Workshop 9: Insolvency pt. 1 - Insolvency Procedures Flashcards
**Topic: Corporate Insolvency** - Introduction to Corporate Insolvency - Formal and Informal Arrangements - Administration and receivership - Liquidation - The statutory order of priorities **Topic: Personal Insolvency** - Personal Insolvency
What are the two main formal insolvency procedures for insolvent individuals?
- Bankruptcy
- Individual voluntary arrangements (‘IVAs’)
What kind of arrangement is an IVA?
Where a debtor makes a proposal for a compromise of their liabilities with their creditors
What are the options a debtor may propose for an IVA?
The debtor
- Paying part of the contractual debt owed
- Having a longer period to pay than the contractual period
Where is the debtor’s money paid out of in an IVA?
- Income
- Business
- Assets
- Combination of the above
What are the requirements to be a Supervisor of the IVA?
A licensed insolvency practitioner must be appointed as IVA Supervisor
What are the requirements to be a Supervisor of the CVA?
A licensed insolvency practitioner must be appointed as CVA Supervisor
What is the role of the IVA Supervisor?
They supervise
- Debtor’s implementation and
- Compliance with terms of IVA
- Report to the court periodically
- Can apply to the court for directions
- HAs the right to petition for debtor’s bankruptcy subject to debtor’s failure of compliance with IVA terms
What is the general duration of an IVA?
3-5 years is common in practice
But they can last any time
What is included in the 3 steps of successfully setting up a binding IVA?
- Nominee (what the Insolvency Practitioner is known as at this stage) assists debtor with drafting proposal of compromise of liabilities and statement of their affairs
- Nominee submits report to court; whether proposal is reasonable in being approved
- Creditors approve of the proposal to become binding
What is the effect of the court granting an order when a debtor applies to the court for an interim order?
Brings about a moratorium
What is a moratorium?
A period where creditors are unable to take action to exercise their usual rights and remedies
How much value of a debtor’s debt must a creditor hold for them to vote and the proposal become binding?
At least 75%
When may a creditor’s vote of approval for a debtor’s IVA or CVA proposal be ineffective?
If more than half of the total value of creditors who are not associates of the debtors vote against it
What are the effects of an approved IVA?
- Binds debtors and their unsecured creditors
- Nominee becomes IVA Supervisor
What are some advantages of an IVA?
- Alternative to bankruptcy; avoids associated stigma and restrictions
- Binds unsecured creditors
- Moratorium available if interim order is made
What are some disadvantages of an IVA?
- May last longer than bankruptcy
- Cannot bind secured or preferential creditor without their consent
- Can be expensive
- Can be time-consuming
- Uncertainty as to whether creditors will approve
What is bankruptcy equivalent to in a business?
Liquidation
How does bankruptcy begin?
Presentation of a bankruptcy petition, by either debtor or creditor
What are the ‘grounds of petition’ for a creditor?
- The debt is a debt the debtor appears unable to pay or has no reasonable prospect of paying at the time of the presentation of the petition
- Debt owed is for an unsecured liquidated sum of over £5k
Can the debtor a creditor is petitioning for bankruptcy be domiciled or present anywhere?
No - England and Wales
What must the debtor accompany their petition with when filing for bankruptcy?
Statement of affairs
What is a ‘statement of affairs’?
Full details of assets and liabilities
What is the ‘bankrupt’ person prohibited/deprived from doing on the making of a bankruptcy order?
- Acting as director
- Being involved in management of company
- Obtaining credit of over £500 without disclosing bankruptcy
- Giving gifts
- Practising in certain professions
- Deprived of ownership of their property except for their reasonable domestic needs
What are the two ways a debtor’s inability to pay their debts evidenced?
- A statutory demand that hasn’t been satisfied within 3 weeks from service of the demand or set aside by the court
- An unsatisfied execution of a judgement or other legal process
What must be satisfied for a bankruptcy order to be made at the discretion of the courts?
Satisfaction of the petition groups and having evidence of a debtor’s inability to pay their debts
What is an immediate and automatic power of a Trustee upon the making of a bankruptcy order?
The bankrupt’s estate vests in the trustee
What does it mean when the bankrupt’s estate vests in the Trustee?
The bankrupt must give up possession/give access to assets to the Trustee
Do assets falling into the estate after the making of a bankruptcy order count as assets that must be vested to the Trustee?
Yes
What are some of the Trustee’s statutory powers following the making of a bankruptcy order?
- To sell/otherwise deal with estate assets
- Carry on bankrupt’s business
- Sell bankrupts assets
- Grant security over bankrupt’s assets
- To disclaim onerous property or contracts
Which order must the Trustee distribute money in the bankrupt’s estate?
In accordance with statutory order of priority for bankruptcies
TRUE OR FALSE
Trustee will ask creditors to prove their claims against the bankrupt
True
What must creditors who are claiming a dividend from the bankrupt’s estate provide evidence of?
Of their claim against the bankrupt to prove their claim
Which order must the Trustee pay dividends to creditors in?
In accordance with statutory order of priority
What must the Trustee do proposing to pay a dividend to creditors?
Must give notice to creditors who have proved their debts, which includes:
- Stating amount of sale proceeds received from sale of estate assets
- Any deductions that have been made from proceeds
- Amount of dividend that they can expect to receive
Who determines the amount of the creditor’s claim?
Who has the final say on the matter if the creditor does not agree with their determination?
Trustee
The court
What is the order of priority of payments for bankruptcy?
- Secured creditors
- Expenses of bankruptcy (incl. Trustee’s remuneration)
- Two tiers of preferential creditors
- Ordinary unsecured creditors
- Statutory interest
- Debts of a spouse
- Surplus payable to bankrupt
What are the bankrupt’s duties to the Trustee to enable them to carry out their functions according to s. 333 of the Insolvency Act 1986? [Paraphrased]
a) give trustee informations of his affairs
b) attend on trustee at such times
c) do all such other things that are reasonably required
What is the effect of a bankruptcy discharge?
Bankrupt is released from most of bankruptcy debts and related restrictions (e.g., acting as director etc.)
Why may the Truee apply for an order to suspend the automatic discharge of the bankrupt?
If they fail to comply with their obligation under IA 1986
What is the usual time frame of a bankrupt being discharged from bankruptcy?
After a maximum of one year
When may the bankrupt be discharged in less than a year?
If Trustee files notice stating that the bankrupt does not required investigation
or that they have conducted such investigation within the one year period
What effect does a bankruptcy restriction undertaking (BRU) have?
Same as a bankruptcy restriction order (‘BRO’) if accepted
What is the effect of a ‘bankruptcy restriction order/undertaking’?
Having the period of time whereby bankrupcry restriction extended
Why may the Secretary of State, or Trustee acting on SoS direction apply to the court for a BRO?
If the court considers it appropriate in the circumstances of the bankrupt’s behaviour/conduct
What are some examples of behaviour in Schedule 4a IA 1986 the court will take into account when ordering for a BRO or BRU?
- Failure to keep records
- Entering into preferences or transactions at an undervalue
- Fraud
- Incurring debt without reasonable expectation of being able to pay it