16. Peripheral Tolerance 1 Flashcards
Why are TCRs so diverse?
- It is essential for survival.
- They are diverse to detect a huge number of different things
- It protects us from lots of different pathogens.
What is the disadvantage of having diverse TCRs?
- The same mechanisms that give us diversity could make TCRs dangerous.
- The random generation of TCRs by somatic recombination could lead to TCRs that recognise self-antigens.
What do T cells need to be able to do to avoid autoimmunity?
They must be able to distinguish between self-antigens and non self antigens.
What do naive T cells that leave the thymus need to be?
- Self MHC restricted
- Non-self reactive
Why do TCRs need to be able to recognise your own MHC?
In order to recognise the peptide presented on the MHC, the T cell needs to recognise and bind a self MHC.
What happens to T cells in the thymus that are self-reactive and not self MHC restricted?
- Death by neglect for thymocytes that have no affinity to recognise self MHC.
- Negative selection is the deletion of strongly self-reactive thymocytes.
Are all self reactive thymocytes deleted in the thymus?
- No
- Central tolerance is 60-70% efficient.
- This means self-reactive thymocytes escape to the periphery.
What would happen if all weakly self reactive thymocytes were deleted?
You would be massively limiting the diversity of TCRs.
What is TCR degeneracy?
- Every T cell has a unique TCR.
- This TCR can recognise a range of antigens that all look a bit similar at different affinities.
- This means if you delete all weakly self reactive T cells you lose a lot of T cell repertoire.
- This means you cannot respond effectively to pathogens.
Does the potential for autoimmunity exist in everyone?
- Yes
- Due to self reactive T cells existing in the periphery.
What keeps peripheral self reactive T cells in check?
peripheral tolerance mechanisms
Why do some self-reactive T cells escape central tolerance?
- Low avidity self-reactive T cells routinely escape negative selection.
- Not all self-antigens are expressed in the thymus.
- Limits in thymic antigen processing can hide epitopes from T cells.
- Self-antigens are expressed at too low a concentration to induce negative selection
What is autoimmunity?
A failure in self-tolerance
Why is the prevalence of autoimmunity low?
Due to peripheral tolerance
What is peripheral tolerance?
- Mechanisms which control mature T cells in the periphery to maintain self-tolerance and prevent autoimmunity.
- Most of these mechanisms overlap in function
- Mechanisms of tolerance help distinguish between self and non-self antigens
What else does peripheral tolerance help tolerate?
- Food antigens
- Pollen
What is a problem with peripheral tolerance?
- Short peptides that are generated by antigen processing can look identical
- This means pathogen and self derived proteins can look the same.
How do T cells distinguish between self and non-self?
- They don’t distinguish self and non-self antigens at a molecular level.
- There is a complex array of signals that tell T cells how to respond.
- These normally come as environmental cues like co stimulation.
- The signals provide clues as to whether a peptide is self and if a T cell response is needed.
What are intrinsic tolerance mechanisms?
Act directly on the self-reactive T cells
What are extrinsic tolerance mechanisms?
They act indirectly via something like an APC
What does tolerance need to do overall?
Strike a balance between damping immunity enough and causing autoimmunity
What is ignorance of self-peptides?
This is the physical separation of the T cell from the antigen they are specific for.
How does ignorance of self peptides work?
- Naive T cells are excluded from non-lymphoid peripheral tissue.
- This means there is a low likelihood of a self reactive T cell from finding the antigen.
- TCR affinity could be too low to find the antigen.
- Self-antigen abundance may also be too low.
- The self-antigen is behind a physical barrier like the blood brain barrier
- The antigen could be in an area of poor lymphatic drainage so the antigen never gets presented to the T cells.
What happens if an ignorant T cell encounters its antigen?
- It is activated.
- Antigen-experienced T cells can traffic through most tissues.
- Activated T cells home to the sites of inflammation
- Once activated, self-reactive T cells are dangerous.
