11. Directors Flashcards
When are directors caught by statutory restrictions>
Company is involved with:
- one of the directors
- one of the directors of holding company
- any person connected with the director of holding company
why must directors be held accountable?
Directors have authority to manage the company (MA 3) and delegate functions (MA 5)
Examples:
- employ individuals
- decide salaries
- enter contracts
- buy/sell prop
WIDE DELEGATED POWER MUST BE CHECKED AND REGULATED (or could lead to corrupt practices) - this is done by statute (Part 10 CA 06)
General Duties
s. 170-177 - Directors must exercise its powers in accordance with their statutory duties
(s. 172 is important)
s.172 - promote the success of the company
Range of factors to consider
- many of these already routinely considered by companies as part of good business practice following ‘enlightened shareholder value’
- s.172 is not an exhaustive list
- if conflict, advise company to consider all factors and ensure detailed board minutes to show consideration of s.172
‘enlightened shareholder value’
the “middle way” between running company to maximise shareholder interests and pluralist approach involving acting in interest of wider group of stakeholders
remedies for breach fo duty
Company has a claim against the director in law (duty is owed to the company)
s. 178 consequence of breach - same as for corresponding CL or equitable principles
- injunction
- set aside
- restoration
- damages
(Could also be grounds for termination of executive director’s service contract)
NB. EXCEPTION: S.174 statutory duties are enforceable in the same way as other FIDUCIARY duties (so remedy is usually damages)
who brings the action?
SH can bring a derivative action against the directors (for benefit of the company)
- directors are in day-to-day control and prob not inclined to cause company to bring proceedings against themselves
(in practice, SH can just remove intransigent directors and appoint more co-operative ones)
Disclosure of IDENTITY of directors and secretary
every comp must maintain a reg of both its directors and secretaries and keep register at its reg at its reg office
reg open for inspection by any member without charge (or another person for fee)
Disclosure required in notes to ANNUAL ACCOUNTS
- directors’ remuneration (salary, bonus, pension, compensation paid for loss of office)
- advances and credits and guarantees for directors by the company
- must send copy of AA to every member of the company
DISCLOSURE OF INTEREST in transactions or arrangements
if s.177 (proposed transactions/arrangements) or s.182 (existing transactions/arrangements) is satisfied
additional burden: MA 14
s.177 - interest in proposed transaction
- direct or indirect interest
- disclosed BEFORE (art. might say ‘earliest opportunity’)
- no need to make declaration if: dir not aware of interest or the transaction/arrangement, or not likely to give rise to conflict of interest, or directors know/ought to know (but do it anyway for good practice)
- if written notice rather than at meeting, notice must be sent to all directors electronically if agreed or paper
- directors can give a general notice (always interested in transaction/arrangement with X party)
DISCLOSURE does NOT ABSOLVE DIRECTOR from the need to comply with other general duties (e.g. s.177)
be pragmatic - easy to disclose so comply
s.182 – disclose interest in existing transaction or arrangement
s. 177 provisions apply equally to s.182 except:
1. disclose as soon as reasonably practicable
2. consequence = not like s.177 duty, failure is instead a criminal offence (fine)
3. applies to sole and shadow directors
interested in transaction? MA 14
Cannot vote or count in quorum for BR re: that transaction/arrangement
- unless MA 14(2), (3)
- can display with OR
- or remove permanently with SR
Disclosure of information concerning DIRECTOR’S SERVICE CONTRACTS (s.228)
at registered office
- for 1 year after after termination/expiry
- members can request copy for a fee
- non-compliance means every officer commits offence
issues that might be raised in transactions?
- General duties (esp. promote success)
- disclosure (MA14, s.172?)
- specific transaction - SPT, loan, long-term service contract
LONG TERM SERVICE CONTRACTS - general
S.188 – SH approval (by OR) may be required for any director’s service contract which is (or may be) for a guaranteed period in excess of two years (“guaranteed term”)
“Guaranteed term” - when does s.188 apply?
FROM PERSPECTIVE OF DIRECTOR - CAN THIS LAST LONGER THAN 2 YEARS?
ONE - the term continues/may continue otherwise than at the instance of the company for more than 2 years
TWO - the term cannot be terminated by the company by notice OR may only do so in specific circumstances
long term service contract - EXAM structure
- is this a guaranteed term?
- if yes - need OR
- written memorandum (setting out proposed contract incorporating the provision which relates to the term) made available to all members before resolution can be passed (for period of not less than 15 days before GM)
- GM (no point in short notice bc of 15 day inspection period)
- NB. Could get around 15 day inspection period using written resolution procedure (attach memorandum to WR)
CONSEQUENCE of breaching s.188
- provision is void to extent of the contravention
2. contract deemed to include a term entitling company to terminate it at any time by giving reasonable notice