 migrants/1000 population
What is the spread of ethnic groups in Japan?
Japanese - 98.5%
Koreans - 0.5%
Chinese - 0.4%
What is the spread of religions in Japan?
Shintoism - 83.9%
Buddhism - 71.4%
Christian - 2%
(many people belong both Shintoism and Buddhism)
What is the spread of languages in Japan?
Japanese
What is the population of Japan?
126,475,664
What is the net migration rate of the United States of America?
4.18 migrants/1000 population
What is the spread of ethnic groups in the United States of America?
white - 79.95%
black - 12.85%
Asian - 4.43%
(many more than Australia)
What is the spread of religions in the United States of America?
Protestant - 51.3%
Roman Catholic - 23.9%
Buddhist - 0.7%
Muslim - 0.6%
What is the spread of languages in the United States of America?
English - 82.1%
Spanish - 10.7%
other Indo-European - 3.8%
What is the population of the United States of America?
313,232,044
What is a similarity of all countries being compared?
all developed countries
When was ‘Australia’s ethnic diversity compared to other developed counties’ table made?
(page 62)
July 2011
CULTURAL/ETHNIC DIVERSITY
- a society, such as Australia, which is comprised of a range of ethnic groups; multiculturalism in society
- eg. Melbourne’s population has a hugely diverse range of nationalities and ethnic groups
COMPARATIVE (METHOD) PERSPECTIVE
refers to analysis involving the similarities and differences in experiences between culture and across nations
ASSIMILATION
- the process whereby Indigenous peoples and immigrants are required to adapt to, and be absorbed by, the dominant culture
MULTICULTURALISM
- refers to a process of interaction between different cultures
- in Australian policy terms, it refers to the expectation that all members of society have the right to equal access to services and expression of their cultural identity, regardless of ethnic background
- The term ‘multiculturalism’ has a number of meanings, depending on the context in which it is being used. They are as follows:
- often used to describe the diverse cultural make-up of a society
- refers to a set of norms that uphold the right of the individual to retain and enjoy their culture
- the name given to a government policy which seeks to recognize, manage and maximize the benefits of cultural diversity
What was the White Australia Policy? When was it abolished?
- set of laws that intentionally made it difficult for non-British people to migrate to Australia
- abolished in 1973
Assimilation dates?
1947 - 1973
What were the social impacts of the Assimilation policy?
- old racism
- segregated within the workplace due to the work they had access to
- migrants heavily represented in manufacturing jobs
- migrant children did not perform as well at school as expected
- school and education
What were the economic impacts of the Assimilation policy?
- rise in population and manufacturing jobs meant stronger economy
- modernize and industrialize the country
- post war reconstruction plan
- helped migrants find work
- cheap labour by migrants
- non-British migrants had limited access to occupations and social security benefits
What were the political impacts of the Assimilation policy?
- government programs were established to help migrants find work, accommodation and to learn English
- ethnic groups were discouraged within the workplace and local communities
- focus was placed on schooling as a way of absorbing children into Australian culture
- Commonwealth established DIMIA
- The development of an integration followed by multiculturalism policy occurred because …
of the difference between the aims of assimilation and social reality.
Multiculturalism dates?
1973 - current
What are the social impacts of Multiculturalism?
- new racism
- recognize that people could be part of two cultures in the same country; allowed people to share the values of Australian democracy but also continue to celebrate their own cultural traditions
- unity; celebrates and values; just, inclusive, socially cohesive; understanding and accepting
- Cronulla Riots (2005)
- Muslim extremism
What are the economic impacts of Multicultralism?
- the Australian government welcomes the economic, trade and investment benefits which arise from our successful multicultural nation
What are the political impacts of Multiculturalism?
- One Nation Party opposes multiculturalism, argued that it threatened ‘traditional Australian culture’
- ended White Australia Policy
- Immigration Minister Al Grassby - people are a ‘Family of the Nation’
- 1978 - first official national policy of Multiculturalism
IMMIGRATION
the movement of people from one country to another on a permanent basis
What are the three key categories of immigrants in Australia?
migrants, refugees and asylum seekers
MIGRANT
a person who leaves his or her country of origin voluntarily to seek a better life for a range of personal and economic reasons
Migrants have made the choice to leave, had the chance to plan and prepare for migration and generally can return at any time.
REFUGEE
(according to the United Nations Refugee Convention)
a person who is outside their own country and is unable or unwilling to return due to a well-founded fear of being persecuted because of their race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion
If an person is found to be a refugee, what is Australia obliged to do?
Australia is obliged under international law to offer support and ensure the person is not sent back unwilling to their country of origin.
ASYLUM SEEKER
- a person who has fled their own country and has applied for recognition as a refugee under the UN Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees but whose case has yet to be determined
The majority of asylum seekers arrive in Australia with permission to enter (eg. they arrive on a visitor or student visa). Some arrive without authorization for a range of reasons (eg. lack access to documentation). No asylum seeker is illegal as it is legal to seek protection from persecution according to Australian and international law.