1.4 - Market failure Flashcards
Define: market failure
The failure of the market to allocate resources efficiently. Resulting in allocative inefficiency and welfare losses.
Where is the most desirable point to be in a market? (for society)
At MSC=MSB
This is called the socially optimum point
Define: externality
When the actions of consumers or producers give rise to negative or positive side-effects on third parties.
Define: positive externality
When the actions of individuals benefit third parties.
Define: negative externality
When the actions of individuals harm third parties
Define: MPC
Marginal Private Costs
Costs to producers of producing one more unit of a good
Define: MSC
Marginal Social Costs
The cost to society of producing one more unit of a good.
Define: MPB
Marginal Private Benefit
The benefits to consumers of consuming one more unit of a good.
Define: MSB
Marginal Social Benefits
The benefits to society of consuming one more unit of a good.
Define: Negative externalities of production.
Examples?
The external costs to society created by producers of a good.
E.g. a cement factory emitting smoke into the air and dumping waste into the ocean
How can you represent a negative externality of production diagrammatically?
MPC further right than MSC
How could you determine the welfare loss created by a negative externality of production?
The triangle above demand, between MSC and MPC.
On a negative externality of production diagram, compare:
- Market equilibrium consumer, producer and social surplus.
- Social equilibrium consumer, producer and social surplus.
Market equilibrium:
CS: a + b + c + d | PS: f + g + h | SS: a + b + c + d +f + g + h - e
Social equilibrium:
CS: a | PS: b + f | SS: a + b + f
What are two general ways of dealing with externalities?
- Government regulation (‘command’ approach)
- Market-based policies
How can the government use regulation limit the external costs created by a negative externality of production?
- Limit the emission of pollutants - a legal maximum.
- Limit the quantity of output by the polluting firm.
- Require polluting firms to install technologies to reduce emissions.
How could the government use market-based policies to correct a negative externality of production?
Diagrams?
- Impose a tax on the firm
- Impose a tax on the pollutants produced
- Set up a cap and trade system
Why might a government use regulation to correct negative externalities?
—
Why shouldn’t they?
+ If the social costs are direct and serious, e.g. radioactive waste
+ Easier to implement and are fixed
+ Are almost certain to have the overall desired effect
—
- They do not allow for the externality to be internalised
- They do not provide incentives to change production practices, only quantity output.
Why might a government use market-based solutions to deal with a negative externality?
+ Internalises the cost
+ Encourages changes in practices, decreasing the aspect that creates the external cost
—
- Rule-breakers may go unnoticed, or hard to detect
- Political decisions on what is the right amount of intervention
- May not have the desired effect or no effect at all.
Define: Negative externality of consumption
Examples?
The external cost to third parties created by consumers consuming a particular good.
E.g. partying with loud music through the night - disturbing neighbours. Consuming fossil fuels for petrol cars - causing pollution.
How can you represent a negative externality of consumption diagrammatically?
MPB above/further right than MSB
On a negative externality of consumption diagram, compare:
- Market equilibrium consumer, producer and social surplus.
- Social equilibrium consumer, producer and social surplus.
Market equilibrium:
CS: a + b | PS: c + d + f | SS: a + b + c + d + f - e
Social equilibrium:
CS: b + c | PS: f | SS: b + c + f