How do we control self-reactive T cells once the self-antigen is recognise via the TCR?
- Deletion
- Anergy
- Negative co-stimulation
What is apoptosis important for?
- T cell homeostasis and tolerance.
- Generally helps control T cell numbers.
What are the different types of apoptosis that occur in T cells?
- BIM mediate which mostly happens in the thymus.
- Fas/FasL mediated cell death that mostly happens in the periphery.
What is BIM mediated apoptosis?
Bcl-2 interacting mediator of cell death
What does activation of BIM or Fas pathway lead to?
- Caspase activation
- Cleavage of essential intracellular proteins.
- Apoptosis
What is the intrinsic method of apoptosis?
BIM
How does the BIM apoptosis pathway work?
- Developmental signal or extracellular stress.
- Activation of BIM
- release of cytochrome C from the mitochondria.
- Formation of the apoptosome with APAF1, pro-caspase 9 and cytochrome C.
- Cleavage of pro-caspase 9 then pro-caspase 3.
- Cell death
What is the extrinsic method of apoptosis?
Fas/FasL pathway
How does the Fas/FasL apoptosis pathway work?
- External signals via the engagement of the death receptor Fas with Fas Ligand.
- Formation of Fas associated death domain protein (FADD)
- Pro-caspase 8 cleavage then pro-caspase 3.
- Cell death
What does disruption of Fas/FasL cause?
- Leads to accumulation of self reactive T cells and autoimmune disease.
- Systemic autoimmunity like neutropenia, haemolytic anaemia, thrombocytopenia, and uveitis.
What humans disorder is caused by a Fas or FasL mutation?
Autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS)
What is Activation induced cell death?
- Cell death triggered by TCR engagement
- Fas-mediated apoptosis
What can induce activation induced cell death?
- High levels of self antigen
- Chronic self-antigenic stimulation
- TCR engagement without co-stimulation.
How is Fas mediated apoptosis a check and balance for T cell expansion?
- Fas is always expressed on T cells
- FasL expression is induced by TCR engagement.
- Engagement of Fas with FasL triggers formation of death-inducing signalling complex (DISC).
- This occurs at T cell activation
- If the correct signals for T cell expansion are present the Fas pathway is inhibited.
- FLIP protein inhibit caspase 8 and DISC formation
- FasL expression is downregulated by CD28 signalling.
What are immune privileged sites?
- Places in the body which are not subject to normal immune surveillance.
- They are places were damage and inflammation is too risky.
- Like the brain, testis and the eye.
Why is FasL expressed at immune-privileged sites?
- To induce apoptosis in T cells that interact with these tissues.
- this protects these sites and contributes to the privileged status.
How can dendritic cells promote T cell tolerance?
- Absence of co-stimulation with anergy.
- Negative co-stimulatory signals.
- Induction of Treg cells
What are immature dendritic cells?
- They reside in parenchymal tissues to monitor for infection or injury.
- High levels of endocytic and antigen processing activity to sample the environment.
- Low MHC expression
- Low co-stimulatory molecule expression.
How do dendritic cells change during maturation?
- They encounter microbial products/necrosis/ pro-inflammatory cytokines.
- Massively reduced endocytosis and antigen processing activity.
- High MHC expression
- High co-stimulatory molecule expression
- Traffic to lymph node to access naive T cells.
How are mature dendritic cells immunogenic?
- They are good at activating T cells due to high levels of MHC and co-stimulatory molecule expression.
- NF-kB signalling causes upregulation of MHC2, CD40, CD80/86, CRR7 and pro-inflammatory cytokines.
- They can deliver signal 1 and 2.
- They migrate to T cell areas of the lymph node
What are tolerogenic dendritic cells?
- They are a subset of dendritic cells that go through a different kind of maturation.
- They are not unique and are induced and maintained by different conditions.
- Characterised by low levels of MHC and costimulatory molecule expression.
How do tolerogenic dendritic cells arise?
