1 - The Nature of Land Flashcards
What is the difference between real property and personal property?
English Law distinguishes the rules that apply to:
- Land (real property), and
- The rules that apply to every other type of property e.g., cars, books, televisions, copyrights, and shares (personal property).
What is modern land law?
Land law focuses on the rights over land, and the responsibilities and duties in land-related relationships, rather than the physical land itself.
Which statute is the foundation of modern land law?
Law and Property Act 1925 (LPA).
What does the Land Registration Act 2002 govern?
The LRA governs the system of land registration, a national record of land ownership in England and Wales.
Who manages the national record of land ownership?
HM Land Registry, a government department, manages the national record of land ownership.
In what context is the distinction between proprietary and personal rights important?
- The remedy available to someone who is deprived of their right.
- The enforceability of it against third parties. (The new owner of the land burdened by the right).
What is the difference between proprietary and personal rights?
- Proprietary: Enforceable against 3rd parties and can be enforced by an action in rem (use/possession of the land can be recovered). The holder of the right does not have to settle for damages if deprived.
- Personal: Can only be enforced by a personal action (in personam) against the person who granted the right for damages as remedy if right is breached. Only binds original parties to the right, there can be no recourse against a third party.
Whether a disputed right is capable of being recovered and enforced against a new owner of the burdened land will depend upon determining this point.
How do you tell whether a right exercised over land is proprietary?
The holder of a proprietary right in the land will have a right to occupy, use or restrict what can be done on the land in some way.
Which rights on the ‘fixed list’ have proprietary status?
- The freehold estate
- The leasehold estate
- An easement
- A mortgage
- A restrictive covenant
- An estate contract
- A beneficial interest in a trust of land
How do you find out if a piece of land is subject to a proprietary right?
Proprietary rights in land must be made apparent by registration at the Land Registry if they are to bind a purchaser of subsequent rights in the same land.
How do you determine whether a right is proprietary or personal?
The nature, creation and protection of rights in land determine if they are proprietary or personal. Not all on the fixed list always have proprietary status.
Fixed list - Is it on the list of recognised proprietary rights in land?
Nature -Does it satisfy certain substantive (definitional) characteristics for the particular proprietary right?
Creation - Has it been created/acquired in accordance with the formalities required for the right (if any)? Compliance, or otherwise, with such formalities may ultimately determine whether the right is proprietary or not.
Protection - If a right is proprietary, you need to ask if it is enforceable against a third party (ie a new owner of the burdened land). Whether it will be enforceable often depends on whether the right has been registered.
What is an example of a personal right?
For example, a homeowner runs a guesthouse and grants guests a licence to stay, and enter into a contract with the guests.
If the owner stopped the guests from staying in the guesthouse, then the guest would only be able to seek damages for breach of contract and would not be able to recover the right to stay in the guesthouse or enforce the contract against a third party owner should the house be sold.
What is an estate?
A proprietary right of possession in land.
What is a freehold estate?
The highest possible estate in land, the fee simple absolute in possesstion - Freehold. (LPA 1925, s1(1)(a)).
Fee - Capable of being inherited.
Simple - It can be inherited by any heir, including distant relatives.
Absolute - The estate is not liable to end prematurely, not determinable or subject to a condition.
In Possession - The fee simple owner has a current right to use and enjoyment of the property. Physical possession not necessary, ie a landlord.
Lasts indefinitely.
What is a leasehold estate?
Where a freeholder owner grants a lesser estate, which is of a certain duration, the estate granted is a term of years absolute (LPA 1925, s1(1)(b) LPA) commonly known as the leasehold estate.
A piece of land may be subject to one or more leases.
What is a sub-lease?
The leaseholder (tenant) may grant a lease of a lesser duration out of their own leasehold, whilst still retaining the original lease, known as a sub-lease.
This process may continue with sub-leases being granted for shorter periods by the successive sub-lessees.
What are freehold and leasehold reversions?
Freehold reversion - The residue of the estate after the granting of a lease.
Leasehold reversion - If the grantor holds the leasehold estate, the residue is known as the leasehold reversion.
This means that when the lease ends the right to physical possession of the land automatically reverts to the landlord.
What are the hierarchy of rights in possession?
Freehold
Leasehold
Sub-lease
What is a commonhold estate?
Commonhold is a type of freehold introduced by the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002.
Commonhold is an estate created out of a freehold registered estate. It is designed to meet the needs of owners of flats or apartments, or other properties where the owners are interdependent on each other, i.e., retirement homes.
There is no overall landlord. However, there is a freehold owner, that is a company called a commonhold association. The owner of each flat is a member of the association, who is responsible for maintining the communal areas of the building.
What are interests in land? / incumbrances
Proprietary rights of a more limited use.
An interest in land does not give a right to possess in the way an estate does, rather gives the interest holder the right to do something on the land, or restrict what can be done on the land.
Powerful right in the land, can be recovered (enforced in rem) and capable of enforcement against 3rd parties.
Which interests are legal in nature? (incl relevant legislation).
S1(2)(a)-(e)LPA 1925
- Mortgages
- Easements granted for a term equivalent to a freehold or leasehold estate (forever or a certain term).
- Rights of entry.
Which interests are equitable in nature? (incl relevant legislation).
S1(3) LPA 1925
- Freehold covenants.
- Estate contracts.
- Interests in a trust of land.
- Easements granted for an uncertain term.
Recognised by courts as having proprietary status. Will only take effect in equity.
What is a mortgage? (incl legislation).
LPA 1925, s1(2)(c)
A bundle of rights granted over a property by the borrower to the lender as security in exchange for a loan of money. This includes the right to possess and sell the land in the event of default in the mortgage repayments.
What is an easement? (incl legislation).
LPA 1925, s1(2)(a)
An easement is a proprietary right to use land which belongs to somebody else.
It must be granted for a term equivalent to one of the legal estates (freehold, leasehold).
What is a right of entry? (incl legislation).
LPA 1925, s1(2)(e).
Known as a forfeiture clause.
A right for a landlord to re-enter leased premises and end the leasehold estate in the event of tenant default or some other specified event occuring, or
A rentcharge owner’s right to hold the land if money owed is not paid - uncommon.
What is a restrictive covenant? (incl legislation).
LPA 1925, s1(3)
Negative in nature - A promise made which prevents a land owner from doing something on their land. E.g., a promise to only use the land for residential purposes.
What is an estate contract?
A contractual right to a legal estate, whether freehold or leasehold, resulting in an equitable right arising.
What is an interest in a trust of land?
Where the trustee holds property for the benefit of the beneficiary resulting in a split of the legal and equitable title (ownership).
The trustee(s) hold the the legal title. The beneficiary(s) hold the equitable title.
Can be the same or different people.