2. Ethics and Professionalism Flashcards
What are the four overarching ethical frameworks?
- Moral rules
- Virtue based ethics
- Metacognition
- Consequentialism
What are the two camps of moral rules?
- Moral absolutism
- Moral relativism
What is moral absolutism?
People who think that there are universal rules that apply to everyone.
What is moral relativism?
Dispute the idea that there are universal rules that all cultures ought to obey.
What are the arguments of moral relativists?
- Different cultures or different periods in history had different moral views
- What is ‘good’ depends on what a particular group of people approve of
- Relativism considers the diversity of human societies and responds to the different circumstances surrounding human acts
- Those who adhere to moral relativism would say “when in Rome, do what the Romans do”
What is virtue based ethics?
Practice that starts with the idea that we can identify what it would be like if we lived up to our own standards, and every decision we made moved us towards being the best version of ourselves.
What are the key concepts of virtue based ethics?
- Flexible approach because there are no universal ‘rules’ to apply when making a decision
- Does require you to be true to yourself and learn from role models (dead or alive)
- A virtue is a moral characteristic that a person needs to live well - what Aristotle called “a fulfilling life”
- The basis of virtue ethics decision making are simple questions such as: “If I choose to do X, will that reflect me being the best person that I can be?”
What is metacognition
Broadly, thinking about thinking.
What are the key concepts of metacognition?
- Helps us to plan, assess, and improve our thinking
- Often used in educational content to refer to the way people improve their ability to learn
- Being capable of making ethical decisions is not necessarily a natural skill, it is a practical capability that we develop with knowledge and experience
What is consequentialism?
A way of working through the consequences of a decision. The right decision is the one that achieves the best outcome (or benefit) with the least amount of harm (or cost).
What is one of the main subsets of consequentialism?
Utilitarianism, which states that an action is morally right if the consequences of that action are more favourable than unfavourable to everyone. It is about maximising human wellbeing. What decision would result in the greatest good for the greatest number of people?
What are the key concepts of consequentialism?
- A way of working through the consequences of a decision
- Tends to regard everybody’s happiness or unhappiness equally valid. Therefore, you have to consider the entire utility, rather than viewing it from a self-centred perspective
- When a person thinks that the means justify the ends
- Whether an act is right or wrong depends only on the results, or consequences, of that act
- The more good consequences an act or behaviour produces, the better or ‘more right’ that act or behaviour
- You consider all the costs and benefits before making a decision
What are the five steps of the ethical dilemma framework?
- Recognise
- Facts
- Discuss
- Act
- Review
Provide a high level overview of each of the below five steps of the ethical dilemma framework:
1. Recognise
2. Facts
3. Discuss
4. Act
5. Review
- Recognise the ethical dilemma
- Look at the facts of the situation, including what are the available options
- Talk about your chosen action
- Implement your chosen action
- Review the outcome
What are the steps involved in: Recognise the ethical dilemma?
- Write down everything you know about the issue - try to identify which points are verifiable facts, which points have an element of intuition and which ones are based on assumptions
- What are the values at stake? Pay attention to language used. Things on the surface may look to be facts but also imply whether we consider it to be “good” or “bad
- Define the issue in terms of value or ethical tensions
What are the steps involved in: Look at the facts of the situation including the available options?
- Once relevant stakeholders are identified, look at the interests each of them has
- What interests are common and what are in opposition?
- When looking at the possible actions available, you want to consider as wide a range as possible
What are the steps involved in: Talk about your chosen action?
- To ensure you make the most ethical decision, it is a good idea to take your preferred two options and “test” them by asking questions and seeking agreement from stakeholders
- Talk to others and seek their opinions
- Then step back - do you need to rethink or adjust your intended course of action?
What are the steps involved in: Make the decision and implement it?
- Are you ready to implement the course of action you think is most appropriate?
- Remain open to feedback and seek additional data or the view of others
3/ You will need to be prepared to explain not just the decision but the decision-making process to stakeholders
What are the steps involved in: Review the outcome?
- Build on your knowledge and seek further guidance as part of your review
- Reflect on the decision-making process both during and after implementation
- Share this process with others, to build the ethical capability of your peers, company or the profession more broadly
What is whistleblowing?
A whistle-blower is a person who reports information, usually gained from their employment, concerning illegal or unethical activities or misconduct within an organisation. It usually doesn’t work.
What are the six principles for effective whistleblowing programs?
- Bank executives need to demonstrate strong and visible leadership cough cough
- Bank whistle-blower policies must allow for disclosures on a range of issues from people who have a connection with the bank
- Banks are to provide clear guidelines on the reporting and investigation process
- Banks will provide support and protections for whistle-blowers
- The whistleblowing program is known, accessible, and effective training is provided
- On an ongoing basis, banks will monitor the awareness and effectiveness of a whistle-blower program