- In the presence of apoptotic cells.
- So they are induced by the normal turnover of our tissues.
- Apoptotic cells don’t trigger dendritic cells in the same way as neurotic cells.
- Apoptotic cells express ligands for MerTK which triggers SOCS 1 and 3 expression
- SOCS shut down NF-kB activation so there is no up regulation of MHC2 and co-stimulation
What signals from the APC are needed for T cell activation?
Signal 1: TCR MHC2 engagement
Signal 2: Co-stimulation
Signal 3: Differentiation via cytokines
What is T cell anergy?
A state of unresponsiveness is induced in antigen-specific T cells.
What are anergic T cells?
- Potentially dangerous but not right now.
- Not proliferating
- Altered metabolism that keeps them anergic
What are anergic T cells characterised by?
- Lack of proliferation
- Significant reduction in IL-2 secretion and effector cytokine production.
- Inhibitory receptor expression
Can T cell anergy be lost?
- Yes
- It needs to be maintained by signalling from the antigen without co-stimulation.
- Anergy can be reversed and anergic cells can die.
What does T cell activation lead to?
- TCR + co-stimulation causes NFkB, NFAT, AP-1 and CREB activation.
- This activated IL-2 transcription.
What does IL-2 expression do?
- Growth factor for T cells
- Promotes CD8+ T cell memory.
- Drives IFNy and IL-4 during TH1/Th2 differentiation
Why is the expression of IL-2 tightly regulated?
- To ensure T cell expansion only occurs under the correct conditions
- This is signal 1 and signal 2.
What happens during T cell activation in the absence of co-stimulation?
- An alternative signalling pathway is triggered.
- Without co-stimulation from CD28 no AP-1 is generated.
- Without AP-1 NFAT can’t induce IL-2 expression.
- Instead, NFAT activates anergy-associated genes.
What is NFAT?
- A transcription factor
- Acts as a biological switch between anergy and activation.
How do we know NFAT is essential for anergy?
If you treat T cells with cyclosporin which inhibits NFAT cells are resistant to anergy induction.
What types of anergy-associated genes does NFAT activate?
- Inhibitors of TCR proximal signalling.
- Inhibitors of gene transcription.
What inhibitors of TCR proximal signalling are activated in anergy?
- E3 ubiquitin ligases like Cbl-b, GRAIL, itch
- Diacylglycerol kinase alpha
- These normally lead to blocked activation of Ras, ERK and JNK.
- Even if the TCR later get co-stimulation the cell remains anergic
What do E3 ubiquitin ligases do?
- Target key signalling components for degradation by the proteasome.
- Like PKC theta and PLCy-1 which inhibits downstream signalling
What does Diacylglycerol kinase a do?
- Depletes DAG to inhibit Ras activation
what inhibitors of transcription are activated in T cell anergy?
- Ikaros
- CREM
- Egr2 and Egr3
what does Ikaros do?
- It is a transcription factor that is normally expressed in naive T cells.
- It represses IL-2 production.
- Expression of Ikaros increases in anergic cells
What does CREM do?
- It is induced by TCR engagement.
- Without AP1, CREM and NFAT bind to the IL2 promoter to repress transcription.
What do Egr2 and Egr3 do?
- Increased expression in anergic cells
- Inhibits expression of il2
What happens in mice with a deletion in Egr2 and Egr3?
- They develop fatal autoimmune syndrome.
- lymphocytic infiltration of multiple organs.
- Anti-self antibodies
- High levels of T and B cell activation causing splenomegaly and super enlarged lymph nodes.
- High levels of inflammatory cytokines in serum/
How does gene expression change in mice without Egr2 and Egr3?
- Decreased SOCS1 and SOCS3 expression
- Decreased inhibition of STAT-1 and STAT-3
- Hyper activation of STAT-1 and STAT-3.
- Dysregulation of cytokine expression
- Excessive Th1 and Th17 cytokines leading to autoimmunity
What is SOCS?
