1. conformity Flashcards
when was Asches experiment/proceedure?
1951
what was the aim of Asch’s experiment?
- to see to the extent that people will conform to the opinions of others
what were the variables that Ash investigated?
- Group size- conformity increased with group size 31.8%
- Unanimity- a confederate which disagreed with the whole group to see if this would influence them
- Task Difficulty, conformity increased
outline Asch’s experiment?
- 123 American male participants were tested
- each participant saw two white cards with lines on them
- participants had to say which lines (A,B,C) aligned with the line on the other card
- the participants were grouped in people of 6-8 with only one person being a genuine confederate
- confederates gave incorrect scripted answers to see if participant would conform
what were the findings?
- participants agreed with confederates 36.8% of the time
what are the limitations of Asch’s procedure?
- Artificial setting, meaning demand characteristics could have been present
- Low Generalisability, as the study only involved men,
what are the limitations of Asch’s procedure?
- Artificial setting, meaning demand characteristics could have been present
- Low Generalisability, as the study only involved men,
- ethical considerations, participants were deceived
what is a strength behind Asch’s proceedure?
- Research support, Lucas et al’s research supports this, people conformed less on hard tasks
COUNTERPOINT: LUCAS ET ALS’ STUDTY FOUND CONFORMITY IS MORE COMPLEX THAN ASCH SUGGESTS DEPENDING ON DIFFERENT CIRCUMSTANCES
who suggested the types of conformity?
Kelman (1958)
list the types of conformity and their definitions
- INTERNALISATION: private and public changes of behaviour/ conformity
- IDENTIFICATION: the idea of publicly agreeing as you want to identify with the group, even if you do not always agree in private
- COMPLIANCE: public agreement, to go along with the conversation, but privately disagreeing
what is the two process theory?
Deutsch and Gerard (1955) developed this theory to explain the reasons of conformity
what are the two explanations of conformity and their meanings?
- INFORMATIONAL SOCIAL INFLUENCE: following the group as you assume they know more and are therefore right
- NORMATIVE SOCIAL INFLUENCE: failure of being socially rejected so you agree with the group to be apart of it
What is the strength for normative social influence?
- evidence that supports it as an explanation of conformity
- Asch 1951 found most felt self conscious when speaking, when writing answers down conformity dropped to 12.5%
What is the limitation of Normative social influence?
- does not predict conformity in every case
- McGhee and Teevan (1967) found students who were nAffilaitor were more likely to conform
What is the strength for informational social influence?
- Lucas et al (2006) provides evidence
- this research support proves the validity
- COUNTERPOINT that there is low res world application and that ISI AND NSI can be blurred in real life