11: Criminal Law Flashcards
What is whistleblowing?
A qualifying disclosure of information
In the public interest
To the appropriate person
Provisions:
- public interest disclosure act 1998
- ERRA 2013
Wrong doing can be employer or employee
What is a qualifying disclosure?
A disclosure of which in the reasonable belief of the worker, shows one of:
- criminal offence
- person not complying with legal obligation
- miscarriage of justice
- H&S of someone endangered
- environment damaged
- info showing above deliberately concealed
All can be past, present or future
What is a ‘reasonable belief’?
Means there must be more than an unfounded suspicion or rumour, in order for protection to be afforded to them
Define the ‘public interest’?
Not been defined by the Act!
If disclosure is not made in good faith, compensation may be reduced by 25%
Good faith - intention is honest
Who are the ‘appropriate persons’ who can obtain protection after disclosing?
Internally
Legal adviser
Minister of the crown
Prescribed person/regulator
- such as HMRC
- prescribed persons have to report annually on disclosures received
Wider
- media
- police
- MPs
- non-government regulator
When will reporting to ‘wider’ get you protection?
Only if the disclosure was not made for personal gain
And whisteblower reasonably felt they would be victimised if made internally or to prescribed person, or
They believed cover up was likely, or
Already raised matter
What makes a disclosure reasonable?
Number of factors including:
The seriousness of the matter
Whether matter is ongoing
Person to whom disclosure has been made
Any duties of confidentiality
What protection is awarded a protection disclosure?
Ensures worker cannot be subjected to ‘any detriment by any act or deliberate failure to act’ by employer as a consequence of making disclosure
Extends to indirect detriment including:
- being overlooked for promotion
- change in working practices
- changes in training of worker
Worker may get awarded damages of a just and equitable amount if gets this!
Can confidentiality clauses be in place regarding whistleblowing?
No!
Any clause that limits a workers right to make a disclosure will be void
Act does not cover subjects of The Official Secrets Act and members of the armed forces
What does prosecution need to prove with fraud? Penalty?
Prove:
- dishonestly
- intention to make a gain or cause a loss to another
Under Fraud Act 2006, which recognised the specific offence of fraud
Max penalty - 10 years imprisonment and unlimited fine
3 ways the single offence of fraud can be committed?
False representation
Failing to disclose information
Abuse of position
Also commits an offence if they make, possess or supply an ‘article’ used in fraud
What is fraud by false representation?
Individual makes false statements
of fact or law
Main a gain / cause a loss?
What is fraud by failing to disclose information?
Individual has legal duty to disclose info but doesnt
Make a gain / cause a loss
What is fraud by abuse of position?
When an individual was in the position where they were expected to safeguard the interests of another, but abuses that
Make a gain / expose other to a loss
Cyber threats identified by National Crime Agency?
Phishing
Webcam manager
File hijacker
Key logging
Screenshot manager
Ad clicked
‘Articles’ - any program or data held in electronic form
Fraud activity determined by Computer Misuse Act 1990?
Unathorised access:
Intention to commit further offences
Intent to impair online material
Damage or risk of
Making, possessing or supplying articles to facilitate above
Prison or fine
What is fraudulent trading?
Business is carried on with intent to defraud creditors
Criminal offence - under CA2006
- can be committed even while the company is a going concern
Civil liability
- only arises when the company is in liquidation
- only liquidator can apply for this
- liquidator can make individual contribute to company’s assets
Who can commit fraudulent trading?
Any person who knowingly participates in fraudulent trading
Normally directors
Penalties for fraudulent trading?
Disqualify that person from being director or involved in management of companies for up to 15 years
Criminal offence, so can also be given unlimited fine or be imprisoned for up to 10 years