Suppressor of cytokine signalling
What co-stimulatory molecules do T cells express?
- CD28
- ICOS
- CD40L
Why is co-stimulation on T cells important?
- Important for activation
- Enhances immune responses
What does CD40L do?
Gives positive signals to APCs to make them better at activating T cells.
What other molecules are expressed by T cells?
Co-inhibitory molecules
Why do T cells express co-inhibitory molecules?
- To limit T cell responses
- To reduce pathology associated with responses to self and foreign antigens.
What co-inhibitory molecules do T cells express?
- CLTA-4
- PD-1
- LAG-3
What balance do T cells need to strike?
- Between co-stimulatory and co-inhibitory to regulate responses to antigens
- If the balance isn’t right, there are implications for immunotherapy of cancer or autoimmune disease.
What can contribute to autoimmune disease?
Dysregulation of co-stimulatory and co-inhibitory molecules
What is CTLA-4?
- An inhibitory CD28 homologue
- Competitively binds to CD80/86 at higher affinities then CD28.
- CTLA-4 exists in vesicles in naive and memory cells
- Expression is up-regulated on T cell activation.
Where is CTLA-4 constitutively expressed?
on Treg cells
What is PD-1?
- An inhibitory molecule
- Expressed by activated T cells
- highly expressed by several Treg subsets
- Important for regulation of tolerance
Where are PD-1 ligand up regulated?
- Inflammatory signals causing up regulation of PD-L1 and PD-L2.
- Expressed in tissue with inflammation
What is LAG-3?
- An inhibitory CD4 homologue
- Binds to MHC2 with high affinity but away from the peptide binding groove.
- Upregulation several days after T-cell activation.
- Also expressed in NK and myeloid cells.
- Upregulated on various Treg populations and anergic cells.
- LAG-3 deficiencies accelerates Diabetes in NOD mice
What does expression of co-inhibitory molecules do in autoimmunity?
- Dampen pro-inflammatory responses.
- Limit local and systemic inflammation to promote tissue tolerance.
- Correlate with favourable clinical outcomes
- Expression of inhibitors gets down-regulated in autoimmunity
What does expression of co-inhibitory molecules do in cancer?
- Dampen anti-tumour effector functions
- Promote tumour evasion
- Correlate with poor clinical outcomes.
- Expression of inhibitors gets up-regulated in cancer.
What is pembrolizumab?
- A PD-1 blocking antibody
- It induces tumour regression in patients with metastatic melanoma.
What can blocking co-inhibitory signals do?
Release the inhibition of T cells that recognise tumour-associated antigens
What is the problem with blocking co-inhibitory molecules to treat cancer?
- It stops the inhibition on all T cells.
- This often results in immune-mediated pathologies.
- This can include things like vitiligo where T cells attack melanocytes.
What are the 4 main mechanisms of peripheral tolerance?
- Ignorance
- Deletion
- Anergy
- Co-inhibition
Extra: Can Fas activate non-apoptotic pathways?
It can induce proliferation through NF-kB signalling.
Extra: What is sFasL?
- Soluble FasL
- It is FasL cleaved off the membrane and released.
Extra: What does sFasL do?
- Can induce apoptosis in Fas+ T cells to evade immune surveillance. This has been seen in some cancers like NK cell lymphoma
- Can also inhibit apoptosis as it doesn’t oligomerise with it binds Fas in other T cells.
Extra: How can apoptotic cells promote tolerogenic dendritic cells?
Uptake of apoptotic debris can inhibit MyD88 and NF-kB mediated proinflammatory cytokine synthesis.
Extra: Why does lack of co stimulation reduce AP-1 production?
- AP-1 is made up of 2 proteins fos and jun.
- CD28, PI3K, AKT, and JNK cascade produces Jun.
- TCR induced Ras signalling induces fos.
- Without CD28 co stimulation limited AP-1 is formed